I Love You, I Love You Knots

'''The host makes the teams go through a truth-or-dare showdown. Someone has to face up to their guilt regarding their problems with another contestant, the attraction between two campers grows stronger, and two competitors keep being tormented over and over. Ultimately someone's issues in being truthful with who they like end up making them tongue-tied and eliminated.'''

Plot
The episode begins the same as the previous two: with Jasmine heading out to forage for the morning's meal. Samey asks if she needs help, and the latter seems suspicious of "Amy" for behaving so nicely. Samey then directs a rude comment at Jasmine, who comments that she's getting the hang of acting like her sister. In the confessional, Samey informs the audience that Jasmine remains the only person aware of her identity. She sticks half a blueberry to her right cheek to imitate Amy's mole, explaining she has to now "sound and look" like her. The friends meet Shawn in the forest as usual. Jasmine asks if he would like to join them to pick berries. He retreats instead of stopping, pulling companion Dave with him. Shawn is still terrified of his feelings for Jasmine (or, more specifically, the possibility of her turning into a zombie and him not being able to kill her). Dave thinks that Jasmine is attracted to Shawn, and also doesn't bathe, commenting, "This place is weird."

With Rodney and Scarlett, she prevents him from stepping in feces, which makes him fall in love with her. Samey offers him berries at breakfast and he becomes infatuated with her as well. Rodney realizes that now he has three "girlfriends" (Amy, Jasmine, and Scarlett) and is conflicted on how to choose between them. Pimâpotew Kinosewak discuss how the berries "Amy" gathered are better than anything Samey ever got. She is visibly angry before Chris gathers everyone for the challenge. Ella invites Sugar to sit next to her, but the latter pushes her off for the issue of "camera time." Chris sees this and sarcastically sympathizes with Ella. Topher compliments Chris, but the host is noticeably irritated at him for doing so. The challenge is an intensified version of Truth or Dare, called "Truth or Scare." Above Chris is a wheel that will randomly select a contestant along with a halo (truth) or a flame (scare). If someone fails a scare or is untruthful, their whole team is shocked with the help of electric collars encircling everyone's neck. During the explanation, the wheel displays Amy's image, and Samey looks on guiltily. Chris introduces Clucky, a chicken with the ability to detect when someone's lying. As Amy is the first spun, Samey is the first to participate. Chris asks her who she hates the most. Samey confesses that it's Amy. Clucky verifies that she's telling the truth, but the others are confused that she supposedly hates herself. Topher calls it "deep." When she seems she is going to admit the truth, Jasmine stands up and reassures "Amy" that Samey's failures weren't her fault. The other contestants agree while badmouthing Samey.

Rodney gets truth and has to answer who he thinks is the most attractive girl on the island. He struggles between choosing from "Amy," Jasmine and Scarlett. Sugar interrupts that it's her, and Rodney goes along with it. Clucky shocks the Pimâpotew Kinosewak. Sugar becomes agitated and says that the chicken is "broken." Ella attempts to cheer her up, but ends up making her fume even more. The next camper to be spun is Sky, who is required to drink an entire jug of mineral water in under thirty seconds. She goes incredibly slowly with her team commenting on her frustrating speed. Shawn takes control by shaking the jug and spraying the liquid into Sky's mouth. He states that it's just another zombie survival tactic. She burps, but it's excessively minor, contrary to what Jasmine and the others suspect. Topher is disappointed by the lack of drama. Sky's stomach is still rumbling, prompting her team members to sit away from her. Next it is Max's turn. He is assigned truth. Clucky approaches him and he recoils as Chris asks what he is most afraid of. Max insists that he fears nothing, earning his team a shock.

