User blog comment:Spiderguy56/How to fix Total Drama All Stars/@comment-25297892-20150605105149

Cast Choice: pick not only the screenhoggers from first generation, so to have the grant to have more new interactions than the usual (and boring) ones seen again in TDAS (Duncan-Courtney-Gwen in especially). Also, you can't do a cast of All Stars with so few true heroic and villainous characters, they should have renounced to this theme because the heroes lacked of Dawn, Harold, DJ, Trent, Noah, Bridgette all victims of previous villains and/or examples of total good people. On the other side, if they wanted to do a true All Stars, they should have featured Harold, Izzy, Bridgette and Leshawna in the Heroic Hamsters, while the villains..eh, this is the main problem, the only one they left was Justin, but is he a true villain? No. So, the Whole all star idea should have been postponed after Pahkitew:

Heroic Hamsters: Mike, Zoey, Harold, Owen, Izzy, Lindsay, Cody, Sierra, Cameron, Shawn, Sky and Jasmine.

Villainous Vultures: Heather, Alejandro, Courtney, Gwen (courtesy of Chris), Duncan, Scott, Jo, Shugar, Dave, Scarlett, Lightning and Samey (courtesy of Chris because she's confused with her evil twin).

OTHERWISE, removing the all star idea, they could have done a Hero vs Villains season without the exclusive use of most famous contestants, and so it could have featured underdogs from TDI and TDROTI, too.

So..

Heroic Hamsters: Lindsay, Harold, Owen, Izzy, Noah (being unfairly eliminated in TDWT), Mike, Zoey, Dawn (being unfairly eliminated in ROTI), Brick (because of his heroic sacrifice) and Cameron.

Villainous Vultures: the original VV + some more minor villains like Justin, Eva, and Tyler.