User blog comment:Christlover357/Characters You've Changed Your Mind On/@comment-25285054-20141017164000/@comment-4742462-20141019135112

TDPIScarlett: Scott's change to me came across as a poorly written attempt by the writers to make him likable after being one of the most hated characters last season. But it doesn't work because of how abrupt it is, pulling a Cody (floating all the way to 3rd place), and the change counting as being derailment since he was more on-par with his Revenge of the Island self in the first few episodes.

I think the only reason why the floater of All-Stars seems to get a free pass is because most of the people hated everyone else in the Final 4 more by this point.