User blog comment:Epic~00/Why Total Drama All Stars Was Such An Abysmal Season (PART 6)/@comment-27013391-20150328015340/@comment-31556666-20150328131551

Uh, that's not the reason Scott was liked. Long before the worst Final 4 ever, Scott was still popular in AS. Thinking of him as the least bad in the F4 has nothing to do with that.

And like I've already pointed out, Scott just wasn't derailed. His stupidity and comic relief personality in AS remained consistent. This is completely different to the other inconsistent people who had their personalities altered in every episode. Scott was the only contestant to actually have this expanded comedy remain consistent with him throughout his 12 episodes, whereas everyone else just changed every couple of episodes for no explainable reason.