User blog comment:Attackin/Why I think Sugar was the worst antagonist/@comment-25285054-20170311182033

To me Scott and Mal were worse antagonist because the way they dumbed down the casts actively made the season worse, at least for me. With Sugar, her prescenes (imo) was at least fairly harmless. Using "this is how many eliminations they caused" is a shallow way of judging the antagonits anyway.

Amy would have been a terrible antagonist. When she doesn't have Samey to push around, she's got nothing.

Scarlett could have potentially done the whole evil pyschopath thing a bit better than Mal, but much like him her archetype doesn't fit Total Drama too well. Maybe if she was just toned down to being a sane evil genius who uses her inteligence to mastermind the elimination order?

The fact that so many antagonistic characters are easily identifiable leads me to believe Pahkitew had way too much going on for a 13 episode season