User blog comment:AGuyHere/Best and Worst Version of that Character: Gwen/@comment-1037137-20150220033241

TDI Gwen was unquestionably the best version of the character, she was absolutely brilliant and easy to root for in that season. None of the subsequent seasons have even come close to how great she was there. Sure seemed like TDWT Gwen was returning to that former glory, but as you said the love triangle made short work of that, and that really sucked. Hard to sympathize with someone who crosses that line.

TDAS Gwen? So laughable that it's downright insulting. This was her worst and lowest point, where she's stupid, girly, not a goth, and downright unsympathetic by the end. I actually liked that she tried to mend thing with Courtney, and I was all for a Gwuncan breakup, but neither was handled smartly or with much common sense. And everything else was downright idiotic. Everything that made Gwen great in TDI is absolutely not present here.