The Treasure Island of Dr. McLean

'''The teams wake up in the middle of the lake, where a returnee begins her mutant transformation, and seeks help from a fellow teammate. Meanwhile, another member tries to help a friend keep his secret under control. Someone reveals to have found the idol, and asks someone else to keep it a secret. The founder is eliminated, but uses their discovery to eliminate a mutant instead.'''

Plot
The episode first starts out when both teams are seen sleeping on rafts out in the lake. Scott doesn't seem to remember anything after dinner. Cameron goes into a flashback when being served the "Turkey Butterlini". Chef tells Cameron to enjoy his nap, then corrects himself and says meal. Mike then finds a fedorra hat and puts it on, which makes him transform into Manitoba Smith and starts to talk to Zoey. Cameron pushes her in the water and takes off the hat for Mike, in order to save their relationship. He then makes a confessional about how he helps Mike with his disorder and he helps him to boot Scott. He also knows all the ways Mike goes into his different personalities, but hasn't mastered getting his original one yet. Dakota also makes a confessional. She states that now being bald, she has to focus on becoming friends with the rest of the compeitors. She chooses Zoey as the best choice to be seen out in public, post-makeover.

Chris then arrives to start the next challenge.

Quotes

 * Mike: What? Where are we?
 * Zoey: No! Chris must've set us adrift when we went to sleep!
 * Scott: Yeah...wait, I don't remember anything after dinner.
 * Cameron: Dinner. That's it! (has a flashback)
 * Cameron: (in flashback) Eww...what is this?
 * Chef: Turkey Butterlini. Enjoy your nap. I mean, meal (laughs; flashback ends)
 * Cameron: Turkey makes you sleepy, so mutant turkey must've knocked us out cold!
 * Dakota: I'm going to turn you into a purse!
 * Dakota: (hurting the aligator) Why you hit yourself? Why you hit yourself?
 * Lightning: (to crocodiles) Uh... Sha-friends?
 * Dakota: Uh-hahaha, me got munchies!
 * Zoey: (after Dakota's elimination) Her friendship was hazardous to my health. I had to vote her off.

Continuity

 * This is the second episode in the season in which Toxic Rats won. The first was Finders Creepers.
 * The is the first time all four of Mike's alternate personalities appear in the same episode.
 * Gwen makes a cameo in this episode.
 * This marks the first time Gwen has lines since Aftermath Aftermayhem.
 * This is the second episode Gwen has to face her worst fear, the first time is in Phobia Factor.
 * This is the first episode Dakota wore her original outfit since Ice Ice Baby, as she had to wear an intern outfit from Finders Creepers to A Mine is a Terrible Thing to Waste.
 * Sam returns in this episode as part of the challenge.
 * This makes him the third contestant to return to do something other than being a contestant. The other are Ezekiel and Dakota.

Goofs

 * Anne Maria's elimination is not mentioned in the recap.
 * When Dakota hits Fang into the mutant squids eye it gets a black eye. When the Maggots get to the squid the black eye is gone.