User:Totaldrama100/Rankings

1st Generation Rankings

I'll only go over a season if the character appears for more than three scenes. A.K.A.  not including the 24 cast cameo in the beginning of TDROTI. More to come for the TDAS characters except for maybe Lindsay and Sierra.

Oppose

24. Sierra - In TDA she was okay. Her inter viewing the contestants but never getting any real gossip was decent. In TDWT she was really annoying. She kept talking about Cody, revealing embarrassing secrets about Chris and was really disturbing and creepy. In TDAS she was REALLY annoying and I mean it. Her first line was "for CODY!". With no Cody around, she was obsessed with her cell phone for the first three episodes. When TMO broke it she went crazy and started hallucinating her whole team as Cody. She also started to hallucinate that Cameron was Cody, disturbing him enough to be transferred to the villains side. Seriously, Cameron a villain is like saying Heather is an angel.

TDA - 5/10 TDWT - 3/10 TDAS - 2/10

23. Harold - In TDI he was okay. He stayed in the background not talking much. Then in TDA he went bonkers. All he would do is ramble on and on about his mad skills for 23 episodes. His team was annoyed with him but they won so much that he was spared. This season his crush with Leshawna developed but not by much. In TDWT he was such a know it all. He poked Ezekiel in the eye and bragged about his knowledge of Japan. Thank god he quit in Episode 3 or TDWT would be my least favorite season instead of TDA. Even more good news! He didn't cameo in TDROTI or compete in TDAS. Although I despise him, the only reason why I hate Sierra more than him is because of his heroic actions. He did save eight people's lives and helped win a couple of challenges in the first two seasons. All she would do is stalk Cody.

TDI - 6/10 TDA - 3/10 TDWT - 2/10

22. Beth - In TDI she was okay. She was in the background for half of her run. Her alliance with Heather was weak. Lindsay was the bigger ally making Beth just there. She stood up to Heather but it wasn't much. In TDA she was really boring. More boring than Zoey. She was just Lindsay's bestie and Justin's pawn. How she made it to the finals is anyone's guess. Fortunately she didn't compete for TDWT. In the aftermaths she was just there. No Beth in later seasons! Smart move producers!

TDI - 5/10 TDA - 3/10 TDWT - 2/10

21. Justin - In TDI he was silent. In TDA he was the worst "antagonist" ever! If no one had ever said Justin was the season's antagonist BC, I would have no idea who it would be. I don't think charming people and making them your slaves deserves for you to be called a season's antagonist. Thank god Courtney came or this season would NO drama at all. In TDWT he was part of the Drama Brothers and then never spoke again. The only reason he's not lower is because he's not annoying and has a funny voice. He was narcissism was okay although Chris's was better.

TDI - 2/10 TDA - 3/10 TDWT - 2/10

Neutral

20. Ezekiel - In TDI he was sexist and the first one gone. In TDA he had like one line? In TDWT he was the first one out and became a monster. In TDROTI he was still a monster. In TDAS his monster form was used as a cruel joke. I'm not a Zeke fan but man, that's cruel! That monster joke got old before it even started. In episode 9 of TDAS, the title is Zeek and You Shall Find. I guess that means he'll be a monster for 3 whole seasons. He seems like a pretty nice guy if you get to know him, but he's neutral because we hardly no anything about him. But look on the bright side, he appeared in all five seasons. Even if 2 of them are monster Zeke seasons.

TDI - 3/10 TDA - 2/10 TDWT - First Half - 5/10 - Second Half - 1/10 TDROTI - 1/10 TDAS - 1/10

19. Katie - In TDI she was annoying. In TDA she was annoying and formed a crush on Trent. In TDWT that crush continues. She's annoying but we hardly know anything about her. Her friendship with Sadie and crush on Trent are annoying. I do have my sympathies for this character though. She only lasted six episodes in the only season she competed in. In later seasons she was just a peanut gallery member. But on the bright side, she was one the non-competing members that talked a lot.

TDI - 4/10 TDA - 3/10 TDWT - 2/10

18. Sadie - In TDI she was annoying. In TDA she was annoying and formed a crush on Trent. In TDWT that crush continues. She's annoying but we hardly know anything about her. Her friendship with Katie and crush on Trent are annoying. I do have my sympathies for this character though. She only lasted eleven episodes in the only season she competed in. In later seasons she was just a peanut gallery member. But on the bright side, she was one the non-competing members that talked a lot.

