User blog comment:TheTDQueen2014/Who's the BEST and WORST Writer?/@comment-2212492-20141111103943

Had to check the list of episodes page to check which writer wrote which episode, lol. So, I have this theory that Ed Macdonald wrote Pahkitew better because he didn't have to rewatch any of the previous seasons and he might be the reason that Pahkitew even happened when the producers decided to give him a chance. When he ruined it, they fired him.

Jennifer Pertsch has to be my favourite writer because she wrote the episodes in which there were some pretty unique interactions like the Island special, the characters interacting in the first episode, handling Katie's elimination well and stuff like that. I'd totally put her in charge for an underdog season. Erika Strobel comes a close second because she wrote some fantastic episodes and she is able to handle eliminations pretty well such as Lindsay's, DJ's and Eva's second elimination. Heather's elimination was also fantastic but the only reason she's not my favourite writer is because she wrote the infamous Mr. Coconut episode which I love about everything including the interactions without Mr. Coconut. Shelly Scarrow..eh. I don't think she handled Cody's (Beth should have been eliminated) and Tyler's (Courtney should have been eliminated) eliminations well but her Gwen/Geoff episode is no doubt one of the most memorable Total Drama Island episodes. Izzy's second elimination episode was also awesome.

We could go without Alex Ganetakos because his only Total Drama Island episode was really horrible and there were many things I didn't like in that episode including Owen not being eliminated. Heather being locked in the freezer was nice though. Alex Nussbaum and Tom Mcgillis were also pretty cool.

Worst writers? Nicole Demerse was just wow. She wrote the episodes with the least amount of interactions and was the main writer to write for the Trent derailment. Brendon Yorke for the Gwen derailment but he did put Heather in a good spotlight. But many characters were out of character in that episode. Mutiny on the Soundstage was useless and the only thing I liked about it was Beth and Duncan's friendship near the end. Paul, a one time writer wrote the episode Courtney returned in Action and unfairly got Owen voted off..

Most of the one time writers wrote my favourite episodes of Action. Alice Prodanou can handle the aftermaths really well. Emily Andras although wrote a Trent derailment episode brought us back to Wawanakwa and there were some pretty good interactions. I also loved every writer of World Tour which kind of shows that it might be my favourite season in terms of episodes but for overall season I love Pahkitew Island better. Can't say anything bad about the Revenge of the Island writers either but I hope Jeremy Winkels and Eliza Crosland return.

Only four writers wrote Total Drama All Stars which was the main problem. Terry McGurrin should be more hated than Ed though because he wrote the final two episodes that everyone hates. He wrote that horrible Heather elimination and made the Island sink. Evil Dread was eh. I think that episode was overhyped.

For Pahkitew, Alice Prodanou returned! Unfortunately, while I liked Sky Fall most people classify it as a boring episode even though I think that the Skave episodes were worse. Alex wrote a good episode, I'll admit so that can show he's improving I guess. I love how Laurie Elliott writers Amy, Samey and Topher. Ed Macdonald improved in this season, I can't believe they fired him. I think it happened after they got All Stars feedback from the fans. Terry Mcgurrin wrote a cool first episode but the last episode was cool, I guess for the Shawn and Jasmine interactions but the Skave derailment was his fault and he completely derailed the couple. On the bright side, he understands our reaction to Sugar pretty good.

Miles Smith sucked. There was nothing but the Rodney gag in the dares episode, the reward challenge sucked and the interactions were repetitive, Sugar was also disgusting in that episode but I did like the Jasmine and Topher interaction. Scarlett Fever was ew, the sudden revelation I guess was handled okay but there should have been some hints earlier. He showed some hints in the reward challenge. Only five writers for Pahkitew, but still better than All Stars which showed that everyone but Terry improved.