User blog comment:Amandatho/Are the All-Stars even All-Stars?/@comment-2181164-20131014025345

"All-Stars that are OK, in my opinion, are Courtney, Duncan, Gwen, Mike, Heather, Alejandro, Zoey, Lightning, and Scott. Lindsay, Jo, Cameron, Sam, and Sierra are not All-Stars at all. OK, maybe Lindsay and Lightning were"

You do realize that Courtney, Duncan, Gwen and Heather are one of the best characters in the series, right? Alejandro and Sierra only competed in one season and made it to the top four (not to mention winning several challenges on their own). Lightning, Cameron, Scott and Zoey are considered All Stars for their placement in TDRI meanwhile Mike and Jo just merged. Lindsay is an All-Star as well.

"Trent, Owen, Izzy, and Dakota should have been in this season."

Trent only qualified for two seasons, Dakota competed in a total of 3 1/2 episodes, as for Izzy and Owen, I'm not too sure why they didn't return. However, they would be a better choice rather than Sam. Sam is pretty much the only person in this cast that isn't an All Star.