User blog comment:Tomas T/Total Drama Revenge Of The Island with the original cast/@comment-31723326-20190913113221

Alright, so I'm assuming the 6 merge campers are all going to All Stars, and now I'll try to guess the surprise All-Star from the pre-merge

Sadie - hahahahahaha no

Katie - see Sadie

Owen - Like the dude, but he's eliminated too early to be in AS

Tyler - First one that got far enough to be considered for the role, he made it as many episodes as Dawn did in and we all know what people feel like with her. However, that's the problem, he only appeared in 5 episodes, so he's a very low chance, but I'll put him in the running.

Bridgette - All-Stars could give Bridgette some development away from Geoff and she made it as many episodes as the canon as the pre-merge camper from ROTI to make it in did, so she's a good possibility IMO

Trent - Possibly, but I'd prefer just having Gwen without him, plus I got the feeling you aren't bringing him back after the note after his elimination.

Geoff - The Most obvious choice, but considering he asked the others to vote him off so he could be with Bridgette I don't think he'll be back, but the fact that he left right before Merge does give him a chance.

So if I had to pick the Pre Merger in All-Stars I would choose either Geoff, Bridgette or Tyler but even then, Tyler is a very small chance and Geoff is probably the one you'll choose.