TDI - 4/10 TDA - 3/10 TDWT - 2/10

17. Owen - In TDI he was decent. Although he didn't deserve to WIN. Sure he had gross jokes but since it was the first season and still fresh, I'll let it pass. In TDA it's obvious karma hates him. His system was "clogged" in episodes one and two. His jaw was broken by Chef in episode 10. His girlfriend was eliminated twice. He was unfairly voted off by Courtney in episode 13 and his family is now broke due to a $50,000 cheese cellar. The karma paid off when he returned to the competition as Chris's mole. He was then "fired" a couple of episodes later. In TDWT he got way too much screen time. 19 episodes of farting, burping, eating, and barfing is way too much. Fortunately, this season he had a lot of plot lines to balance out the farting. His aero phobia and friendship with Noah was funny. Even Alejandro played an important role in Owen's development. In TDROTI he had a short cameo only to be blasted by Chris's bomb. I will say this, Owen is a major screenhogger and is the true definition of a writer's pet. How he didn't make it to All-Stars is still a mystery.

TDI - 6/10 TDA - 4/10 TDWT - 6/10 TDROTI - 2/10

16. DJ - In TDI he was meh. In TDA he was decent. In TDWT I wanted his head! He's a pretty boring character overall and has no real plot. A relationship would develop him a whole lot but no, he was instead left to hung dry. His illegal alliance with Chef made some decent drama but was quickly flushed. It had so much potential! I hated him in TDWT. His stupid animal curse eliminated three of my favorite characters. If Harold hadn't quit and DJ had gone home, Team Victory wouldn't have been such a mess. At the very least, Lindsay should have stayed instead of him. His cameo in TDROTI was pathetic. All he did was run away. I'm disappointed DJ, you had such great potential!

TDI - 5/10 TDA - 6/10 TDWT - 3/10 TDROTI - 2/10

15. Geoff - In TDI he was good. His failed flirting with Bridgette was hilarious. Duncan and DJ also helped develop him. In TDA he turned into kisser status. After he was eliminated, his role in the aftermaths was terrible! Captain Hollywood is not Geoff's thing. Luckily his real personality returned in TDWT only to have his girlfriend cheat on him. He then has to put up with Mildred and her ridiculous schemes and pranks against Bridgette. Geoff is one of those characters who the producers just don't care about. Fortunately, he lasted a LONG time on TDI. He would have been up higher but he didn't really develop that much.

TDI - 7/10 TDA - 2/10 TDWT - 5/10

14. Courtney - In TDI she was eh. She was bossy but her politeness balanced it out. Her friendship with Bridgette went nowhere, but her relationship with Duncan was well developed throughout a decent number of episodes. In TDA she well I have no words to describe how much I hated her. She sued her way into the show, unfairly got Owen kicked off, gotten special treatment, and made several new enemies along the way. Her PDA only added more hate for Leshawna and her constantly calling her lawyers is annoying. She got her ultimate downfall when she was outsmarted by Beth and was eliminated by her own boyfriend! TDWT was the season I liked her the best. She was nice, polite, and wasn't very bossy. Her friendship with Gwen was the best. Her best episodes were 7-13. Then came the biggest jerk of all..........Duncan. He ruined her friendship with Gwen, her sanity, her positive attitude, and her relationship. Everything went downhill from there. She broke up with Duncan, sabotaged her team three times, eliminated Gwen, flirted with Alejandro, and made Heather annoyed the entire time. After A LOT of drama she was finally eliminated. She continued to show her hatred for Gwen & Duncan in the aftermaths and TDAS. In TDAS she returns as a "hero". She continues to be bossy but less bossy than before. Her hatred of Duncan grows, while her relationship with Gwen starts to heal. She is transferred to villains after using Sam as a meat shield and starts to bond with Scott.....

TDI - 5.5/10 TDA - 2/10 TDWT - First Half - 7/10 - Second Half - 3/10 TDAS - 5/10

13. Cody - In TDI he was boring. I didn't find his crush on Gwen to be funny IMO. In TDA he had like one? two lines? In TDWT he grew on me. He wasn't like Beth were she just magically makes it to the finale. He worked to get there. Anyone that can survive a Sierra attack for as long as him gets an A+ in my book.

TDI - 5/10 TDA - 2/10 TDWT - 6/10

12. Izzy - In TDI she was crazy. Being hunted down by the RMCP, telling wild stories, and scaring her teammates by dressing up as a bear is pretty psycho to me. In TDA she was okay. Her first three episodes were boring and so was her aftermath episode. When she returned I liked her more. If it wasn't for Justin, she probably had a likely chance of merging, if she got past Courtney safely. In TDWT she was fun. Her crazy antics were interesting and funny. This was the season I really wanted Izzy to merge. But of course, she was removed from the competition because of head injury and she broke up with Owen! She had such great potential! She likely would have merged because everyone would focus on eliminating the threats (Alejandro, Duncan, Gwen, Courtney, Heather) that they would forget about the underdogs (Izzy, Owen, Noah, Tyler, Sierra, Cody). Her cameo in TDROTI was typical Izzy fighting with Chef.

