User blog comment:Superdawnfan/People Thought To Make Great Main Villains But Wouldn't/@comment-26910203-20161127054235

No offense... but where does this even come from? The writers can honestly make almost anyone a villain if they really feel like it, look at Courtney and the creation of Mal which the creators basically pulled out of their bums for AS.

The characters in TD are hardly consistent and periodically change. You don't think they would change certain aspects or emphasize certain traits to make a character more fit for a main antagonist role? They've certainly done it before. This is why it annoys me when people say "so and so is not suited for an antagonist role" as if we actually know anything. Obviously someone like Owen is probably not going to be an antagonist but we don't really see people suggesting him now do we?

It's really not that far fetched for characters like Amy, Eva, or Duncan to be main villains (even if I don't necessarily agree). For craps and giggles, I'm actually gonna rebuttal your arguments for Amy and Duncan. For Amy, put her and Samey on different teams, now she actually has to try to get far in the game to one up her sister, problem solved. For Duncan, "he isn't the type to cheat", I specifically remember him cheating in Princess Pride and I'm sure there are other times he also hasn't been shown to be soft on the inside since Island.