User blog comment:CheeseBurgerGuy/Where Did It Go Wrong?: Duncan/@comment-39251217-20190816075352/@comment-35606925-20190816083208

I understand what you mean by genders being off balance for these. Considering that having a repeat winner goes against Total Drama's unspoken rules anyway, I based my theroies on the events of the season. For example, Duncan getting to the finale with Scott in All-Stars was, in my eyes, the most plausible route to get Duncan there.