User blog comment:TheDipDap1234/Scarlett - a Good or a Bad character?/@comment-2147650-20141112233032

To me, Scarlett was always neutral, leaning towards a more positive rating.

In my rankings, she is ranked 7th out of the 14 contestants that appeared in Total Drama: Pahkitew Island. Before the season started, she was ranked 11th out of the 14, being my least favorite female.

I feel as though the problem with Scarlett, is that she got way too much hype... and it didn't really die down. Spoilers emerged that she had a dark side and that got people really excited to see her in action. At the big reveal, you either loved her that much more or she just remained neutral (like with me). I rarely see a Scarlett hater, which is probably because those users just liked the other characters more or hated the others more. Either way, it's rare.

Also, I do feel as though her interactions were really limited. I don't understand how people can complain about Topher rarely interacting with anyone except Chris, but don't complain about how Scarlett did the same thing with Max. If her villain-ness was played out throughout the whole season, then she probably would've been a better villain in my opinion, but she kinda just blew herself up. So yeah, I do think that Scarlett is a good-ish character (mildly entertaining) but is also overrated at the same time.