User blog comment:TylerSurvivorFan/What Is The Most Realistic Season?/@comment-26897147-20140927150929

Total Drama Island was the most realistic season followed by TDA, TDWT, TDAS, and TDRI.

Pahkitew Island was the most unrealistic character in my opinion. Not only was the robot island thing over the top, but nearly 80% of the cast were horridly cartoonish, and too unrealistic compared to the TDI and TDRI cast. Though I gotta give them credit for that astonishing Skave plot, which was 100% realistic and relatable.