Thread:ArtDraw12/@comment-25397397-20141109041522/@comment-11883116-20141115002149

Just as I promised, I've read all of your elimination orders and here's my response:

Well, you definitely do it in a more realistic way. Sometimes, you're likely reading my mind and your version is similar to mine, so I like it! You're also not scared to drastically change a lot of important plots in the series. I respect your opinion but I'm not sure if it's always good. Let's move on:

TDI: TDA: TDWT: TDRI: TDAS: TDPI: Other things that are not mentioned were really cool as well. IMO, the only problems were some contestants being eliminated too early and some too late. But, once again,  it's your elimination order.
 * Heather is eliminated too early. I know her role as an antagonist is replaced by Courtney (who would be similar to her, I admit) but it's a waste of such a good character. But I'll give you points for realism.
 * I especially like the reasons of Owen's, DJ's, Lindsay's, and Cody's eliminations. Tbh, I thought about eliminating DJ in Who Can You Trust? for the same reason, but I thought Hook, Line, and Screamer would be better. I didn't know Lindsay would fit this role as well.
 * I think Ezekiel and Noah made it too far. Don't get me wrong, but it was the first season, they had almost no plot and very poor social game. I think TDWT would be better for them to make it far.
 * Courtney's hair doesn't get shaven? Aw, poop! So, what's her karma? Duncan's betrayal? Nothing?
 * Perfect final 2, as I've already written in one of my posts above.
 * Gwen and Trent as Aftermath hosts instead of Bridgette and Geoff? Hmm...Interesting. I think it would prevent both pairs from character derailment. How about Aftermaths in TDWT? The hosts will be Trent and Blaineley, right? And will Gwen and Trent break up? You know, the whole love triangle in the next season...
 * This time I will forgive you Heather's early elimination, as she had not that much important role in this season. But why is she always eliminated early? She's one of the best strategists of the real Total Drama.
 * Harold is eliminated way too early. He was a star of a real TDA and a fan favourite, along with Lindsay.
 * Cool reason to eliminate Duncan. Only females in the final 3? Nice!
 * Once again, perfect final 2, just as I've already said in one of my older posts.
 * Hmm...The beginning of the season doesn't change that much...and that's good! These characters would have no purpose this season.
 * However, Ezekiel could last longer to prove everyone that he's a stronger contestant now. But since he made it far in your TDI version, then it wasn't really needed.
 * I'm glad you eliminated Owen earlier.
 * So, Bridgette attraction/conflict with Alejandro is much more important now, right? Cool!
 * Blaineley is eliminated too early, just like in the real series. I know it'd be unfair if she lasted too long, but at least 1 or 2 episodes more would be better.
 * Heather being eliminated right before the finale? In a season that belongs to her?! What's wrong with you always eliminating her too early?! Do you hate her or something?
 * Alejandro and Cody? Not that bad. It would make their conflict more important and it's good after we had a girl vs. girl final 2 last time. But wouldn't fans think Cody was a floater even more than already do? Once again, I think Heather would be better (especially with Alejandro, like in the real series).
 * I don't really know if Lightning would've been a better antagonist than Scott.
 * Anne Maria is eliminated too early. The love triangle would've had even less screentime than in the real series. But I know it'd be hard for her to survive on Mutant Maggots. So, once again, a point for you for realism.
 * Brick was also eliminated too early. But I know that the plot of this episode is possibly the best for his elimination, so I won't complain that much.
 * Another thing that was too early for me was the merge (however, it's good that Dawn made it to the merge).
 * Sam making it to the final 3? Isn't that impossible?
 * Final 2 is kinda weird this time. I like those characters, but I don't think they would be able to make it to the final 2...Wait! Lightning somehow did in the real series! And he was an antagonist in your series. So, it's not that bad, but it could be better. One another thing - was Dakota able to build Cameron's suit of the real series? Or did he build it for her?
 * Courtney being the first boot? I know it makes sense for this episode...but you completely changed this season's main plots! Hmm...Maybe it's better? Maybe it could prevent TDAS from being such a disaster?
 * I know it was hard to change some things...but I think that Jo, Alejandro, and Heather (once again) were eliminated too early while Sierra, Lindsay, Sam (3rd place again, really?) & Mike and Zoey (I've already explained why I think they're terrible final 2) made it too far.
 * Cameos? Cool! But did everyone had a cameo in the last episode, like in my version? Same question goes for TDRI.
 * Ok, Leonard deserves to stay longer than Beardo as he could've easily had some plot with Dave, Ella or Sugar, but you know what I think about being eliminated in the 1st episode...
 * Dave is eliminated too ear...Oh, wait! He returns. So, it's ok :P
 * So, Amy is eliminated along with Samey in A Blast from the Past, right? Too bad...
 * I didn't expect Leonard to last that long. I don't know if it's good or not...
 * ...but Rodney definitely lasted too long.
 * Yay! Ella makes it to the merge!
 * Didn't Max last too long as well? However, I'm happy he didn't say anything after Scarlett's elimination.
 * And we have another girl vs. girl final 2. You're gonna make a male vs. male finale next time to make it even again, right? Anyway, the final 2 isn't that bad except for one thing... Sugar!
 * Wow. So many antagonists, just like in the real series.