User blog comment:GWEN+TRENT FOREVER/Why I view Noah as a failed character/@comment-11883116-20160307203023

Tbh, I'm one of those who didn't mind him in RR. He was more competitive at the beginning to show how much he changed because of his relationship with Emma. And the fact it was his first relationship is believable for me.

But then, there are still some problems with him that I have too.

I was such a big fan of him in TDWT either. Maybe if he stayed a little longer...But we all know that Alejandro's true side would either be exposed and the writers would have to make some BS eliminations like in TDI to keep the main antagonist in the game, or Noah, Alejandro's greatest competition at the time, had to be eliminated. I'm not shocked they chose the second option, though the reason why he left is annoying, I admit.

And the fact that he completed the bull challenge?! Ok, I understand Crimson, that's just part of her character and comedy. But Noah? Wow, he was just waaaaay too lucky.