User blog comment:Epic~00/Why Total Drama All Stars Was Such An Abysmal Season (PART 4)/@comment-27588345-20141030221457/@comment-27588345-20141102012134

You're right, nothing can ever compare to the horrificness of All Stars.

Let me list the things All Stars did wrong:

1. It derailed all of it's cast, Lindsay got dumber, Lightning became more arrogant, Jo became less strategic (This is especially prevalent in episode 3.), Sam got eliminated in a very ooc moment, Heather became dumber and less strategic, Sierra became creepier, Duncan turned into a wuss, Cameron took 10 levels in both jerkishness and dumbness, Alejandro became more of a Justin clone, Courtney became nicer only for her character to drop down into a pit in the 11th episode, Gwen became Courtney obsessed, Scott turned into a total buffoon, Zoey became so moronic and whiny, and don't even get me started on Mike.

2. Most of the season focused on two characters, Mike and Zoey, some of the most boring contestants to be on this show.

3. Terrible writing.

4. Awful villain, even worse than Max for pete's sake.

5. Having characters dumbed down so said villain can look more threatening.

6. The Final Wreck-ening, and Sundae Muddy Sundae.

7. Mike's MPD, which was made even more offensive in this season.

I can go on and on about this one, TDAS did so many things wrong.

Things PI did wrong:

1.Dropping the Samey pretends to be her sister plot after only two episodes.

2. Eliminating Beardo instead of Leonard in episode 1.

3. Made a major plot line become irrelevant after one episode.

4. Had Chris become more of a d*** and not a funny one either.

5. The Jasmine hates Shawn plot, she was going to throw the challenge anyway, why make her all pissy and mean about it?

6. Making a potential bad*** last for only one episode, and that episode being the episode of her elimination where she revealed the bad*** part of her.

7. Turned two decent characters into unlikable pieces of writing.