User blog comment:CheeseBurgerGuy/TDCYOA Island Edition: Episode 3 (The Big Sleep)/@comment-24623255-20191105154643/@comment-35606925-20191105202245

While the situation you stated is kind of funny, it's not going to happen. Firstly, despite Duncan's flirtatious nature he's never flirted with a guy, so I doubt it makes sense he would be gay.

More importantly, Duncan is on the other team and is tied for the lowest affinity score. I doubt you'd be able to duffel the requirements this season, if ever.

Katie and Sadie are options though.