User blog comment:BarBar/Something that bugs me about Courtney and Heather/@comment-25297892-20150203203124

Both Heather and Courtney have their flaws, even as antagonists because if Heather dodged some deserved eliminations in TDI (thanks to Lindsay or the lack of coherence of the Writers) Courtney same did at the beginning of TDI and literally floated on her lawyers all the TDA she was in, but Heather Always provided for more interesting plots while Courtney was redundant once TDI ended: love Duncan, hate Duncan, befriend Gwen, be her enemy, the only thing she was coherent all the time was treating the Others like losers (as she did with Beth, Harold, Tyler, Gwen, Trent, and the list can be infinite..). Courtney became soon annoying to me as TDA started her derailment, Heather on the contrary stepped forward more and more, do not being totally changed (she's basically still the b***h we know from TDI) but was certainly improved.

They did so opposites courses as the series progressed and Courtney bested eventually Heather in terms of cruelty and mischievousness: while Heather sticks with her evil persona just for the reality business, Courtney does this just for her personal satisfaction: humiliate a pitiful Gwen or control a doggy Scott is strategy or pure mischievousness? You can sure debate Heather treated Lindsay like a slave during the Whole TDI...not only for strategy but because she's a b***h, but this happened a lot time ago and honestly soon after TDI I saw free acts of cruelty of Heather rarely.

Heather is not at the top of my rank neither at the bottom, unlike Courtney: the reason? Follow the evil strategies adopted continuosly by Heather (as main villain or secundary as in TDA, TDWT and arguably TDAS) is more entertaining than following Courtney doing Always the same things: get a boyfriend, dump him, hate Gwen, befriend Gwen, hate again, get another delinquent, dump him again...