User blog comment:TDABeth/My Total Drama All-Stars!/@comment-25297892-20160517221340/@comment-25297892-20160517225201

Ah, only first three seasons, then. Well, still, Noah would have more rights to be considered an All Star than Tyler, considering his popularity in TDWT and his main interaction with Owen and Izzy (also the undeveloped rivalry with Alejandro) compared to Tyler that's known only for Lyler and he's not so popular among fans even after TDWT. In my opinion.