User blog comment:BlueBarracudas555/Discussion: Characters that everyone else hates that you LOVE./@comment-4742462-20150731165315/@comment-4742462-20150731233145

He actually receives praise because everyone hated everything else about the season more that it actually made him look "Good" in comparison. I didn't think he was funny as his shtick got very old VERY quickly (which they'd pretty much repeat with Max but just replace "stupid farm boy" with "idiot who tries to be evil but fails"). In my opinion, he doesn't deserve even a small percentage of the praise he gets.

If this Scott was in any season other than All-Stars, he would've been rightfully ripped apart.