User blog comment:Numbuhthreefan/What contestants I do and don't want to see in TD S6?/@comment-1943341-20170517002221

I think almost half of the Pahkitew Island cast will not return if season 6 is an "All Stars 2" between the 3 generations. Why?

Beardo - Weird character that lacks much of an actual character. 100% Gag character.

Leonard - Entertaining gag character. Hilarious he got booted early twice cause he sucks. 3 times would be overkill. Developing this character at all would ruin the character. Character is better left alone now.

Topher - All he did was worship Chris - then tries to take his job. Character is too tied down to the host and Chris doesn't even like him. Bringing him back to Total Drama would not make sense since Chris makes the calls as to who to bring back.

Ella - (Yes, I know hate me all you want) But she's a legit princess. She's delusional. She is just as bad as Leonard tbh. Bringing her back would waste a spot for a better character.

Max - Lovable Evil gag character. Although bringing him back to the show would not make sense since Chris got fed up with him and he makes the calls as to whom to bring back. His only scheme is being "evil" and it may not work for a 2nd season.

Scarlette - She actually is diabolical and insane. Bringing her back wouldn't make sense (like Max). Chris doesn't even like her.

That leaves: Amy, Samey, Jasmine, Shawn, Dave, Sky, Sugar, and Rodney as the only potentials to return. I think all of that would make sense as they have more realistic characters than the other half of the cast...well...except maybe Shawn. But, Shawn did make the finale afterall. Although, I don't think he has all that big a fanbase.