User blog comment:YoungEezy27/3rd Alternate Ending?/@comment-3573655-20141006220931/@comment-25285054-20141008020351

Uh, causing eliminations isn't enough to make a good antagonist.

Pretty sure Scarlett's plan was to escape the island and leave with the money-she's not dumb enough to just sit there and get arrested. Plus she never got arrested, she got shot out of a cannon; we don't even know where she was after that and I don't think it's hard to come up with an excuse to bring her back.

And Scarlett's potential for antagonism is immense, while Sugar being one was a bad idea from the get-go.