User blog comment:King Flurry51/If not a villain../@comment-26484129-20141203023402

This is my opinion:

In ROTI, his team would probably be winning some of the challenges, but he probably wouldn't be voted out until a little later. His conflicts wouldn't work out, unless the other person tried to do something to Scott, but he would've probably been the main pain-magnet of the season, other than Brick.

Averge ROTI Placing: 7th or 5th

In TDAS: Maybe the same thing. Maybe he could've had a friendship with Heather, or maybe a conflict with Mike or something. But then, nobody would be Courtney's 1 episode boyfriend, unless Alejandro or Duncan would, but that seems unlikely.

Average TDAS Placing: 10th, 9th, 8th

As you can see, without being an antagonist, Scott seems to be worse, and maybe wouldn't have as many interactions as he had before, because he would be getting 3rd and 4th place, but without being an antagonist, his placings in TD get worse.