User blog comment:YoungEezy27/3rd Alternate Ending?/@comment-3573655-20141006220931/@comment-4742462-20141009152431

@TDPIScarlett: It would've been better if Scarlett was defeated by Sky or Jasmine or even Shawn. But being defeated (and outranked) by Max was pretty much a complete slap in the face to her plot. The last three minutes of Scarlett Fever felt like Miles Smith realizing that he had to wrap it up and pulled that ending right out of his butt.

Sugar's elimination was so much of a shallow victory that it almost felt pointless as it ultimately more rushed than Max's elimination and in an episode that was overall very unsatisfying as well as completely insulting your intelligence throughout with all the BS moments in it. That and her suffering no karma really doesn't help.

I would also honestly rather shoot myself before ever calling Sugar a villain. But the fact that she is considered one just further drags down the credibility of any of the post-Island villains (excluding Scarlett and maybe Mal).