User blog comment:Spiderguy56/ranking the total drama's form worst to best/@comment-1037137-20141123031624

5. TDAS (Don't worry, I'll spare everyone the ten-hour lecture that comes with this train wreck)

4. TDWT - Way too much toxic drama in the middle third and several high-profile derailments, along with some excruciatingly moronic running gags; but the songs, settings, and the first half are good, I'll give it that.

3. TDA - Horribly wasted main theme, it was lacking in much drive, focus, or anything that should've made it exciting. But it gave some characters some overdue spotlight, it had a couple of exciting moments, and slightly improves with its second half.

2. TDROTI - Unpopular Opinion: It had some very creative challenges and some lively standouts in the second cast, even if the more lackluster ones eventually took center-stage. A lot less BS to be concerned about than in the aforementioned seasons and reasonably fun for what it is. It could've been a lot worse, trust me. And it has the most satisfying finish since Island, and these days that is saying something.

1. TDI - Unquestionably the best and by far the most fun, with great characters, amazing chemistry among the cast, great jokes, great challenges, a refreshing down-to-earth premise, a surprisingly sophisticated and mature tone for its intended audience, it is by far the best paced, best written, and best developed. It set a standard that the other seasons ought to have tried to be a little more faithful to. And it gave us who is truly the greatest villain in Total Drama: Heather.

TDPI - Didn't see it yet, so until then I'm NEUTRAL.