User blog comment:ArtDraw12/Say something positive about/@comment-24245380-20161125230235/@comment-27447405-20161125232923

I agree with SDF, I am really happy she wasn't a one of the antagonists. I mean, look at the Survivor female villains, Parvati, Jerri, Sandra, Danielle, and Courtney. They were all on the villains tribe but I don't think that necessarily means they are bad people in real life, they just. Even in Total Drama, some female villains have redeemable qualities like being clever or being redeemed in later seasons. Like Heather and Courtney. However I had to skip over most of Amy's scenes because they made me physically sick, there was nothing intelligent or intriguing about what her character or she did, her only trait was a one-note abuser to her sister, that's it. Amy was used as a plot device, Samey needed to grow to stand up to her as her plot.

That being said, Amy clearly has potential as you said, she isn't going to be a vile creature for no reason. But I am not so sure she can be redeemed since she literally attempted to murder her own sister and did nothing but treat her like crap in Pahkitew, but they redeemed Heather and it is extremely likely the twins will return so who knows I could be proven wrong.