User blog comment:OMGitsGARRET/Scarlett is THE worst antagonist ever!/@comment-4758157-20140717134126

First of all. Scarlett has a better character than Mal/Mike {who is considered the worst to most fans, because scarlett had a better character development at-least (she was like a hidden villain, which i like, not just reveal in early game like others). And unlike Mal, he was a one-demonsional villain, he hadn't a great back-story (just friends with Duncan only ?) and his goal ? He wasn't a good one. Scarlett was evil in heart from beginning which wasn't even visible during her audition and the show.

And secondly, this is the first season that has not a true villain. Sure, Sugar did some antagostic things or maybe Max tried to be a mad scientist, but any villains like Scott or Heather or Al to be known from beginning ? Nope.

A great villain isn't just all about how many episodes/time appear (like Heather or Al even though they're my fav still), its about how evil they be. Scarlett didn't become crazy, she was evil at the beginning and prentented to be a nice girl. Destroying the whole island was much more evil than all Mal did, it wanted to kill the host and cast for real, which not even Heather or Alejandro did. A great villain is not about how they did things to eliminate them, and its not all about Eliminating. It's about see the people near them getting hurt both in mental and physical and see them burnt by the villain's hand. Yeah, amazing villains like Heather or Al eliminated a lot and even hurt the other cast's emotion, but its not all about Eliminating. A great villain who should be a master mind, powerful, which Heather or Al had, but one thing they didn't had: The ability to destory everyone physically or mentally in a successful plan like Scarlett did, not the one demonsional villain Mal.

Plus, even if its cartoon, total drama for older audience, not just children. we have dark cartoons like Batman: The Animated Series, not all cartoons have to be light-hearted.

You can bash me what you want, but just only eliminating somebody isn't what an epic villain should do.