Thread:TheFanmellow/@comment-32999728-20191109150236/@comment-32999728-20191125234650

TheFanmellow wrote: RadicalPatMan wrote: And have you soured on Island Heather recently enough to see her as a bad villain? Yes, I am so angry that everyone keeps her to the final three and state they need an antagonist. Why not Duncan or someone else to keep the drama going. Island Heather honestly is overrated when it comes to my ways. So, were Alejandro (even if he was too perfect), Courtney, Scott, Mal, and Sugar any better as big bad villains for their seasons?

And with your version, it does border on no antagonist territory at times since Heather's out early and Duncan doesn't even start plotting eliminations until three quarters of the way in.

And is Duncan still friends with DJ, Geoff, Gwen, and Owen in your new new version of Island despite him being bumped up to being the new Island antagonist (or the closest that season has)?

Duncan getting Courtney eliminated in Island does feel a bit farfetched though since this was before she got more abusive toward him. If it were Action, World Tour, or All Stars it would be more understanable but not so much in Island.