User blog comment:Total Drama Wiki! Wars/Week of December 7, 2014/@comment-31556666-20141207213223

I'm voting based on what I think of them as a character. Justin was hilarious in TDA but was silent in TDI. Alejandro was alright in WT, had a few moments of derailment in AS. Was Scott arguably derailed in AS too? Sure. But I can come up with more explanations as to why Scott was stupid. Plus, he has pros and cons of both of these characterizations anyways. Looks like I'll be the unpopular opinion on this one.