TDI - 6/10 TDA - 5/10 TDWT - 7.5/10 TDROTI - 6/10

11. Duncan - In TDI he was cool. He pranked a nerd, dated a crazy girl, and bonded with dudes. He made it all the way to final four! This was Duncan's shine season. When his girlfriend was eliminated he didn't go into sob mode like Geoff, he stayed cool and got even better. In TDA he was seriously overrated. Not only did he last as long as he did in TDI he lasted even LONGER. It was the same stuff he did in TDI, pranking Harold, fighting with Courtney, and constantly breaking rules. But this time he didn't do it in a cool way, he did it in a jerkish way! After all that drama, he won the million. In TDWT he quit the competition and was the first to go home. Yay! BUT, he returned a dozen episodes later, ruining Courtney and Gwen's fan base and traits. He started dating Gwen and cheated on Courtney. After they were both eliminated, Duncan's source of drama was finished, causing him to be eliminated. FINALLY! In TDROTI his cameo involved a prank. He returns to TDAS as a "villain" and makes Gwen feel bad because of her actions. After saving her life, he is transferred to the heroes and the next episode, Gwen dumps him in less than 3 seconds. Duncan is seriously overrated and somehow made it to the final five in EVERY season. He practically gained every high ranking spot (1st/2nd, 4th, 5th). If he gets 3rd in TDAS, I will personally write a long blog on the flaws of Duncan. I don't even know why he's so high on my list, let alone borderline on support. Oh I know, he's actually interesting unlike Cody, DJ, or Owen.

TDI - 8/10 TDA - 5/10 TDWT - 2/10 TDROTI - 3/10 TDAS - 3.5/10

Support

10. Leshawna - In TDI she was sassy! I loved her conflict with Heather, and the classic Gopher interaction she always had. In TDA she was okay. She wasn't as sassy as before and lied to her teammates, resulting in her long dragged elimination. She started to become better in TDWT but was eliminated too early. I guess after two seasons of merging that seemed fair, or else she and Lindsay would turn into screenhoggers.

TDI - 8/10 TDA - 6/10 TDWT - 6.5/10

9. Alejandro - In TDA he was really good. His dramatic entry and mysterious personality only added to the charm Alejandro had. In TDWT he was awesome! He's like the male version of Heather. Great strategy, plan, and charm too. After the triangle came to play, Alejandro lost control, as his pawns (Bridgette, Leshawna, Lindsay, Izzy, DJ, Noah, Tyler) have already been eliminated and he's starting to lose focus. After the triangle left, he was forced to get acquainted with the handful of players left, further developing his relationship with Heather. When they were the final two, Heather betrayed him by kneeing him in the groin so she can have the million for her self. In All-Stars, he returns as a villain with the charm he once had, long gone. He starts to walk on his hands, claiming that his legs are asleep from the robot incident. He's the second best antagonist guaranteed. Even if his role in All-Stars is mediocre, he will always be remembered as the boy who swooned even Heather.

TDA - 8/10 TDWT - First Half - 8.5/10 - Second Half - 6/10 TDAS - 4/10

8. Trent - In TDI he was awesome! He's like a more causal Geoff, a nicer Duncan, and a more stylish DJ or Owen. He's not the kind of person where the producers want you to like him but you don't. Trent is the kind of guy that justs clicks on right away. Gwen's relationship with him was cool although it ultimately was his downfall. He started out in TDA as okay. Not as cool as before, but still alright. Starting in episode four, he became so obsessed with nine. It ruined his personality and his fan base. In TDWT he was in the Drama Brothers, but that's it. Trent was a great while he lasted. His development in season two was so powerful, but he faded away after the first aftermath, and COMPLETELY faded in season three. I always felt it was unfair how Gwen, Duncan, and Courtney got the drama, while Trent has left to dry. Those four were the ORIGINAL couples, maybe the producers thought Trent was too boring. Don't worry Trent, the fans will always love you.

TDI - 8/10 TDA - 5/10 TDWT - 2/10

7. Eva - In TDI she was the second one eliminated. In TDA she did nothing. In TDWT she did nothing. Eva is one of those characters who the producers just HATE! She so funny! Her return in TDI was epic, with the fire and the taunting. She would have been great on the villains team in TDAS. Unfortunately, she never got to shine. The producers need to let go of the screenhoggers and let Eva back.

TDI - 7/10 TDA - 2/10 TDWT - 2/10

6. Bridgette - In TDI she was so causal. She was friendly, athletic, and clumsy. Her relationship with Geoff was okay. I was never a fan of Gidget though. Everything went downhill in TDA, she would nonstop make out with Geoff. She was better in TDWT, but got zero screentime and was quickly eliminated. Her cameo in TDROTI was typical Bridgette. I'm a bit surprised that they let Bridgette cameo though. She's not exactly the producer's favorite character.

