User blog comment:Bears&Memes/Total Drama: Ridonculous Despair Ch. 1 Investigation/@comment-27126228-20170103103106

I'm still going for Jay as the culprit.

First of all having Geoff or Brody as the culprit is too obvious with the pink shirt and also is there anymore pieces of evidence pointing at either of them because I don't see any. Another note is that there would be no reason for Geoff or Brody to have shown the way it would work since all it does is make them more suspicious. The most likely reason to show this is because, they want to explain that it doesn't need both members to enter the door in order to get them registered, just one member is fine. Which is where my entire theory is going in full circle.

First of all this was the act of two people. Mickey and Jay who probably called our Gerry at some point to go to the garden that time. Mickey was the lookout while Jay was the one who did the murder. Mickey most likely kept an eye on the roof to see when Gerry was going to the roof via binoculars and when he signal Jay, he took Jay's place in the cafeteria while the real Jay went to the garden to ambush Gerry. Explains why Mickey was never seen. He must have stolen his headband to because I know how it was use. It was use as a slingshot along with the rusty nail and the two holes and with the tennis ball as ammo and the plastic object as the container of the tennis ball, that was how Jay struck Gerry in the nose.

That probably stunned Gerry and then Jay took this opportunity to kill Gerry. Afterwards they moved his body all the way from the garden to the fountain and in order to hide the weapons and the crime scene, Jay use the water hose to clean the weapons and wash away all the blood and the water use was from the pipes of the fountain. Most likely Kitty say him at that point and asked him what he was doing. Out of panic Jay hit Kitty with the shovel and then rush away. The coffee and the the Blogger's testimony will be evidence Kitty is not the culprit since that'll provide her an alibi at the crime scene.

The pink t-shirt? Jay might have been wearing it and used it to disguise the blood he must have gotten after the kill. It was dried to wash away any traces of blood.

Monoshop Bag? Evidence to show the culprit was one of the first people of the store and eliminating Emma and Taylor, most likely candidate is Mickey and Jay.

Shed's lock? Proof Kitty is not the culprit since the key would be with her.

Splinters in the Door? Will be the decisive evidence to prove Jay is the culprit since he'll have scratches in his arms.

That's all folks, hope you enjoyed my theory. Think it might be right?