User blog comment:A Mystery Anamatronic/TD Seasons Hurt n Heal/@comment-26344841-20160102144833/@comment-26344841-20160102152004

In my opinion Action did everything good what Island did wrong so it deserves to be much higher. The only thing that holds it back is the finale which is the worst finale in the series if it comes down to tension and build up.

ROTI had good character: Jo, Brick, Lightning, Dakota, Sam (who I actually enjoyed after rewatching the season), Scott, Cameron (people who say that Cameron is a bad character need to get their brain checked cause on his own Cameron is a darn good character) but like you said the interaction is a bit... meh. However the finale is the best in the series and makes up for a lot.

Pahkitew is worse than both of them.