User blog comment:TylerSurvivorFan/How Total Drama All-Stars Could've Been Better/@comment-1037137-20140904070939

If Ridonculous Race can bring back that edgier humor a la Island days, more power to them. Hope that's true. I still don't consider this a true kids' show, I don't like the more childish humor, and I don't like how it's driven more towards kids when a lot of the more recent content doesn't even work for the longer-running adult fandom.

Yeah, if they wanted Zoey to be a finalist, should've done it last season. She didn't earn it here, she got played up too much and got dumbed down too much. And I don't even have to comment on Mal.

Cast choices would've been forgivable if they had developed them or given them anything worthwhile, or hell, kept them CONSISTENT. But even then, I would make a few switches.

You entitled this thing "All-Stars", Fresh. But it sure as hell didn't feel like that kind of season, let alone even a good season.