User blog comment:Smv21/My Total Drama Season Rankings/@comment-4742462-20180516000710/@comment-4742462-20180517034306

As I said earlier, after thinking it through more I'd say that RR would be considered to be on-par with TDA if there'd been no TDAS to make it look better in comparison. But you're right, TDPI would've definitely been considered the worst had there been no TDAS beforehand.

And again, I feel like some of the praise RR got was only because of TDAS existing first since the former makes a lot of the same mistakes that it (and TDPI) made. Plus, having the show return to 26 episodes I felt made many of those mistakes not as easy to pick up on.

And yet you've got people who still rank TDWT at least one spot higher than RR. At least the former had a mostly enjoyable first half whereas RR pretty much slowly began to fall apart as early as the fourth episode and only got worse the further it continued on.