User blog comment:MegamanZero0002/Second All-Stars Speculation and Potential Ideas/@comment-24152851-20140420084930/@comment-24152851-20140422025027

lol, great minds think alike I guess, Brian Froud's return is also the exact reason I deduced why Sam and not Brick was brought back. As Wikipedia have kindly pointed out, Brian Froud is 1 of 3 VA's to feature in a main role in all 5 seasons, but I still think they couldve included Harold (one of the funniest, most interesting, and heroic characters in TD history). So what if that meant less ROTIers, the original cast has been there longer, they deserve to come back more.

I'm not sure if Scott McCord was busy at the time, now that youve brought it up it makes sense. I think he was voicing McGee for Camp Lakebottom at the time. But still, based on how little Sam appeared in All-Stars, I don't think it would have been too much trouble to cram Owen in a similarly short time. I mean they release the series as a whole, it's not like they shoot one episode and air it. Some episodes need to get redubbed anyway so it wouldnt have been too much trouble to put Scott McCord in just a little more.

And while Brick isn't my favourite character, I agree he definetly deserves All-Star status, being so physical skilled, such an asset to his team, and most importantly he has saved several campers lives before.

Another way they could have gone about the problem was if they just included a few more contestants; I mean would having 16 or even 18 contestants be too much to ask? That way they couldve included Owen, Beth and Harold who all deserve All-Stars status. And maybe adding in Anne-Maria or Dawn to balance it out, (Dawn because she's awesome, seems to be the most popular ROTI character, and she is pure of heart having done countless heroic deeds).