User blog comment:TotalDramaFan82498/Is It Bad That I've Liked Every Season?/@comment-25027229-20150308234509

I've liked every season as well. Each has high and lows, like you said above.

TDI was the best of the bunch, but it had weak humor for the most part that could either be gold or s*** depending on the delivery. The large amount of fodder didn't help either. The tone and mood were perfect though.

TDA was just boring. It fixed a few of TDIs problems, but added, like, three times as many. Boring plots. Bad interactions. Things happening for the sake of it. Aftermaths. Lame jokes. The worst finale ever. OWEN. The best things about the season were Courtney, the theme, and the development of Beth and Harold.

TDWT was a drastic improvement over Action and dealt with its problems by the end of the show. Noah and Cody got more camera time (I don't care about Tyler), Aleheather was a great rivalry, the jokes were considerably more consistent this time, and the first 12 episodes are what I consider to be the best stretch of the series to date. However, I See London... through Picnic at Hanging Dork nearly sunk the season, and all because of Duncan and Courtney. From the merge onward, it was nearly perfect, albeit a bit dark for my tastes.

ROTI is my least favorite season. Everything that made TD great was missing. Interactions were limited, the boot order was horrid, the villain was the worst ever, and the theme was atrocious. The only redemption I can give this season was Jo, Lightning, and the post merge episodes. Unfortunately, the season is still lackluster, but not bad by any means.

As the rare All-Stars "non-hater," I see the issues, but was never bothered by them until Bold and the Bootyful and that's really the only episode I hated. I didn't care about Courtney and laughed when she was booted. I liked Scott. I didn't find Mal that bad, only his downfall. Alejandro was better here than in WT. Gwen was finally given the upper hand for once. Even the finale wasn't that bad. However, the worst writing ever was dominating the season. Plots were ignored, dropped, or just missed out on. It was a good season, better than ROTI and TDA, but nowhere near the top three.

PI is slowly losing its luster for me. At first, it was better than Island, then it was just below it, now it's behind WT. I liked almost everything about the season, from the great cast to the amazing interactions and stellar animation. However, it had the "3rd Quarter" curse of WT with episodes 8, 9, & 10 and plots were resolved terribly with Skave and Scarlett.

To be honest, I like every character as well, but only to a certain extent. All of them have both impressed me and made my blood boil whenever they're on screen.