Heroes vs. Villains

'''Fourteen past contestants return for another chance to one million dollars at a newly redeemed camp. Seven campers are deemed heroes, while the others are deemed villains (along with one other). While competing for a new spa, old heartache rears its ugly head, and old rivals reunite. Shockingly, an archenemy returns, while a lovable dimwit is flushed away.'''

Plot
The episode begins with Chef Hatchet walking down a prison's hallway as we hear Chris' voice in the background, narrating a fake Total Drama season that he has made up in his head. Eventually, Chef arrives at Chris' cell, visiting him for the first time after a whole year. Chef states that Chris' prison sentence for dumping toxic waste on Camp Wawanakwa is over and that he can leave, but Chris refuses to, saying that he has everything he needs in prison. Once Chef announces that the producers have green-lit another season, Chris changes his mind and resumes his role as the show's host. After the theme song, Chris, alongside the Robot, welcomes us to Total Drama All-Stars, which is once again taking place in Camp Wawanakwa because Chris needs to be in a "familiar environment around people he loves to hurt." For this season, fourteen of Total Drama's all-star contestants have been brought back to compete for the prize of $1,000,000. After Chris' short introduction, the contestants arrive in a helicopter in the following order: Mike, Zoey, Lightning, Cameron, Sam, Scott, Jo, Courtney, Gwen, Duncan, Heather, Lindsay, Sierra, and seemingly Ezekiel. However, as Ezekiel drops down from the helicopter, the Robot's arm extends into a plunger which tosses the rabid ex-contestant away. Chris then says that there is no way Ezekiel is coming back.

Now on the shore, Heather denies missing Alejandro, while Courtney tells Chris that he will pay for her dry cleaning. Much to her chagrin, Chris reveals that they agreed to new contracts, causing Courtney to voice her displeasure in the confessional. Later on Chris announces that they are going to compete again for another million dollars "Heroes vs. Villains" style, and then places the cast into two teams, which are the Heroic Hamsters and the Villainous Vultures. Cameron, Courtney, Lindsay, Mike, Sam, Sierra and Zoey are placed onto the heroes team while Duncan, Gwen, Heather, Jo, Lightning and Scott are placed onto the villains team.

Gwen is confused that she is considered a villain but Duncan is happy that they are both on the same team. However, Jo complains that the Villainous Vultures only have six members and are one member short, prompting Chris to place his robot onto their team. Chris then explains that challenges this season will be based off of previous challenges with the first a combination of the cliff dive from Not So Happy Campers - Part 2 and the Baby Carriage Races in Central Park from Broadway, Baby!. Chris orders the campers to meet him at the top of the Cliff, and tells Mike there's no time to change into their swimsuits.

As the campers walk through the woods, Gwen catches Courtney glaring at her causing Duncan to stare at her back. However, Courtney looks away, confusing him. Lindsay then tells Courtney that Duncan wants her to yell at him, but she refuses, by stating there's no point as he doesn't listen and then reveals she thought she was friends with Gwen. The Villainous Vultures soon enter a power struggle for leadership while Gwen tries to convince them that they should act as a team, causing them to laugh. Arriving at the cliff, Chris reveals the first challenge, which is to jump off the 1,000 foot tall cliff into shark infested waters and then find the key that opens the door to the hotel.

At the cliff, the original contestants jump without any problems, but the Revenge of the Island cast, especially Scott since Fang is back, are scared to do so. After they all jump and get the keys, they then have to race back to the cabins on baby strollers with the keys. Both teams jump at the same time for several times until the robot jumps and explodes.

A bearded and shaggy Alejandro then pops out of the robot suit, scaring and surprising everyone, especially Heather. Alejandro and Jo then race back to the cabin on the baby stroller with the right key. Alejandro finally unlocks the good cabin with the key and Chris announces that the Villainous Vultures win the challenge. The villains now get to sleep in the McLean Spa Hotel, while the Heroic Hamsters have to sleep in the regular cabin and vote someone off. At the elimination ceremony, Chris explains that the winning team can now sit in the peanut gallery and watch the losers send someone home. Gwen awkwardly tries to apologize to Courtney with flowers, but Courtney is allergic to them and calls Gwen a villain. Chris then reveals the new voting style for eliminating contestants which is by marking an X on a picture in the confessional. Before announcing the eliminated camper, Chris asks for a volunteer from the Villainous Vultures. Lightning is quick to agree and discovers he has the chance of finding the McLean-Brand Chris Head by spending the night at its location, Boney Island. Chris gives Cameron, Mike, Sam, Sierra, and Zoey marshmallows, leaving Courtney and Lindsay in the bottom two. Lindsay is voted off by her team and is thrown into a giant toilet called the Flush of Shame.

Cast

 * Ezekiel appears, but he does not speak.
 * A prison guard appears but he has no lines.
 * Several prisoners can be heard screaming but it is unknown who voiced them.
 * Two interns appear but they have no lines.

General

 * A black and white version of Team Chris Is Really Really Really Really Hot's logo is seen on the contestants' new contracts.
 * Chris and Chef's bobbleheads that were first seen on Cartoon Network's Total Drama World Tour website are seen in the jail scene.
 * This marks the first episode Alex House plays the role of Alejandro, replacing Marco Grazzini, who voiced Alejandro for Total Drama Action and Total Drama World Tour.

Continuity

 * Chris is shown to have gone to jail after being arrested in Brain vs. Brawn: The Ultimate Showdown.
 * The Escaped Killer make a brief cameo in prison, successfully being caught after the events of Hook, Line, and Screamer.
 * Total Drama All-Stars occurs about one year after the conclusion of Total Drama: Revenge of the Island. During that time, all toxic waste on Camp Wawanakwa was cleaned up.
 * Also, Scott has recovered from all of his injuries and has gotten out of the Trauma Chair since the finale of Total Drama: Revenge of the Island.
 * Alejandro has finally recovered from the injuries he suffered two seasons ago.
 * However, neither Ezekiel or Dakota have yet recovered from their mutations.

Goofs

 * Gwen mentions twice that Duncan and Courtney weren't dating when they kissed, even though they were.
 * When the rest of competitors make it into shore, Heather's ponytail is short rather than long, but in the next scene, she was seen with long ponytail again.
 * When Courtney falls from her team's carriage, she seems to land underneath it.
 * Alejandro claims he was in the suit for a year, which would be highly unlikely since he was placed in the suit at the end of Hawaiian Punch, and Chris has been in prison for a year.
 * This may be possible if Total Drama: Revenge of the Island takes place shortly or directly after the events of Hawaiian Punch.