User blog comment:ArtDraw12/How could've original TDAS look like?/@comment-1037137-20150808034404

TDAS would've been better if more deserving contestants like Brick, Anne Maria, Harold, LeShawna, or others like them were in and in place of unpopular choices like Sam or Zoke. Either for being true All-Stars or for offering obvious fan favorites some additional development.

Along with actually staying faithful to the plots you set in motion and not abandoning them at the drop of a dime or reneging on them completely after substantial focus and development. And these plots should've promised more positive character development as opposed to the extremely exaggerated and negative portrayals they have instead received. While also keeping continuity and consistency in mind, since not even that was handled with any care when it really counted.

Also, don't make the majority of the challenges homages, but original challeges, though that may have been the least of its problems.

And most importantly, in an All-Star season, give EVERYONE something to walk away with, give all of them some sort of positive to go home with, a payoff for everyone who is a fan of each of those respective contestants. And give them all equal and fair focus, don't ever pull that favoritist BS they did with Zoke.