Thread:Stryzzar/@comment-1037137-20141017070841/@comment-1741760-20141022125419

Just chipping in, I think they meant ranked as in ratings, like how many viewers they got due to being back on the island (since Island was a huge success in reception, ratings, etc.). They meant that Island and Revenge of the Island were the highest rated seasons with viewers. If my research is correct, they actually did get that with All-Stars, it had ratings as high of the likes of Island and Revenge of the Island.

Reception and quality, however, is a different story.