User blog comment:ThomasVeggieDramaFan/Pahkitew Island: One Year Later/@comment-25166946-20150629161652/@comment-4742462-20150629170523

Yeah, Revenge of the Island's cast was better because the characters felt more realistic and not ones that you'd find from a Robot Chicken parody of the show. The reason why they get shafted though is due to the trio as well as most of them being rather underdeveloped. But that to me means that they have more potential unlike Pahkitew Island's cast which for the most part consist of complete one-note joke characters. Scarlett, Jasmine, Sky, and Ella are the only ones from this cast that I remotely like.

The vibe I got from Shawn was a character who should've been fodder with how over the top and played up his zombie obsession was, yet somehow became the main protagonist. At least Leonard was the 2nd one out, Topher should've gone sooner as he didn't participate in most of the challenges, and I will never understand why they let Max float all the way to 5th place despite being just as irrelevant as past floaters like Cody and Lightning.