User blog comment:CheeseBurgerGuy/Total Drama My Way: ROTI/@comment-32999728-20200215131623/@comment-32999728-20200215191352

It'll be a tad confusing when I use it for a All Stars compilation but I'm chill if you decide to do one with 16.

Assuming the 1st gens competing in your AS are same as canon, you may need to add Molly and Brick to replace Sam to make it 8 from Revenge then have the same first gens that were in the canon one plus Owen (obvious why) to make 8.

Revenge: Mike, Zoey, Cameron, Scott, Jo, Lightning, Brick, and Molly (essentially mergers plus Mike and Scott)

1st gens: Alejandro, Heather, Duncan, Gwen, Courtney, Lindsay, Sierra, and Owen