User blog comment:Epic~00/Character Appreciation - Week 43: Scott/@comment-30567301-20171026202224

he's just plain annoying i just. in tdri he's practically mal 1.0 where he runs around trying to be a menacing villain (and failing) only mustering up feelings of either indifference or annoyance. do i think he's the worst total drama character ever? no. but he's just not likable, for me, i don't see how he was "redeemed" in all-stars, he felt even more pathetic, just not really enraging. he felt super dumbed down, to the point of lindsay or lightning and his gag didn't really keep me perched cause there's so many pain magnet idiots who's humor is way more varied than his. overall, he doesn't feel important to all-stars either, just an accessory to courtney's story... and he made the final 3.

personally, if scott just has to return, i'd prefer he'd flame out early in a comedic and trainwrecky way. but considering his placements, i wouldn't be surprised to see him as a finalist. help.

best season: n/a

best episode: um. n/a

best moment: being the pivot point of zoey's eternal rage