User blog comment:Cody Kins TD Fan/Which is the Worst Season Finale: TDAS or TDWT? Note: PLEASE NO MIKE AND ZOEY BASHING!/@comment-1854897-20131206225635/@comment-1037137-20131208053953

Can't say I see the merits of either finale. I'm not foolish, I know they survived that but it still happened, and it all had us wondering for nearly two years what became of them. And look now, everyone is seriously debating the fates of the eight who floated away right now. Some may just be kidding around, others seem pretty serious though about that debate. I mean we all know better, but come on, what a lousy sendoff. First finale not to feature all the losers watching nearby? Why? To tick us off? Because that's exactly what they did. And I remember people for the longest time not really being particularly happy that we had to wait that long to see how the cast fared after supposedly being hit by that volcanic rock, for a while it was a sore point for a good number of people.

In the special he did, but Island itself had a conclusive and satisfying ending. And I'm not talking just the money either. That season ended on a high note. Most of the later ones didn't. Even with Action, I think most folks by that point were just glad to see it end. And TDAS really ended on a very low note, raising more questions than answers and leaving a lot unresolved. Island was pretty much a self-contained season that set out to do many things, and managed to end almost all of it on a high note. The later ones do not. Besides, some running gags are better off allowed to die off. *Cough, Cough* Feral Zeke *Cough, Cough*