User blog comment:Spiderguy56/ranking the total drama's form worst to best/@comment-24466939-20141123233223

6. TDAS (gee I wonder why)

5. TDRotI (horrible merge and mostly flat cast, but I liked returning to the island and the Toxic theme)

4. TDA (devoid of drama in the first half besides Gwent and the spa incident, felt like a boring rehash for the first half and last quarter, but the third quarter was as good as TDI)

3. TDPI (enjoyable and very creative, but the cast only interacted in pairs (better than ROTI) and the finale was lackluster)

2. TDWT (overall very enjoyable; Cody, Tyler, and Noah were brought back into the spotlight, constantly changing setting was unique and made this season feel more fast-paced than the other seasons which I liked, Alejandro was the best antagonist along with heather, songs, but certain episodes (African Lying Safari, Picnic at Hanging Dork, Jamaica Me Sweat) were very sub-par and Team Victory was a disaster when they could have been so much more)

1. TDI (best season only challenged by World Tour, the first season was an interesting parody of Survivor and it set the bar for the following seasons to strive for, only problems were lack of major development outside of Gwen, Beth and Lindsay, Owen making the finale, and Camp Castaways)