User blog comment:Epic~00/Why Total Drama All Stars Was Such An Abysmal Season (PART 4)/@comment-24971793-20141030161213/@comment-24971793-20141030225956

Maybe she flushed her plan down the confessional toilet and Mal fished it out ;p

I really don't remember a redemption from Courtney, can someone remind me? She always had a borderline personality that switches from "sweet girl" to psychopath in the blink of an eye (watch her audition tape). She got toned down a bit in some of the TDWT episodes but every single season (including TDI) she had "villainous" and I guess "heroic?" no wait, "less villainous" moments. She's constantly placed in a victim position and I think a lot of people mistake that from positive development. But no she's had a pretty horrible personality starting from her audition tape all the way till her last AS episode.

She could be an acceptable protagonist, but I don't think the Gwen and Scottney storylines where the right way to do it. She was in fact a secondary villain in AS, even being switched from the heroic hamsters to the vultures because of her heinous actions. The only way I would buy having Courtney as a "hero" would be if she realised her evil and actively tried to become better. Instead of being victimized.