User blog comment:CheeseBurgerGuy/My Thoughts On Total Drama Action/@comment-28092650-20191028145511/@comment-25342388-20191030035922

"Although Sugar to me was the worse antagonist. As she barely count as one. Scarlett should have been the main or Amy (Because that story line with her sister went nowhere)"

That is why I am to this day still a little confused who the antagonist was supposed to be. Sugar just didn't really feel like a villain (mainly because she hardly did anything and the show kept having her go back and forth between being comic relief and somewhat of a legit threat) but I knew it couldn't be Amy due to her early eliminated and general villany being limited to only her sister. While having a hidden villain is a neat idea, Scarlett not doing anything but following Max around until her elimination episode makes her plot feel extremely rushed and kind of forced, so I am really hesitant to call her a main antagonist.