User blog comment:ThomasVeggieDramaFan/Pahkitew Island: One Year Later/@comment-4393544-20150629102727/@comment-4742462-20150629122008

Ella's the only gimmick character from this cast that I liked. Topher could've been eliminated earlier because he was such a non-factor. Shawn honestly felt like a fodder character due to how played up and over the top his gimmick was.

Samey could've been better if her purpose wasn't around a plot that insulted the viewer's intelligence nor dependent on her sister. They tried with the plot of her wanting to be her own person, only for it to be thrown out the window after two episodes. Amy's 'meh', but that doesn't mean I like her.

On the contrary, those three were honestly the only truly defined characters of the season even if Scarlett was underdeveloped.

Dave wasn't developed, his character was thrown off the rails for the sake of needless drama as well as the writer's desperate attempt to break the couples trend.

This show is honestly much better off without those two pieces of trash.