User blog comment:CheeseBurgerGuy/What if All-Stars Came After Pahkitew Island?/@comment-34183063-20181202152442

I find this better than the original TDAS (Which isn't saying much).

But using in-show universe reasoning, I doubt Chris would let Scarlett return for another season after TDPI. Not only did she nearly derail the entire season, but she attempted to blackmail Chris and at one point nearly killed him. I'm not saying I don't want Scarlett to return (I actually quite like her and would love to see her return), but within the show's universe she'd likely be denied a chance to return.