User blog comment:The Noah Killer/Total Drama Pahkitew Island: My Way/@comment-35606925-20190821011423

Last but not least, we have my recomendations for the first gen. Since there is so many, I'll just talk about my thoughts on all the major characters:

Courtney (she may have made it far in All-Stars, but there is still her showmance with Scott if you want to go down that road.)

Duncan (Duncan has potential but don't bring him back if he's just going to be fodder. The fact is unless you do the break-up or have Duncan see the errors of his ways, he has no plot left from canon. Maybe you can have him cameo.)

Gwen (Gwen is another weird case. She honestly doesn't need to come back unless you have plans for her either. i think her story finished nicely and like Duncan she was already a finalist.)

Owen (I like Owen, but he doesn't need to be here unless RR flat out doesn't happen in your timeline.)

Harold (A fan favorite character. I didn't recomend bringing back Sam since he and Harold share a voice actor and so similar. If you don't want to bring Harold back though, replace B from my previous recomendations with Sam.)

Lindsay (Cool but unneeded. Only consider if not fodder.)

Heather (she won All-Stars. No need for her to be in Finale as her arc is over.)

Noah (My thoughts on Noah are the same as my thoughts on Owen. Besides, he's too similar to Dave.)

Bridgette and Geoff (while the latter has RR, Bridgette is the perfect fit for this season in my eyes. Would also explain why she isn't in RR. Just don't have her win if RR is still in this universe.)

DJ (YES! DJ needs fixing and I trust you'll be able to do it.)

Leshawna (maybe. She won in your version of WT and was also in your version of All-Stars. If Harold is in conisder it but otheriwise don't).

Beth (Another obvious yes in my eyes. Either a decent early boot or one of the few finalists that still needs to prove her worth. Even better if Lindsay is not here.)

Tyler (On the other hand, we've already got enough jocks in this cast. Tyler can fit this one out.)

Alejandro (Maybe. We've already got to see him play without heather but since he didn't win he is one of the few gen one characters that could.)

Cody and Sierra (Since you removed Sierra from All-Stars, she needs to be in finale. Besides, eliminated them so early in WT that their arc didn't get to play out. Cody, if written well, could make a good finalist and you could spend the time to fix Sierra.)

Zeke (NO. He's useless fodder in my eyes and you already allowed him to go a little farther)

Justin (NO. If your bringing back Justin bring back Al instead.)

Eva (NO. If your bringing back Eva bring back Jo instead)

Katie and Sadie (NO. They don't have anything to offer outside of a possible second season of RR.)

That should be everyone. The short version of it, and my final recomendations are the following: Courtney, Beth, Bridgette, DJ, Cody, Sierra, Alejandro, Harold.