User blog comment:Thedramamaster/Top 5 most overhated characters/@comment-24152851-20160723130120

I guess RR Noah is a little overhated, though I can understand the complaints against him. They took away a lot of his appeal from the previous seasons, his dry sarcasm that earned him his massive fanbase. Like some people have said, he was more boring in RR compared to TDWT, and Owen was the one who shone out of the duo. Noco was never canon to begin with, and was a running joke. Though tbh, Noemma was more harder on Emma's fanbase than on Noah's, as it kept making her jump between personalities and made her hypocritical.

The problem with Duncan isn't really what he himself chose to do, it's the way the writer's favored him and gave him unfair treatment. So many characters had to get mowed over just to ensure Duncan could stay longer. Noah was eliminated in one of the most BS eliminations ever, Tyler got booted when he had so much more entertainment value, while Gwen and Courtney's friendship they had been developing for half a season got thrown out. He's one of the biggest writer's pets in the show.

Gwen is a huge mess right now, but for the most that's not her fault. It's all the crap that gets thrown at her. Though TDAS is where she herself started to plummet. They clearly had done no research whatsoever into Gwen from past seasons, and made her into a girly girl who wanted to talk about hair products and dreamed of ponies. It's this excessively OOC Gwen that got really irritating. Aside from that and looking at TD as a whole, Gwen's still a fairly well written character, but one who had to deal with so much BS.

I honestly have no problem with Sky, but she wasn't the best pick for finalist. And what she did in the finale, really made her less likable. I am no fan of Dave, and was immensely annoyed by him for several episodes after his sanity snapped over Sky. What she did in "Hurl and Go Seek" was fine, being straight with him after he spent ages being creepy and clingy. But in the finale she had to exploit his feelings for herself. I know she had no choice and wanted a helper who could be of use, but it's really hard to side with her because of that.

No, he's not, his MPD was what made him a really cool character.

Actually Mike is hated for exactly that reason. Because they're using MPD to make him interesting. Mental conditions are no joke, and should not be used as a source of humor. There have been real viewers with mental conditions who have been offended by Mike, he's up there using his mental conditions like a superpower, and ends up being cured by a press of a button, then gets the money and the girl. It does not work that way in real life. Sure, people will bring up "it's a cartoon, not meant to be realistic". However, they used a legitimate mental disorder, but failed to depict it correctly. Furthermore, as some people have pointed out, his label is literally "The Multiple Personality Disorder", as in he is defined by condition and nothing else, that's like calling a handicapped contestant "The Wheelchair Guy".