User blog comment:PhoenixDragonSamurai/Courtney vs Duncan: Alignment Scale/@comment-1141831-20140813205511

I think if anything Courtney has mostly held up the ranking of a Lawful Neutral character as an average; or as you said bouncing between Neutral/Lawful Evil and Lawful Neutral. She is definitely an Anti-Villain.

Duncan is a little more complex: He is, simply put, an Anti-Hero. What we must take into account is how broad the hero-villain scale categories are. The only true villains in the series are only that way in their debut season: Heather, Al, Scott, etc, then they typically fall in either Anti-Hero: Gwen, Heather or Anti-Villain: Scott, Alejandro. Duncan is a special case in that he has never held the "villain slot" or the "hero slot" He has spent his time on the show either being kind of a slimy d-bag, or just a loner who doesn't like to show how much he really cares. He is definitely an Anti-Hero in Island and an Anti-Villain Action, and I know Im gonna be flamed for this, wasnt even on the scale in WT. Him going after what will make him happy, regardless of how it effects others, doesn't move him from being an Anti-Hero...just what he is on the Alignment scale

Island Duncan was Chaotic Neutral and an Anti-Hero Action Duncan was Chaotic Neutral and an Anti-Villain World Tour Duncan was Neutral Evil (barely) and wasn't on the scale All-Stars Duncan was Chaotic Good. and an Anti-Hero

He has always been all over the place