User blog comment:Don25/Because Scarlett should come back./@comment-25342388-20171117015828/@comment-25342388-20171117211325

Yeah but the contestants signed contracts absolving the show for any unfortunate "accidents" while performing the challenges so technicality what Chris does to the contestants is "legal". Scarlett blackmailing Chris by threatening their lives wasn't part of the challenge, and therefore illegal.

Plus, Duncan was specifically stated to had gone to jail for the destruction of private property and Pahiktew Island is certainly a more expensive property than Chris mansion.