User blog:CheeseBurgerGuy/Total Drama Island: Community Choice (My Way Compilation)

Hello everyone. I welcome you all to the ultimate version Total Drama Island! No, I'm totallly not being subjective here either. For you see, I've compiled twelve completed Total Drama Island My Way blogs, putting them under the microscope. From there, the elimination order of the season was determined by a variety of factors, but for the most part, it came down to simply who was most commonly sent home.

If this sounds familar, than you would be correct. About two months ago, Gabrinitro posted an extremely similar blog tittled Total Drama Island but I look at everyone's blogs. There are a few differences between his previous blog and this one.

Firstly, I will only be using elimination orders from versions of the season that are complete. We need to have complete visions of the season that likely isn't going to get editied during the writing of this blog. For example, eliminating Gwen in the first episode is 'great' and all but how would that impact the rest of the season? Unfinished blogs lack that answer, which is why I'm only looking at complete My Way Series. Additonally, this will prevent me from having to rely on others finishing their blogs first.

Secondly, like with basically all my other elimination blogs, I will be adding my formatting and crazy amount of detail to flesh out the season as much as possible.

The Offcial Ruleset:

1. As a principal, if the majority of users voted a contestant out in a particular episode, then I must also eliminate them that episode.

2. If the contestant with the most votes has already been eliminated, go down the list to the next option.

3. In the event that two options are tied, count up the total number of users who eliminated the tied contestants in earlier episodes. The person/people who last(s) longer in the majority of blogs will be spared from elimination.

4. There will be no double eliminations. Instead, if a user included a double elimination into the season, it will count as two seperate votes to each of the contestants they eliminated. Exceptions will be made if the canonical episode had a double elimination.

5. The number of non-elimination episodes in the season is based on the number from canon. They will be treated like contestants, with the sole exception that those episodes are chosen as their vote counts compare to all the other episodes with votes for non-elimination. For example, if a season only has one non-elimination episode in canon, and Episode 3 gets 5 votes while Episode 7 gets 8 Votes, then Episode 7 would be the non-elimination episode (even if making Episode 3 Non-elimination is what the majority did, it will default to highest contestant).

This is due to the no double elimination rule. If I allowed there to still be non-elimination episodes without them, then we would not have enough time to eliminate all the contestants.

6. Outside of the guidlines, the only imput I can add into the season is the plotlines. Considering how much power I have as blog author, it only seemed fair I couldn't impact elimination order.

With the rules out of the way, I think I should be introducing you all to the blogs which I took my data from. They are as follows:

ArtDraw12

CrazCrazy

Tomas T

Elodge

NesteaCookie

The Noah Killer

JoshTheKing3

Jasminefan114

HugeTotalDramaFan

NbaChamp2017

Amazing Brayden

The Fanmellow

I want to shoutout all the people on this list. For those of you on this list, don't worry about me spoiling your blogs, as I only intend to show the numerial statistics for who chose who.

If any of you would like to be added to this blog, I apoligize but it is too late for it to affect this specific version. However, if you want to still be apart of this blog, post a link to your My Way and once I finish I will show an updated list of the votes (so we can see if a wider poll changes things by a lot).

Alright then everyone, let's get this train underway.

Episodes 1 & 2: Not So Happy Campers
Challenge Update:

Now you have to land in the safe zone for your points to count.

Camper Updates:

Duncan: Instead of waiting until the merge, Duncan immediatley suggests taking advantage of the male majority on the Bass and work to take out the girls.

Lindsay: While there are still smaller hints that Lindsay might be into Tyler, there is more emphasis on her crush on Justin. In fact, he is the one who convinces her to jump.

Justin: As he lands outside the safe zone like in canon, Justin fails to earn a point for the Gophers.

Ezekiel: Firstly, hitting the cliffside causes him to spiral out of control into the shark infested waters. Secondly, he gets cocky when Geoff comes to him with the alliance. At the cafeteria after the challenge, Ezekiel taunts the girls about the guys alliance, but it gets misconstrued by the girls as a sexist comment.

Immunity: Screaming Gophers

Reason for Victory: Same as canon.

Bottom 2: Ezekiel and Courtney

Courtney Votes for: Ezekiel (his 'sexist' comment)

Ezekiel Votes for: Courtney (she's too bossy)

DJ Votes for: Courtney (she campainged for his elimination)

Bridgette Votes for: Ezekiel (his 'sexist' comment)

Tyler Votes for: Courtney (she campainged for his elimination)

Eva Votes for: Ezekiel (his 'sexist' comment)

Katie Votes for: Ezekiel (his 'sexist' comment)

Sadie Votes for: Ezekiel (his 'sexist' comment)

Harold Votes for: Courtney (she's too bossy)

Geoff Votes for: Courtney (the guy's alliance)

Duncan Votes for: Ezekiel (Duncan couldn't trust Ezekiel to keep his mouth shut about the guys alliance)

Vote Tally: 6 - 5

Eliminated (22nd Place): Ezekiel

In The Blogs:

Ezekiel = 5

Courtney = 4

Sadie = 2

Harold = 1

Nobody = 1

Comments: 

I was reading through a lot of the blogs that kept Ezekiel around and noticed a pattern. Almost all of them had mitigated or removed Zeke's sexist comments from the season. As such, I decided to bring in the plot about the guys alliance early. Firstly, this keeps Zekiel innocent, only punishing him for not following Chris' advice of keeping his mouth shut. More importantly though, Duncan actually does something as the secondary antagonist before going into the merge that isn't just bullying.

