User blog comment:Broodje Kroket/Did Total Drama's increasing surrealism only lead to bad things?/@comment-25297892-20150125124902

They need to come back at the old style. If Total Drama Island still is the best season ever the reason is only one: it looked like a TRUE REALITY SHOW. The other seasons didn't seem like that for different reasons:


 * TDA: way too much drama on love stories.
 * TDWT: probably the only enough closed to the old format, but all the unnecessary boring way too much focused drama on the love triangle ruined everything.
 * TDROTI: started the surrealism, and if there's something I disliked openly was the MUTANT THEME.
 * TDAS: no more a reality show but a cartoon. The quality of the plots, half redundant (Courtney, Gwen, Duncan, love business, yaddayadda) half cartoonical (Mal, Zoey, Scott, the various jokes, puns, the surrealism, extc) evidenced this at all.
 * TDPI: totally a cartoon. If their aim was to bring back the old TDI sensation, they should have not created Dave, Topher, Sugar,Max, Scarlett, Ella, Leonard, Amy and Rodney. Shawn more or less was like Izzy in TDI, a quirky wild card. Sky was the most normal. Samey was normal, too. Jasmine was the australian Leshawna. The only four realistic, then.