User blog comment:KrispyBaconator/Unpopular TD Opinions/@comment-5928665-20180923204501

I'm kicking this old blog post because I simply felt like sharing some of my controversial opinions about the show.

- TDAS Gwen is better than TDWT Gwen. Yeah, TDAS Gwen has a lot of problems but at least she felt like her own character that season. The only reason it felt like Gwen was even in TDWT was so she could be a plot device for Duncan. And TDAS was also the only season where Gwen's plot (mostly) didn't revolve around her romantic relationships, which felt refreshing.

- Duncan's only good season was TDI. His TDAS performance was his second best portrayal but it's a distant second. He was absolute garbage in both TDA and TDWT. I have enjoyed his "Dramarama" portrayal so far and find it to be the best version of the character since his debut season.

- Scott is a bad character. Fixing his flaws from TDROTI by giving him an almost completely different personality in TDAS was not good writing.

- I still despise the love triangle in TDWT. You could say it was necessary to give that season some much needed plot, but was it particularly fun to watch? Not really. For me personally, I don't derive much enjoyment out of watching a bunch of angry people who despise each other bicker endlessly for about six or so episodes. It's not exactly my idea of a good time. And it really didn't develop in any interesting ways either.

That's about it for now.