User blog comment:Epic~00/Why Total Drama All Stars Was Such An Abysmal Season (PART 4)/@comment-27588345-20141030221457/@comment-4742462-20141101205744

The mutant creatures were more unrealistic rather than insulting to your intelligence. They reacted to the challenge when they discovered they were forced to wear backpacks full of explosives. Everyone sees Amy being eliminated while Samey isn't wearing her fake mole yet still believe that she's Amy in the very next episode after she just now puts it on.

Either way, both seasons are flawed. Revenge of the Island is heavily criticized for it's flaws while Pahkitew Island doesn't get enough criticisms for it's flaws.