User blog comment:TotalDramaAndrew/Ranking on the Male Finalists in Total Drama/@comment-25793496-20140503204451/@comment-24152851-20140504143901

I honestly wouldn't rank those 2 far apart, they were both pretty strong in their own way. I suppose Heather did have a higher success rate, but that's because prior to Al, she was the only real villain and the writers needed to keep her around.