User blog comment:LoganParvatiTD225/Was SMS Courtney's well deserved TDA karma?/@comment-1764858-20150718150023/@comment-1037137-20150718184812

In TDA possibly. But in TDAS? NO. In that season it was totally uncalled for. And you do not, I repeat, you do NOT build up an entire arc like that where more than one character seems to finally be coming back around and finally seeing their redeeming traits come back to form, to play all of that so genuinely and then at the last minute invalidate all of it. You don't do that, whatever their thinking was you don't do that and then make everyone feel it was a waste of time.

Some may feel she dodged karma too long or hate her enough that they don't care about any other aspects behind this mess, but there are plenty of reasons why this was entirely uncalled for and why it just goes way past the extreme in something that if they were gonna do it, it should've been done years ago and not when it seemed like a redemption arc might've finally taken hold only to find out that they were not sincere about it.

There's nothing to debate, what they did was disgusting.