User blog comment:WhatZoeyhasfans/Which season do you guys thinks is better Total Drama Action or Total Drama All Stars/@comment-2002887-20131109044719

It really comes down to which characters you're most a fan of and you're most attached to. If your favorite character is Gwen, you'd prefer TDAS. If your favorite character is Beth (I remember Beth's fan base grew after TDA because she was more relevant and less stupid, plus HER BOYFRIEND IS REAL), then you'd prefer TDA. If you hate reward challenges and aftermaths, TDAS>TDA, but the opposite is likely true if you prefer 26 episode seasons. I'm a huge fan of Total Drama and even if I had to rank the seasons, there wouldn't be a significant gap between 1st and 5th place. Mainly because there's only 5 seasons to rank. It's easier for me to say my favorite episodes, characters, challenges, couples, and so on.