User blog comment:TheAmazingTurtle/Why Pahkitew Island is so great/@comment-25027229-20150821225816/@comment-26916878-20150822153158

I actually really liked Dave early on as a mostly normal guy who can't wrap his head round a bunch of really weird teens that he's forced to interact with. I was thinking I'd be reacting the same way to some of those weird people as well. For example I was thinking the wizard tower thing was a really stupid idea and Dave voiced my thoughts!

Sure his funny lines weren't Noah quality but honestly who is that good to be fair, besides the great Noah himself?

Honestly if he'd kept an interest in Sky but not gotten obsessed(or not developed a crush on her at all) and continued along the lines of early-Dave, I'd have ranked him fairly highly, possibly on the verge of top 10 characters.

His end was disgraceful. He deserved some measure of retribution against Sky not even more pain. With how inconsisten sky was writter she sure as hell shouldn't have won either!(thankfully I got the Shawn ending in my country.)

Shawn and Jasmine are an incredibly well written couple I fully agree there, I have to say.