User blog comment:CandyAnaisWatterson777/WHY?/@comment-27607014-20180701233313/@comment-32912801-20180703203151

ArtDraw12

"The Sundae Muddy Sundae is the most hated episode.

Sundae Muddy Sundae I do not know if it will be the worst episode, but it is certainly bad and even without any doubt, the most hated.

For the following reasons.

1 It is full of errors of continuity, something stupid for supposedly professional screenwriters.

2 Narratively damages Courtney and narratively kills Gwen, the girl type A, needed his redemption, after being excessively humiliated in TDWT, it was necessary to show that although being competitive and aggressive, it had a sweet side, and the gothic, after being like the worst friend and one steals boyfriends, who smiles as his new boyfriend assaults his ex, needed to recover, and of course here is worse, a girl lying, hypocritical and hormonal, and practically insalvable.

3 Courtney is an amoral character, not good or bad, can be a gentle person or the most destructive, is a character of gray layers, and is very popular beloved (and hated) by millions of viewers, and this season and in this episode, humiliating it without shamelessness and with it to all its followers.

4 You can love her, you can hate her, you can be neutral, but you can not deny that Courtney is one of those characters who exemplify the hard work, the training, the skill and the effort, represents those boys and girls who day by day the soul is left to achieve its goals, is expert in different fields, is highly fit physically, knows how to sing, knows how to play the violin, knows how to care for babies, knows medicine, does not have a unique talent, his talent is the effort continuous, is always improving.

She is an exceptional contestant, and in this episode they make fun of her, or rather they take away her intelligence (the list is of fools), her recency (an iron stomach) and valor (defeat to three sharks), always denied the victory in TD, thanks to the unfair rules of Chris, in the first had his logic, in the second was cheating Owen, in the third was already more of the same and poor excuse, it seemed to be a joke, Courtney always lose for injustice, and frankly the joke was beginning to stink.

But in this they happened and much, it was noticed that they despised it, and that they eliminated it humiliatingly, only to give space to Mike and Zoey, two gary stus that are of the most hated by the public.

5 This episode left TD in a critical state, left moribund, had to do a purge of writers, and still did not give them the green light for another season, given the poor results, had to create the Spin off, to prove that even they could have quality, a Spin off where what matters is to strive and give everything, wink Courtney wink.

Now after four years (five for when it premiered) TD will have a new opportunity.

That episode along with its season, almost killed the franchise.

6 And finally, for those who say that it is a good episode to return the personalities to Gwen and Courtney, huge mistake, involucionaron, certainly the writers did not know how to take their evolution properly (it is noticed that they did not care about anything to the writers), but in eposode 7, Courtney admitted to miss Gwen, in his way appreciates (remember gray character), when returning them to their personalities of previous seasons, they prevent them from developing.

A clear example is Noah, at first is a cold, insatiable boy who does not appreciate anyone, in TDWT begins to show empathy and concern for his peers and in TDRR show us with conscience, feelings and even with kindness, without losing his cynicism so personal.

Sundae Muddy Sundae is a terrible episode, because it mutilates to Gwen and Courtney, because sends a terrible message, of the poorly elaborated that this, Gwen represents the people marginalized by the society and Courtney to those people who fight for to survive in that same society, having in common, loneliness and incomprehension, they are not enemies, they are people who on opposing sides can understand each other, and this episode destroys that for a cliche and abhorrent end.

Leaving Courtney wounded and killing Gwen.

That is why he is the most hated, maybe not the worst, but the one that generates more rejection."