User blog comment:TheDipDap1234/My Top 10 Favorite TD/RR Eliminations/@comment-3394399-20160411114642/@comment-22535514-20160411225556

I agree that Harold and Lindsay would have been better finalists than Beth and Duncan, and I was annoyed when both were eliminated. If you are going to complain about Beth not having any plot (though she had some relevance), than that should be said about Duncan as well. He did nothing of note during the first half, and his redundant, repetition of a relationship with Courtney was repeated, and sucked dry.

TDA is not that well liked amongst people because it is clear that the producers were throwing things at the wall to see what would stick. The narriative was not as strong as it was in other seasons.