User blog comment:Webkinz Mania/"Scarlett Fever" Review/@comment-23995441-20140716231457/@comment-27329394-20140717121357

"This is the same guy who was going to watch Zoey get slowly eaten alive by pirhanas with a sadistic smile on his face."

That's just the thing - he was going to do it. He also wasn't the one who set up Zoey to do so since it was a gambit in order to get Mike back. While they may not have been on an animatronic island, we've seen other contestants willingly try to kill someone else. Scarlett was legitimately played as a threat, but Mal's contributions (which were mostly messing with the challenges, which I don't have a problem with) were generally undermined by something else (which I did have a problem with), which didn't make him as threatening.

I do see where you are coming from though.