User blog comment:Stryzzar/Who is the Greatest Antagonist?/@comment-27329394-20140609190008

I ended up voting for Alejandro. Heather and Al are definitely my two favorites, but sometimes it wasn't explained why well why Heather was safe (Tri-Armed and Wawanakwa had some pretty bad reasoning) and she got extremely lucky in Search and Do Not Destroy, but otherwise was more effective. Al made sure most of the votes were explained, and they were otherwise similar.

Scott, Justin, and Courtney showed they were better not as villains than as villains to be honest. Scott was WAY better in All-Stars whereas he was disliked in TDRoTI, I think most people think Justin as a character isn't bad but he wasn't a good antagonist, and Courtney is better to sticking as an anti-villain or anti-hero imo.

I don't dislike Mal but there were a lot of bad decisions regarding him. He did do some stuff that I would consider antagonistic (most of Obsta-Kill Course and breaking the boats to hinder the others), did a decent job of imitating Mike (although it just proved how unexplored Mike himself is, even Mal said he was boring) or was just was antagonistic without thinking about the competition which was interesting (breaking other stuff solely to make people upset), but he was perceived as more evil than the others which was hardly true in the first place, majoly dumbed down Zoey (as long as Zoey didn't know, which she never did, he pretty much could do whatever) and Cameron (he can't trust anyone but all of a sudden trusts Mike for an unconvincing reason), never actually eliminated Zoey which made the finale lame, and the brain scenes were also weird. It's mostly Zoey's fault honestly, considering she got several warnings, but as long as Zoey was on his side Mal hardly had to try.