Thread:Fedora Kid/@comment-2091662-20141218114510/@comment-1734566-20141231181135

So you really mean to say that Phillip and Natalie T were literally the ONLY people in ALL of Redemption Island that Boston Rob could beat? Yeah, OK, sure. Again, OF COURSE Russell had to boot people that he could beat - like I said, you can't take ALL goats to the finale. Especially considering that Natalie W. = Natalie T. XD

Actually, you CAN compare their games despite the results. Russell and Tony both found idols without clues. Russell and Tony both lied about their occupations and personal lives. Russell and Tony both swore on something close to them, only to break said promises. Both Russell and Tony did well in challenges. Both Russell and Tony got mega-grilled in the FTC's. You can't just say that their games are NOTHING alike just because one lost and one won - that's idiotic. Seems to me that you blindly ignore EVERY SINGLE POSSIBLE ASPECT of a season, contestant, strategy, etc. and sacrifice it all at the altar of "THE WIN." It seems that ALL that matters in your book is the win, which, again, is false and moronic to suggest. Trish certainly didn't bail out Tony ALL THE TIME just because she "liked him." The edits went so far as to even SHOW how exasperated Trish was getting with Tony's paranoia, and constantly having to bail him out. And again, she was the one who slammed him the hardest at FTC over "swearing on his father's grave." And again, if you HONESTLY believe that Spencer and Erik DIDN'T change a lot of minds, then sorry, that's just you being close-minded.

When did Natalie W make him CRY, lol? That was in Redemption Island, when his idiot tribe threw a challenge and killed their own chances JUST to get rid of him, like a bunch of morons. I would cry too...for the future of humanity with such idiots in existence. XD

And are you really gonna blame the EDIT for making him look "better"? Well then shoot, I guess the edit is to blame for Kim being perceived as so great in One World - I'll bet it was really Chelsea doing all the behind-the-scenes work in that season, Kim was just "favored" by the edit. Or it was really Gervasse doing all the work in BvW, like Vytas said - the edit simply favored Tyson. See how this argument fails? For you to blame a blindside on the victim of the blindside is ridiculous - that's like saying Natalie A. this season had NOTHING to do with Jon Misch's blindside. ;P

And Russell was the first in Survivor history to find idols without clues, on top of just how many he found. And he "wasted idols?" OK, sure - but what would YOU rather do? Waste an idol when there's no votes for you, or be blindsided with an idol in your pocket like James Clement, John Rocker, or Jon Misch?

And again, you really think that the audience sees LESS than the cast members? Does the cast get to see everything happening behind the scenes, in the woods, in the confessionals, on the reward challenges, on the idol hunts, in Ponderosa? No. The audience gets to see multiple angles that the cast members never do. You simply cannot argue against that - it is FACT.