User blog comment:ThomasVeggieDramaFan/Pahkitew Island: One Year Later/@comment-27329394-20150629031753/@comment-4389268-20150629041712

If Dave did not have a storyline with Sky, then he is just a clone of Noah without the comic relief and he would be eliminated early. His romance with Sky however, the outcome is slightly similar what happen to Courtney/Scott and Gwen/Courtney. All that build up and it leads to nowhere and the character either have no development or derailed. Then again, having all major attractions become a success is too cliche so its also good that Dave did not win the girl. I mean, Trent would have ended up like Dave for example until he finally let it go. The goes with Zoey in a way.

I dont see what the fuss of Chris letting the contestants die in Scarlett Fever. His being doing this for a long time. Remember the Mine episode in TDRI, it's more so the same. Scarlett might be a poor villain but all the build up for her until this episode is actually a development for her.