User blog comment:Asriel Meemurr (Ellafan4evr)/Which TD season is your favorite and why?/@comment-4389268-20140811135855/@comment-5956575-20140811194955

I agree. Season 1 did take out all of the "filler" characters early. All of the important characters were the characters that lasted longer than Cody (or at least characters who began to gain more significance). With action, although most on this site may not be a fan of it, I loved the Duncan-Harold rivalry, Lindsay and Beth's amazing development. And I loved how they foreshadowed Duncan and Beth being in the final two when Leshawna was doing her pep-cheer song in Million Dollar Babies.

Not much to say for TDPI as it was one of the more excellent seasons. It truly was worth watching, and for 13 episodes, kept me engaged in the story. Sort of agreed about TDWT. Although I love season 3 as well, and whether people hate Duncan/Courtney/Gwen post-Greeces Pieces, Duncan was keeping the story interesting (to me at least). And agreed, I hated that they made Al a villain stu and Sierra excel at most things (at least when determined enough). You had about half the cast of season three being punked by Al (who was a good antagonist), but they looked like fodder.

The rest doesn't have much to comment on as TDAS ruined several characters. On top of that, it trashed several characters in favor for others that weren't quite developed enough.