User blog comment:Smv21/My Total Drama Season Rankings/@comment-4742462-20180516000710/@comment-4742462-20180517010043

OK, maybe it was a little too far to say that it would've been panned as badly as TDAS was, but at the same time I can't see it getting the same levels of praise it got had the aforementioned never existed. At best, it would've been seen as either slightly better than or about the same as TDA (or TDRI depending on which has the worse reputation).

At best, RR was only maybe halfway coherent as it was a giant mess at times for some of the reasons I've already mentioned (especially during it's last three episodes when you could tell that they were hastily rewritten in order to atone for the sudden last minute return of the Surfer Dudes).