User blog comment:CheeseBurgerGuy/Total Drama Theory: Who Is the 'Canon' Winner of Each Season?/@comment-11883116-20191007170328/@comment-35606925-20191007211806

Actaully, I'm kind of curious about this myself. Let's take a look at who these characters would've voted for:

Gwen votes for Duncan (in this version, Gwen would no longer be the swing vote because, let's be honest, that was stupid)

Geoff votes for Duncan (he doesn't really know Beth while and Duncan are on good terms)

Trent votes for Beth (this would be nothing more than a bitter juror vote)

Lindsay votes for Beth (why would she vote for the guy that got her out over her best friend?)

Bridgette votes for Duncan (this might seem strange as Bridgette doesn't like Duncan, but I think that the couple would inevitably vote together)

Leshawna is the swing vote (Leshawna is the only person with serious justification to vote either way. Firstly, she could vote for Duncan because she repsected his game. On the other hand, she and Beth were on good terms back in Island. Makes a whole lot more sense narratively to me that the person who lost to the jury last time decides the winner or loser this time.)