User blog comment:Cody Kins TD Fan/Is Ed McDonald REALLY That Bad of a Writer?/@comment-10310224-20140302192359

I never watched My Little Pony, and the last time I watched SpongeBob was probably a year ago, so I can't really compare him to those writers, but he inst the best writer.

I fell he passed Total Drama off as a really kidish show, because he jokes sucked...... a lot, and I have a felling he didn't even watch TD before (and probably after) writing his episodes.

I'm pretty sure the eliminations and challenge's are planed by the directors, so we can't fully blame him for the sucky challenges and his Cameron saving, but he still probably could of done better job of making them interesting and less random. Like, the way he handled Sundae Muddy Sundae's challenge twists was very lame, and completely random. Also, the way he handled Gwuncans break up was awful. I have a felling the directors wanted him to make it short because of CN, but it still could have gone a LOT better.

In the end, I wouldn't say he should stop writing, but maybe try to come more prepared and really think things threw. But hey, we all hated Laurie Elliot, and know she is one of the better writers.