User blog comment:Asriel Meemurr (Ellafan4evr)/Ella vs Sugar/@comment-24971793-20140808183020

Ella was incredible in Pahkitew island but as character/competitor I think Sugar has more potential.

Ella had incredible charm, but she was a horrible competitor. She's unable to harm anyone (which is an essential part of most challenges), doesn't have any insight or strategy and is too perfect to start any trouble/conflict. If she would, it would be character derailment. So the only reason she could ever get far in a season is when she's put in the background and floats through the season (like Lightning in ROTI or Owen in nearly every season), they turn her into a godplayer (like Zoey in AS) or she get's literally carried by someone (like Cody in TDWT). All 3 of these options are bad... her singing also annoyed me in the first 2 episodes. And as I said before, her personality is "too perfect" which makes it hard to develop her character any further or give her a plot.

Sugar on the other hand is perhaps the most competitive contestant ever. Because of her pageant history her mind is 24/7 focussed on the competition and she's always planning ahead. She didn't develop throughout the season which means she still has potential to do so in a next one (I also really want to see her in a full-on pageant look. With ridiculously big hair, dress, make-up and bling bling everywhere). IMO she was the most believable antagonist since Heather in TDI. And I thought she was hilarious, she mastered gross out humor and did it at least a 100 times better than Owen. Nearly every sentence she said or action she did was a joke and most of them landed.

So in my rankings Sugar would place higher than Ella.