User blog comment:Flagator24/Is Pahkitew Island better than Revenge of the island?/@comment-26385595-20180517155404

Revenge of the Island is better.

General better cast excluding maybe Staci or B.... Sure you can hate on Mike if you want, but he was decent enough in ROTI, and Zoey was actually quite good in ROTI.

Decent premergers excluding the two I said which I feel like PI seriously lacks.

Some may have not really cared or found it pointless, but I liked the random cameos from people of the original generation, and PI really lacked that, not much to connect it to any of the previous seasons at all.

Slightly better villain (although Scott is pulling it a bit and Lightning was kinda last minute, but I liked Jo even if not the absolute main villian. Sugar wasnt a good one in my opinion, and Scarlett I liked as the snarky one but I did not like how insane she became in Scarlett Fever)

Only thing I will credit is a slightly better finale, atleast in terms of the finalists, not the finale itself.

Otherwise, I find ROTI better.