User blog comment:Jakusz/If Beth debuted in Niagra Brawls instead of Blaineley/@comment-1443671-20141001035451/@comment-24971793-20141001114711

If Beth didn't know the answer to the question she would have been eliminated and Lindsay, the only one left in the competition, would have automatically won. But it's not completely sure if Beth knew the answer but just got distracted by Blaineley's rudeness, or if she really didn't know the answer.

Either way both could have returned. I was always under the impression that it would have been Lindsay, since Beth (whether or not she actually knew it) failed to give the right answer on time.