User blog comment:ArtDraw12/TD Theories: Who May Return in Potential Future Seasons?/@comment-2212492-20160619164058

You can actually feel Brick's presence on Total Drama All Stars. Despite being eliminated, it's easy to see what he would've gone through while competing. Somewhere along the lines of the third episode, he would've been the one to take out Jo instead of Zoey,  resulting in him getting he upperhand this time around.

He would have a fate similar to Cameron's in Moon Madness but would have survived through the madness. I think he would've gotten eliminated by Suckers Punched, either by refusing to fight Jo or the other team deciding to eliminate him as he was a threat.