Thread:Fire Eater/@comment-1141831-20140323173636/@comment-1037137-20140323181632

Apology accepted, even though I fully admit to being a pessimist. But it's not without some cause that I've come to being one here. The show's been hit and miss for a very long time, and lately it's been mostly some very big misses. Island's the only season I can say is entirely watchable again in its entirety, and while Revenge I thought was decent, still not without flaws. The others though are pretty bad.

I wish I shared your optimism that you expressed on that page but some bad news there man, the folks who wrote All-Stars wrote for Pahkitew Island before being let go. So I'm not particularly certain a revival is what we're in for. And I still am not a fan of most of these designs, they just lack the appeal of the first two casts. I don't how else to explain it.

Is the return of McGillis and Pertsch as directors a good thing? Only time will tell. But I won't miss Hicks and Oliver.