User blog comment:Epic~00/Why Total Drama All Stars Was Such An Abysmal Season (PART 4)/@comment-24971793-20141030161213/@comment-31556666-20141030173949

Courtney was fine up until Sundae. Yes, making an elimination list would be something Courtney would do... TDA Courtney. This Courtney on the other hand is devoid of real human emotion or sympathy in this episode. I liked her redemption. Sure, I didn't like when she was occasionaly in the "unicorns and rainbows" path with Gwen, but there was times where she still had her same personality during her redemption.

And from what I've seen, I don't think that she'd betray Gwen or Scott after everything we had seen. She already mentioned to Gwen all the way back in Regatta that she wants her to win. Yeah, it's a really unrealistic and stupid scene for Courtney and Gwen, but it was still involved in a break in continuity in Sundae.

We don't know how Mal got the list, sure, but the last time Courtney is seen with the list is in the confessional. This accidentaly implies that that was the last place the list was, making Courtney come off as not only suddenly unlikable, but pretty dumb.