User blog comment:HammerBro101/How I Would Rewrite Total Drama All-Stars/@comment-31723326-20180620062622/@comment-31723326-20180620072023

just because you hate characters, doesn't mean you should discount them from the All Star Season, I hate Sugar, but if there was to be an All Star season with the third gen campers, just going by Pakithew Island, I would put Sugar in it, because she is a major character, Leshawna made merge in 2 Seasons and Zoey made top 3 in her first season just like Sugar, and I already talked about Heather, it's not just your personal opinions that make the character roster, if they appeared as much as Heather, even if she is your least fave character, she should be in the characters.

I get you have more reasons to dislike SMS, but you could bring a few more of them up, like the chart, I know that is partially to do with Courtney's elimination, but you could say how that is somewhat out of character for Courtney post season 1.

I get the point with Gwen, but you could say some of the plots in another section, and put that the Love Triange plot is resolved in episode 5 for example, and then eliminate her in episode 5 or 6

I'm fine with Sierra getting replaced, she is horrible in All Stars and Izzy is reasonably All Stary so yeah, that's the one character change i'm fine with.

Ironic that you hate Staci, yet give her a cameo and not even mention Heather

As I said in the first comment, Owen could simply be the 1st out

I don't think Lightning and Alejandro shouldn't be finalists BECAUSE Lightning and Alejandro made final 2 before, As much as I love Duncan, I don't think he should make final 2 in All Stars because he made Final 2 in Action