User blog comment:PokemonTDHTF98/TDAS: What if Courtney is Replaced with another contestant./@comment-26897147-20141022102042

Hate to break it to you, but you can't just "replace" Courtney in TDAS. It's not an all star season without Courtney, one of the show's best characters.

Putting that aside, I would probably go with Leshawna. Dakota and Dawn are not all stars in the slightest bit, Izzy hasn't even been around in the competition long enough to be an all star, and plus she isn't even used as an actual character, rather as a joke. As for Bridgette, she's only competed in 23 episodes, which is half the amount Leshawna's competed in so I personally consider her a semi all star.