Thread:Stryzzar/@comment-1037137-20141017070841/@comment-1037137-20141023005310

Yeah really, that's just total BS, my friend. When was the last time Total Drama got a professional review from well-known big name critics? At least the ones Wikipedia is probably harping for? Their editing standards cannot void what is the harsh truth about TDAS, that many fans, if not the majority of fans all agreed that it sucked on most if not all counts. And it's certainly undeniable that it has some of the sloppiest writing of any series to date. There's a reason it got burned for its blatant continuity errors. If you can't even keep your own continuity in check, then I must assume you don't even have the sense to have a proven editor on hand. Wouldn't surprise me if they didn't. And that's not even getting into the tastelessness of its humor and its horrific character treatments. Wikipedia can't undo all of that just because the cited sources are by their terms "not professional". Hopefully somebody will break past their bureaucratic skulls someday though. Just so that the truth is not being hidden from view there.

I liked the movie too, but boy does it have problems. Most fans never forgave Jar Jar Binks for his role in that one. But it has many other problems too that dragged it down. Though if you just cut out Jar Jar the film would not be quite as big a laughingstock as it is now. And yeah, Darth Maul was pretty cool. I also liked Indiana Jones 4, but I do see why people disliked it. And it wasn't just because of Shia LaBeouf, either. But the movie was so worth it for that "nuking the fridge" joke, I crack up every time it's uttered. XD And Revenge of the Fallen...........Crap. Dark of the Moon probably does suffer a lot of the same problems, I will take your word for it even though I remain curious of it.

Really? What did she say when she brought it up? Do you remember? I may have heard it too but I'm curious as to what it was that was said.

Green hair?

I know, That is not how goth girls act. I know because I am a huge fan of goth girls. And Gwen's perfectly capable of being civil and nice without getting so gushy. Anyone who's ever seen a goth girl on TV knows that that is not how they are typically portrayed. And I suppose I see the reasonings for that, though Scott still didn't get through this cleanly either. He barely resembled his villain self at all. And the Tyler charm should stay with Tyler, since that's his routine and he's the one who made it hilarious.

Total Drama All-Stars should've been renamed Total Drama In-Name Only. Because I am pretty aggravated that something so inept and mean-spirited is a sequel to something that was so great. Island deserves better sequels than this. And playing up the cruelty factor as much as they have is killing it, as is the complete nonexistence of genuine character development and integrity in the stories or the plots. They can't even maintain political correctness as we saw with Mal and the reset button either.

TDAS also nuked the fridge. Get the TDI writers back pronto. The show is suffering without them. The creators need to look at TDI again and understand why it was so successful, and why the later seasons just don't work.