User blog comment:Flagator24/Is Pahkitew Island better than Revenge of the island?/@comment-1056199-20180528200050

Hard to decide between TDRI and TDPI, it's a tie to me.

However, I think the cast of TDRI and TDPI should had been combined into one big cast of 26 contestants. Imagine an alliance of Mal and Scarlett or Scott and Max (maybe Fang would have fun with 2 punching bags instead of one), a rivalry between Jo, Jasmine and/or Sky. Some fans on Deviantart and Fanfiction.net even imagined some fanon pairings of Scott and Amy, Brick and Samey. Then some cast members of TDRI and TDPI could had returned to the movie lot of TDA or we could have a bigger and greater All-Stars season.