User blog comment:ThomasVeggieDramaFan/Pahkitew Island: One Year Later/@comment-26542772-20150629020913/@comment-4742462-20150629024649

I'm the exact opposite.

Pahkitew Island's cast was full of duds with only four good characters (Scarlett, Jasmine, Sky, and Ella) and Sugar was a far worse antagonist than Scott (even though I'd rather eat my foot before classifying her as a villain).

Revenge of the Island's cast was better, it's just that everyone let's their hatred for the trio completely overshadow the other characters like Brick, Dakota, Jo, and Dawn.