User blog comment:VeryUnknownFan/Do you think the Wikia is overreacting about Total Drama All Stars?/@comment-7985501-20140131220429/@comment-24078152-20140131232035

I strongly agree with everything you said. I mean, this nose dive that TDAS took was absolutely astonishing and deplorable. I actually enjoyed every season except for All Stars. I wanted to like it. It had a lot of potential, but for the most part, it just came off as a really lame, horribly written season. I'm aware that Action and Revenge of the Island have a lot of hate, but truthfully, I really enjoyed those two seasons (though not as much as Island, of course). Give those two seasons credit for trying and for making way for some good character development and humor and for tying up the loose ends really well. I acknowledge both of them have flaws, but in the end, I'm glad I saw those seasons. Island will always be the best season imo, but in terms of my second favorite season, it's actually a three-way tie between Action, World Tour, and Revenge. I enjoyed all of those seasons thoroughly, despite their flaws, but All-Stars was just inexcusable. It seemed more unrealistic and more child-oriented. I'm probably not going to watch TDPI unless people say that's it's good or any of the old contestants cameo.