User blog comment:Epic~00/Ranking Total Drama Characters By Morality: Part 2 - 42-33/@comment-2091662-20140729173458/@comment-24152851-20140730030027

Noah, Izzy and Sierra may have "maintained their flaws", but they were substantially less evil to begin with and fall into hero territory. Even with Scott's redemption he's still a villain. Being a redeemed villain doesn't automatically make you better than a flawed hero (of course in some cases they can be, but Scott has not done enough good, he still has a fair share of evil deeds in TDAS such as sabotaging the Hamsters in Ep. 2, or pushing Cameron into the water - I know Cam asked for it and it was called for, but it's still an evil deed).