User blog comment:WhatZoeyhasfans/Which season do you guys thinks is better Total Drama Action or Total Drama All Stars/@comment-31556666-20131104222716

All Stars has had ups and downs so far, but it hasn't really destroyed the show as much as I think Action did. Island was so fresh and new, but Action ruined everything about characters that I used to love. It's the season that made me hate characters that I used to love like Leshawna, Geoff, Owen, and Duncan.

There was also very boring filler in the season with every second episode being a reward challenge. It's elimination was also pretty screwed up. I had lost respect for Beth since Get a Clue for her betrayal towards Lindsay, and I saw Duncan as nothing more than an unlikable jerk. Harold and Lindsay on the other hand gained so much respect from me that I had hoped that both would be the Final 2. It's even worse when Duncan won, because he didn't deserve the victory at all.

All Stars suffers from none of these problems. It may have had some bad (Moon Madness) and mediocre (You Regatta Be Kidding Me) episodes, but it hasn't made me hate characters more, or lose respect for them. Some may have acted out of character now and again, but not enough for me to hate them (except for Cameron).

I also am positive that it will have a good Final 2 with how the show conveniently gets rid of whoever I want to get eliminated, with the exception of the two times Cameron escaped elimination.

Ultimately though, All Stars reminds me of the Golden Age of the show, when it was at its best.