Thread:Fire Eater/@comment-24078152-20160809131104/@comment-1037137-20160813050757

As one of the show's harsher critics and strongest skeptics, I can tell you that that was never gonna be the case.

I can only say that RR is miles above what either All-Stars or Pahkitew combined were. And it's a better world tour season than, well, World Tour. It has very little of what I hate most about Total Drama. Then again, RR doesn't feature characters I'm sick of seeing be derailed. Either way, I am not mad about spoilers, I was spoiled months ago.

I don't get why we can't just enjoy both. And Gwen really sucks all kinds of ass now. Like Courtney, she's inconsistent and too often unlikable. They've done just as badly with Gwen as they have with Courtney. Little point in debating who's had it worse when both have been bad for many of the same reasons, as well as many different reasons.

Either way, that's no excuse for the appalling writing between the two of them or for the fact that it's Courtney who's been relegated to this treatment. It's got to be dealt with.

No he was fine in Island for the most part, but nowadays I'm glad when I don't see him.

Simply put, they were being stupid and foolish when they wrote All-Stars. And they definitely weren't sure what to do with the season. It's too much of an inconsistent mess for me to believe that they all had a clear plan in mind as the writers rotated between scripts. Absolutely not the case for sure.