User blog comment:TheDipDap1234/Sugar - a Good or a Bad Character?/@comment-31556666-20141029214510/@comment-24971793-20141029224351

I really like this analysis, it's strange but her biggest positives are the same as her biggest negatives. The comedy, bold/unique characterization, gameplay, interactions with others, domineering personality and her different style of antagonism.

Which is I think a big reason why discussions on the topic don't seem to go anywhere. Every reason you love her is a reason why some hate her and vice versa. Future appearances will probably turn the scale.