TDI - 7.5/10 TDA - 3/10 TDWT - 5/10 TDROTI - 5/10

5. Tyler - In TDI he was funny. His relationship with Lindsay and always failing at sports was hilarious! In TDA he didn't do much. In TDWT he got the BEST development out of the four underdogs. His facial expressions were really clever, and we got to know more about him. He was dragged into the triangle by Alejandro and indirectly caused some MAJOR drama. Funny guy Tyler.

TDI - 6.5/10 TDA - 2/10 TDWT - 8/10

4. Noah - In TDI he was sarcastic. In TDA his one line was funny. In TDWT he was, I have no words. His one liners and monotone voice always cracked me up. His friendship with Owen really helped them both. He really should have merged this season. Instead he was flushed to make room for the triangle.

TDI - 6/10 TDA - 3/10 TDWT - 8/10

3. Heather - In TDI she was interesting. Her schemes were purely evil and her conflict with Gwen? Best conflict ever! She faded in TDA but still lasted fairly long. Her role in TDWT was even larger than the triangle. She rocked that season with Alejandro. That was the season were Heather was somewhat the good guy. When it came down to her and Alejandro everyone (except for Courtney) cheered on for Heather. Her cameo in TDROTI was really good. It was longer than others and showed Heather's bad side had returned. She returns to all-stars as a pure villain and proudly accepts it. Her role this season has faded but she is still is a fairly important character in the season. Although her constantly switching hairstyles every season is getting slightly annoying.

TDI - 8/10 TDA - 6.5/10 TDWT - 9/10 TDROTI - 7.5/10 TDAS - 6.5/10

2. Gwen - TDI was her best season. She wasn't forced to deal with drama, or cry over being a villain. This was the season Gwen was herself. Her sarcasm was hilarious and her conflict with Heather was great too. Another thing I like about Gwen this season is that she's not whiny. After Trent was voted off, she only cried for like a minute before Leshawna stopped her. For the rest of the competition (which was a decent number of episodes actually) she focused on the game, took leadership, and won several challenges. She only lost to Owen because of some stupid brownies. TDA ruined her. She broke up with Trent and lost many fans. She was slightly healed in TDWT. The only problem was that she was fairly quiet. She didn't use the confessional every five minutes, in fact this is the only season Gwen didn't use the confessional in the first episode. Her friendship with Courtney rocked! Until Duncan came. He ruined her friendship with Courtney, her sanity, her positive attitude, and her friends. She was even nicknamed the "New Heather!" Eventually, she was eliminated. In TDROTI she had a short cameo with Sam. It was fairly funny. She returns to TDAS as a villain.... She gets mad, sad and breaks up with Duncan as a result. After Courtney is transferred, she begins to bond with her.....

TDI - 9.5/10 TDA - 3/10 TDWT - First Half - 6/10 - Second Half - 4/10 TDROTI - 5/10 TDAS - 5.5/10

1. Lindsay - In TDI she was funny! Her constantly forgetting names and being easily fooled by Heather was gold. In TDA she got more screentime and developed greatly. She showed her leadership skills after Trent left and tried to help the team. (Even if her help only made the team lose faster.) In TDWT she returned to her more comedic self. Her calling Tyler random names that didn't start with T was hilarious. Unfortunately, she was wiped out by DJ's stupid curse but fortunately, she was the second to last person from Team Victory to go. That means Lindsay was forced to get aquatinted with DJ and develop a friendship. Her cameo in TDROTI was awesome! The way she give the Maggots a 1.8 instead of a 8.1 was genius! She returns to TDAS as a hero, but is the first one gone. Apparently, the writers made her too dumb resulting in her downfall. If this is the last season Lindsay is competing in, that was definitely a terrible goodbye to Lindsay. I just LOVE Lindsay. She's funny, dumb, pretty, and can have an attitude if she needs too. I love when she gets really mad or really sad. Her facial expressions show her emotions greatly! Good job producers! Some people may not realize this, but she's really smart. She built an entire statue of David without the help from DJ in like 7 minutes! She was the only one on the Grips to figure out the ghost prank. Lindsay has developed on and off throughout the series. In TDI she was dumb. In TDA she smart/dumb. In TDWT she was dumb in a good way. TDAS she was dumb in a bad way. Here's a really hard question for Lindsay fans out there. How can you NOT like her? She's gotta be at least in your top 10 characters. Lindsay 😍😘❤️

TDI - 7/10 TDA - 9/10 TDWT - 8/10 TDROTI - 7.5/10 TDAS - 6/10

More to come!