User blog comment:MiraculousWizardsDeepTNSDramaDragonsMarvel Fan/Total Drama Theory: What If All - Stars Was After Pahkitew Island/@comment-37411074-20200114235936/@comment-35606925-20200115182919

Who I would consider All-Stars and in order of importance (based on Island-WT):

1. Owen (Won the first season (canonically) and merged twice since)

2. Duncan (Has made the Top 5 thrice, and was a finalist in the second season.)

3. Heather (The orignal antagonst, made the final 3 twice, and won WT)

4. Alejandro (finalist in a season where he was one of only two newbies)

5. Gwen (finalist in the very first season)

6. Lindsay (merged twice, auto-eliminated two of her three seasons, final two with Beth)

7. Beth (winner of the second season)

8. Leshawna (merged twice)

9. Cody (removed due to injury in his first season and made top 3 in his second)

10. Sierra (top 4 in a season she was one of only two newbies)

11. Courtney (merged twice, even if she had to debeut to do it)

12. Harold (merged once and holds one of the most iconic moves in Total Drama history)

13. DJ (merged once, was the last survivng member of Team Victory)

After this point, I don't think an argument can really be made.