User blog comment:TDIfanaric/Total Drama Season Analysis/@comment-26129120-20151114193759

Total Drama: Revenge of the Island isn't realist but it isn't worse than All Stars or Pahkitew Island. The season theme just isn't good but, the characters are realist (except Staci, Mike, Cameron and Dakota after mutation), some of them are well written, especially Brick, Jo, Anne Maria and Scott, and most of them are original.

Mike is a bad character, but the most offensive scene is actually in Total Drama All Stars. If you compare how are the characters written in TDROTI and TDAS you can realize how TDAS is written worst than TDROTI.

Pahkitew Island only have few realistic and original characters, those who are realistic and original, are poorly written.

Why do you prefer TDAS and TDPI than TDROTI?