User blog comment:King Flurry51/Mal and Scarlett:analyzis of their values and vices as villains/@comment-24971793-20140821131423/@comment-25297892-20140821140023

Agree about some pure evils committed by the "normal villains" as Heather or Scott,even if they're kind of justified by their respective backstories:

-Al became the bad and conniving latin lover he is now mostly as a response to all the nasty treatments received from his bigger Brother Josè -Heather born as a fat unlucky girl constantly mocked by her Brother,and once she finally ended out this condition she decided to give back to the world all the hate she had accumulated,becoming the Alpha bi**c queen bee we were introduced to on the Island. -Scott,Dawn told this,had an unhappy infantry,maybe cause of the bad influence of the father.I can imagine this as the typycal farmer tough man.XD

Mal and Scarlett from what we know about them,hadn't no reason or background story to justify their evilness:why they want the world domination?Just for the sake of the evil,no else. I agree about considering Scarlett not the main villain of TDPI,because she was costantly separated from the rest of the cast being able to keep interactions only with Max.The Maxett duo appeared all the time in a different dimension respect the reality:planning evilness all the time,don't helping in the challenges without second intentions (Max to appear Always the most villainous,Scarlett to rid off him)...they were a completely different matter respect the rest of the cast,that was focused basically on the challenges. Sugar was most of the time the antagonist of the ingenuous Ella,and only in the final episodes she appeared all of sudden as a general antagonist,able to skive Always the elimination and win many challenges.I compared Sugar's rise to the same of Lightening:both were put in a background safe position all the time,having only easy conflicts that solved soon..while Scott,Jo,Amy and Scarlett rised and fell under the cameras.Once they all gone,then we saw both Lightening and Sugar as real antagonists. Turning back on Scarlett,I think her return is less probable then Mal's,because while Mal can Always creep out from nothing as he did in TDAS,being an evil side not a true person,Scarlett revealed to the the entire world to be an aspirant evil Genius,utterly crazy,fake and sociopath.How you would trust again one like her if she returned?I'd never trust anymore Beyond those nerdy glasses and haircut.The only way she could return,is as a complete different person,an utterly fake identity with a fake name.Unless,another rise of Scarlett will be logically favoured only by dimming even more than in TDAS the other contestants,so to make 'em blind of her evident nature.