Dave goes after him. He is okay with telling the truth and claims he has nothing to hide. However, he gets scare instead. Challenging Dave's germ sensitivity, Chris says he must kiss the mouth of a contestant sitting next to him: Shawn or Sky. Shawn bolts without a single word, citing suspicion he will bite him, thus turning him into a zombie. Dave is elated at what this means. He and Sky lean in to satisfy the challenge, but she belches in his face. In the confessional, she reveals she has a habit of doing this whenever she's nervous (like when in the presence of a guy she likes), but persists that it was the mineral water that caused it. Waneyihtam Maskwak is electrocuted. Shawn is dared to pick his nose and wipe it on a competitor next to him. There is no one to his left, and Dave takes hint by automatically getting up and running away. Shawn shoots a "snot rocket" at him, covering Dave and the rest of the team in mucus. Clearly in disgust, he attempts to calm himself down. Chris corrects that he had to pick his nose, not shoot a rocket, and so, Maskwak fails again.

It is Ella's turn next and she is selected to answer a question. She welcomes Clucky onto her lap, and Chris asks what she would change about herself if she could. She replies she would change whatever is preventing her and Sugar from being friends. The latter notices when she begins using "pageant speak" and lunges at her. Dave and Shawn hold her back. Even though Clucky judges Ella's answer as truth, Chris declares there's no way it could be and electrocutes the team anyway. The following challenges proceed quickly. Sky puts braces on a beaver, Rodney refuses to answer who he would save from his team, Scarlett beautifies a bear, and Jasmine feeds an iguana with just her mouth. Rodney simply sighs when it is his turn, resulting in Kinosewak being shocked once again. Sugar eats a tarantula although all she had to do was pet it.

After this, Chris ends the game and announces a "sudden death" round, during which each team will be represented by one person: Rodney for Kinosewak and Ella for Maskwak. There are no truths in the next round, only scares. Rodney taunts Clucky that she has no power anymore, adding that he eats eggs for breakfast daily. This infuriates her and she goes to attack, but Chris calms her down. The challenge is to untie a bag containing a remote programmed to the other team's collars. The winner is the camper who retrieves the control and activates them. Rodney's fingers are too large, while Ella easily gets hers open. She tries to offer him some help, but she is urged by Chris to press the button, shock Kinosewak, and win. She decides that she can't do it. However, Clucky snatches the remote and repeatedly shocks Kinosewak for Rodney's words.

After the challenge, Dave and Sky meet up, but she becomes nervous again and runs away. Her belching can be heard in the distance as he begs no one in particular for a "sign" of how she feels. At the elimination ceremony, Rodney and Scarlett are in the bottom two. Chris struggles to explain why she could be there and eventually gives up. Scarlett gets her marshmallow and Rodney is put into the Cannon of Shame. Before he is shot, he clumsily confesses his love for Amy, Jasmine, and Scarlett. Chris signs off the episode afterwards.

Cast

 * Chef Hatchet appears; however, he has no lines.

General

 * This is the first episode written by Miles Smith.
 * Topher is the only competitor who is not shown being called on to participate in the challenge.
 * Sky reveals she has a habit of belching when she gets nervous.
 * Rodney reveals in this episode that he eats six eggs a day.
 * This is the only episode, in which Ella appears, but doesn't sing at all.

Continuity

 * This is the second episode containing the phrase "I Love You" in the title, the first being I Love You, Grease Pig!.
 * This is the third challenge to reference the game "Truth or Dare", the other times were I Triple Dog Dare You! and Truth or Laser Shark.
 * This is the second episode of the series that a contestant doesn't appear despite technically still being active in the competition.
 * This is due to Samey posing as Amy, after having her sister be eliminated in her place.
 * It also happened in Zeek And Ye Shall Find, where Mike's evil alternate Mal had taken over control over his host.
 * The music heard when the contestants are selected is the same as the one that plays when the Wheel of Misfortune is spun.

Goofs

 * In a pan shot across Sugar and Ella, there is a point where Ella's bow is missing from her headband.
 * After Scarlett completes a challenge, instead of the Pimapotew Kinosewak getting a point, it's the Waneyihtam Maskwak who get it.
 * Rodney's chin cleft disappears several times during this episode.
 * When Sugar was about to attack Ella, Sky's hair seems to be normal, but in the next scene, it appears to be messed up again.
 * When Chris spins the wheel one time for the Pimapotew Kinosewak, it shows Samey without her mole.