User blog:Flagator24/Pahkitew Island vs. All Stars which one was worse?

Pahkitew Island and All Stars are considered the worst seasons of Total Drama. But which one is worse?

Here are the pros and cons of each season-

All Stars-

Pros

The interaction between both cast.

This was pretty cool that original cast members competing against revenge of the island cast members.

Return of the McLean brand Chris Head.

This was pretty cool the show making fun of Survivor even more.

Alejandro leaving the robot suit.

Hey Aleheather can return.

The Heroes vs. Villians concept

Reminding us who was a hero and villain of the series.

Cons

Gwen on the villains team

Of course remind us about the scene that ruined I see London.... and caused Noah's elimination (who became a fan favorite overnight in a way)

Scottney

Don't ask me why this couple exist. Oops you kissed on accident which makes you a couple.

The Final two

Zoey vs. Mike? Seriously it should of been Lindsay vs. Courtney.

Made before Pahkitew Island.

Okay it would be awesome for all three generations to compete against each other. Like a Jasmine vs. Courtney finale would be awesome.

The derailments

There were many derailments with characters this season

Cameron almost going crazy with only trusting Mike and Zoey and only not trusting anyone that was on the villians team.

Sierra almost going crazy because of her obsession with Cody and not having her smart phone.

Duncan becoming Mr. Nice Guy when we went on the heroes team.

Lindsay not knowing how to push a cart.Hey she was always dumb but not this dumb.

The reset button

Do I need to say more?

Sam returning

I'm not a big fan of Sam in general they could of brought back Owen instead and have the same way of being eliminated. (Owen sneaking pancakes into his pockets instead of Sam)

The contestants floating away

Like are they dead? The balloons should of popped at the end of the episode.

Making one of Mike's alternate personalities the villain.

Nice learning about Mike's past but Mal just mainly destroyed stuff and whistled.

Camp Wawanakwa sinking

This just made the finale even worse than what it was.

The flush of shame

Hey I like potty humor as much as the next guy but this was just plain dumb.

Lack of writers

Really this season only had four writers?

Pahkitew Island -

Pros

New Cast

It was interesting to see a new cast

The main couple was better than the previous season's new couple

Shawn and Jasmine is short of better than Zoey and Mike.

Scarlett going rogue

Hey she was almost an unexpected villain until she fixed Max's inventions and almost killing the contestants in Scarlett fever.

Amy and Samey's conflict

This sibling rivalry was almost the only good conflict in the season since it wasn't one sided. Besides the way Samey got revenge on Amy was great.

The final two was good

The final two wasn't great but better than the All Stars final two.

It short of made fun of Survivor even more.

Since Pahkitew island was mostly artificial and the team names meaning Confused bears and Floating Salmon. Since other locations were an old abandoned summer camp ,old abandoned film lot, and the world.

The Horror movie episode was good

Hurl and go seek wasn't great but a funny zombie apocalypse parody and Chris referencing Here comes Honey Boo Boo by saying TV broadcast standards not getting that low was great.

Cons

Lack of originality with the cast members

Almost all of this cast has parodies of a character or person from other TV shows or movies

Shawn's name is pretty much a reference to Shaun of the dead and Jude from the Fresh TV show 6teen

Dave is based off a character from Old School

Ella is a parody of a Disney princess

Sugar is a parody of Honey Boo Boo

Jasmine is a parody of Mindy Irwin

Max is a parody of Dr. Evil

Leonard is based off of a character from role models

Topher is a parody of Ryan Seacreast

Ella not realizing Sugar didn't like her

At least Lindsay figured out Heather didn't like her and we all know how that turned out.I would pay to see Ella cuss out Sugar the same way Lindsay did.

Dave's derailment in Hurl and go seek and Lies,cries and one big prize

Dave became crazy when Sky rejected him and cried like three times in Lies Cries and one big prize.

Sugar making it further than she should have.

Sugar is probably the worst character in Total Drama since she is a parody of somebody from one of the worst reality shows in the history of television.

All stars

Pros-4 Cons-9

Pahkitew Island

Pros-6 cons-4

So All Stars is worse Than Pahkitew Island.

What's your opinion? What season do you think is worse?