User blog comment:Gogogadget831/Character Appreciation - Week 48: Sugar/@comment-27157772-20171128042714/@comment-30895873-20171128081154

"Total Drama had made that work with Scott in ROTI" - TDFanatic

First of all, Scott did not work out as an antagonist and comic relief, especially in Revenge of the Island. I tell you, Scott is TERRIBLE in Revenge of the Island.

Scott was bad as an antagonist. Sabotaging people on your team ain't what I call a great strategy. Notable people such as Alejandro and Heather worked well with their strategy of sabotaging other teams. They perfectly mastered the art of villainy. His villainous arc here is kind of forced and bad, that it was hard to watch Revenge of the Island again.

Scott should not be a great comic relief either. I only remembered some moments with the Fang, but that's about it. Nothing memorable about his Revenge of the Island version.

In All Stars, he only remained as a comic relief and nothing else. I personally enjoyed him, but he no longer have the evil lurking around his body. There's nothing that executes well with Scott.

And you call that a comic relief or even a villain?! If you consider Sugar a failure which I will deeply respect, you should also see that to Scott which horribly fails.

While I respect your opinion for you have reasons why you despise Sugar though, but respect my opinion as well.