User blog comment:ArtDraw12/Total Drama Horror 3 - Episode 1/@comment-31556666-20170304050916

Amy will survive in either scenario, mark my words. The thing is that killing and sparing her could have completely different consequences in future.

On the one hand, "killing" her could either lead to her death straight away, make her think her sister is more strong willed, or not trust her sister at all and possibly sacrifice her.

Sparing her could make Samey be more trustworthy to her but could also make her a pushover.

BUT, I think we should ALL go for B because of the OBVIOUS pun here. Spare Amy. Sparemy. Yes I know, a very cringe moment in the show. But I get the reference. And I think it points to that we should spare her.