User blog comment:Total Drama Wiki! Wars/Week of June 9, 2015/@comment-4516085-20150610054121

While Gen 3 has gems like (Sugar, Ella, Jasmine, Amy) it had major DUDS (Beardo, Leonard, Sky, Rodney, and Topher to some percent).

Gen 2 had really great characters like Dakota, Jo, Anne Maria, Lightning, and Dawn to some percent. And it only had 2 really bad characters (Mike and B). Overall I prefer Gen 2 because it is more believable and serious. So my vote is for