User blog comment:Total Drama Wiki! Wars/Week of June 9, 2015/@comment-2147650-20150610051050

I think this is just what we've been needing for Wiki Wars - pitting two evenly matched… things and seeing which one wins! Good job on this one, whoever came up with this match up.

As for my vote, it's tough to say… both have characters who are well-developed for a short season (Brick, Cameron, Dakota and Jasmine, Samey, Shawn). However, overall likability goes to...

Even though half of the cast was gimmicky and such, they're overall more likable, while it would take the second cast more than one season to have them achieve this.