Thread:Fedora Kid/@comment-2091662-20150222173813/@comment-1734566-20150222222854

Not sure, TBH. Greatest Castaway, to me, DOES sound more competition-oriented. I mean, let's face it - if this was a popularity contest, Rupert would be #1 again, lol. XP

Yeah, "best player" is subjective, and with that said - I'm mostly shocked at Richard, Kim, and Tyson not making the Top 10, although I'm happy Richard and Kim didn't make it since I think they're overrated. Same with Borneo being #7 in the Best Seasons list - just because it's first doesn't automatically mean it's best. And that's the funny thing with the selection process - of the 20 contestants who were choices in "Greatest Castaway," only FIVE were non-winners: Russell, Cirie, Ozzy, Rob C, and Amanda Kimmel. And whaddya know? Four of those five made the Top 10. So I think that's the viewers agreeing with me that people can be non-winners, and still influential/strong players.

That said, what do you think of Yul getting #9? I know you really don't like him, since you said his "strategy" in Cook Islands was to just ride the coattails of the OP idol? :p