User blog comment:CheeseBurgerGuy/TD Choose Your Own Roleplay: Island (Part 3)/@comment-35606925-20200121232842/@comment-35606925-20200122001242

Duncan would take the olive branch but, as far as he knows, Beth would side with Leshawna and Katie over Duncan any day. This comes down to the majority. Remember, Duncan thinks it could easily be him going home. He has an anybody but me mentality, so if the majority would want Heather and the other option means elimination, he's going to do what he has to do to stay. Again, Duncan isn't against working with Beth now or even in the future, it's just it sounds too good to be true.