Episode 3: The Big Sleep
Camper Updates:

Duncan and Harold: In order to keep the guys alliance from turning on one another, Duncan pins the swing vote on Harold, citing how he probably respected Courtney's CIT expirence as a boy scout, kicking Harold out of the alliance while pranking him like canon.

Courtney: While it's not much, Courtney deduces down that it was really Duncan who saved her. She thanks him when nobody is looking. More of a hint at there relationship if anything.

Lindsay: She mostly turns her attention towards Justin after not realizing his whole strategy was cheating and getting super impressed.

Eva: Heather still steals her MP3 player like canon and it plays out the exact same way.

Immunity: Screaming Gophers

Reason for Victory: Same as canon

Bottom 2: Eva & Duncan

Eva Votes for: Duncan (he cost them the challenge by losing to Gwen)

Harold Votes for: Duncan (for everything the deliquent did to him this episode)

Duncan Votes for: Eva (her anger issues made her to dangerous to keep around)

Courtney Votes for: Eva (her anger issues made her to dangerous to keep around)

Geoff Votes for: Eva (her anger issues made her to dangerous to keep around)

Bridgette Votes for: Eva (her anger issues made her to dangerous to keep around)

Katie Votes for: Eva (her anger issues made her to dangerous to keep around)

Sadie Votes for: Eva (her anger issues made her to dangerous to keep around)

Tyler Votes for: Eva (her anger issues made her to dangerous to keep around)

DJ Votes for: Eva (her anger issues made her to dangerous to keep around)

Vote Tally: 8 - 2

Eliminated (21st Place): Eva

In The Blogs:

Eva = 4

Justin = 4

Sadie = 1

DJ = 1

Beth = 1

Ezekiel = 1

Comments:

This episode was a weird exception to my rules where I had to break the tie since neither Justin or Eva had gotten eliminated during Not So Happy Campers in any blog. I'm sure you want to know why I broke the tie in favor of Eva when I've previously been on record as of saying Justin deserves to go home for cheating. To be blunt, I wanted to keep Eva's iconic elimination so that the audience wouldn't start thinking Duncan was the primary antagonist and because Justin isn't lasting very long anyways (as you could've probably guessed).

Episode 3: Dodgebrawl
Camper Updates:

Justin and Lindsay: He decides not to particpate in the challenge worried that the dodgeballs could hurt his face. Instead of going to make out with Tyler, Lindsay is seduced by Justin into going to the beach.

Heather: Obviously, like canon, Heather brings her wrath down upon them in the form of a canoe.

Noah: Honestly, nothing changes with him in this episode, except that he's the one to notice Justin and Lindsay being abscent.

Immunity: Killer Bass

Reason for Victory: Same as canon

Bottom 2: Justin & Noah

Justin Votes for: Noah (he was annoyed by Noah's half-hearted cheering)

Noah Votes for: Justin (Justin did less for the team than even himself)

Heather Votes for: Justin (revenge is a marshmellow not served)

Lindsay Votes for: Justin (Heather threatens Lindsay, telling her that if she doesn't show her loyalty to the alliance by voting out Justin, Lindsay will be the next to walk down the dock)

Beth Votes for: Justin (Heather forced her due to their alliance)

Owen Votes for: Justin (while Justin might be hot, Noah is Owen's friend)

Trent Votes for: Justin (Heather convinces him due to Justin's cheating last episode)

Gwen Votes for: Justin (she was too tired to care and caught him cheating last episode)

Leshawna Votes for: Justin (she realizes that he's been dead weight the last three challenges)

Izzy Votes for: Justin (she thought that Justin and her had some sort of connection)

Cody Votes for: Justin (with Gwen and the rest of the majority)

Final Tally: 10 - 1

Eliminated (20th Place): Justin

In The Blogs:

Justin = 5

Noah = 4

Eva = 2

Lindsay = 1

Comments: 

Yeah, my other reason for booting Eva last episode was so that I could send Justin out this episode. Basically everryone is in agreement that he should be the first Screaming Gopher to go. As for re-intorducing his plot from the my own series...I needed a reason people would target Justin over Noah. This also allows Heather to be responsible for another elimination.

Episode 5: Not Quite Famous
TBC