User blog:CheeseBurgerGuy/What If Total Drama Revenge of the Island Had the OG Cast?

While Survivor has a brand new cast every season, Total Drama didn't introduce new contestants until the fourth go-around. How would have TDROTI looked if the writers had decided to stick with the original cast all the way through?

Cast
First, we have to determine which characters make the season.

Almost all charaters cameos should make the season with the exception of three: Owen, Ezekiel, and Izzy. Owen won't be in the season because there is no place for him in it and we can keep his cameo. Izzy, considering her role in Finders Creepers, will also be ineligible to return. Obviously, Zeke is in no state to return in any capacity past his cameos. I considered also saying no Duncan due to his role in Grand Chef Auto. However, I don't believe those are mutually exclusive. This means that are cast will include: Heather, Duncan, Gwen, DJ, and Lindsay.

Both Alejandro and Sierra will return due to only being introduced in WT. Since Sierra is here, so is Cody.

To round out this cast, i believe that we would have Eva, Noah, Courtney, Tyler, and Harold.

Episode 1: Bigger! Badder! Brutal-er!
Notes: immunity: Mutant Maggots
 * Order contestants cross the finish line: Duncan (Rats), Gwen (Maggots), Alejandro (Rats), Eva (Maggots), Heather (Rats), Sierra (Maggots), Courtney (Rats), Cody (Maggots), Harold (Rats), DJ (Maggots), Tyler (Rats), Noah (Maggots), and Lindsay (Rats).
 * The three girls (Courtney and Heather and Lindsay) immedietly start fightning for control of the Toxic Rats, pushing their team to victory until the whole cabin thing.
 * On the other hand, Eva threatens everyone to name her team captain. They all agree.

Bottom 2: Duncan and Courtney Eliminated: Courtney (13th)
 * Why Duncan?: Courtney still hasn't forgiven Duncan for the whole love triangle last season.
 * Why Courtney?: Heather and Alejandro knew that Duncan could serve as a sheild for them. Courtney has also been getting on the nerves of all her teammates.
 * Comments: Since nobody in this cast is obvious fodder, I needed to eliminate someone based on their plots. The love triangle stuff isn't needed in this season (since I'm saving the forgiveness stuff for All-Stars), so I got rid of the root problem.