User blog comment:Epic~00/In Defense of: Duncan/@comment-25302812-20150327004239/@comment-31556666-20150327164834

Escaping one elimination in TDA honestly doesn't seem like a bad thing. It's not really Duncan's fault that there was such a stupid elimination when Lindsay is the one who voted herself. Besides, Harold technically escaped elimination in Basic Straining but that remains one of the most iconic eliminations there is. A poorly written elimination is just not something I can see that makes a character worth complaining about. That's like if someone liked Max less in PI because his elimination was poorly written.

Duncan has shown remorse for people. But why show remorse to someone who has manipulated him like that? Duncan has always been shown to be vengeful.

Even if Duncan won 1 immunity challenge, that can't just automatically make him seem like a floater. Floaters are characters who don't really contribute to the season in the long run and Duncan has contributed majorly to the show many times.