User blog comment:CheeseBurgerGuy/Total Drama: The Finales We Never Got/@comment-32999728-20191213125415

Well, I don't think placing top 5 more than once would be an issue since World Tour and All Stars have more than one person that made the final five prior to those seasons.

World Tour had Duncan and Heather

All Stars had Scott and Zoey (not mentioning Gwen and Courtney since they weren't in the final 5 together in a season before All Stars)