User blog comment:Stryzzar/Who is the Greatest Antagonist?/@comment-12762816-20140609192029/@comment-24152851-20140610013022

Well Scott is inept the most hated antagonists, no question there. But he's quite an effective antagonist in his own right, as he tore apart the ROTI cast, while Courtney is definitely a better character, but she's not quite as proficient more as an antagonist, which is justified since she had a lot less experience than others (only genuinely starting in Total Drama Drama Drama Drama Island). She played a very dangerous game and was targeted by everyone since Day 1 of her return. She basically used Heather's strategy but didn't pull it off with the same amount of success.

I don't think u can count Scott's second elimination, because that was after he turned into an idiot and wasn't the slightest bit villainous anymore. And he actually made it further than her in TDAS, and lasted longer in their antagonistic seasons since Courtney came in half way.

One of the main reasons why he's so hated is because he kicked out all of the really loved characters from the new cast like Dawn and Dakota.

If this was a poll about who's a better character than Courtney would kick his sorry little butt, hands down.