User blog comment:Epic~00/In Defense of: Duncan/@comment-25027229-20150326231046

While I'm not a fan of his and enjoyed watching him get dragged to prison (best karma ever), I won't deny how important and well-written he has been.

In TDI, he was awesome, but a bit of a bully, but that was in his character. He knew how to play the game and should've been in the finale over Owen, but the writers just had to have their fart jokes. -_-

TDA Duncan was great until he started surviving eliminations like Lindsay's and had his "friendship" with Harold destroyed by Owen. His rivalry with Courtney was great though and doesn't get enough love in this season.

But in TDWT, he is ruined for me. Returning mid-season, forcing the Noah/Alejandro rivalry out the plane, and immediately cheating on Courtney without even caring about Gwen but a little? Boo!!!! He was great without Gwen ans Courtney around, but he was just so annoying in the third quarter that I can't even tolerate him for the rest of the season.

TDAS Duncan was near perfection. He had depth, great comedy, and finally received karma for everything he's done to others on the show. Becoming a hero, only to stick to his roots and get burned by it was glorious and carried a good message for the kids to boot. Too bad his thing with Mal was tossed aside. The one time I WANTED him to go far since Island... and nope. Oh well.

Overall, he's not even close to my top five because of his treatment of others and lack of remorse, but he's a good character though, just not my type of character.