User blog comment:Flagator24/Is Pahkitew Island better than Revenge of the island?/@comment-27157772-20180519233311

Revenge is by far a superior season.

Lets start off with the cast. ROTI had more relatable and a great, colorful range of characters with their unique strengths and weaknesses. PI had good characters, but the executions of them all were poorly done.

The interactions were a lot different. In ROTI, we had a taste on what the previous seasons had. People talking to one another, sometimes strategizing, and their interactions were more heartfelt. PI just felt force.

The villains... OMG. Talk about a huge difference. I have always talked about how Scott is a great antagonist with his strategy while contempating his biggest flaw in Grand Chef Auto. In PI, the two, dare I say, antagonists were basically insults. Starting off with Scarlett, her plot felt force. Her interaction was limited to only Max and nobody else. With Sugar, though I do admire her competitveness, the comic relief as a character didn't do much for her. Her two biggest (strategic) moves was getting rid of Ella and help drive a wedge between Dave and Sky. Other than that, a pretty lame villian.

The eliminations are as plain as night and day. ROTI had a few dull eliminations, but they were so great. There were a few that caught me off guard without the use of spoilers. I just did not like the irregular eliminations that have taken all but four in PI. Even the four regular eliminations that we did have were lame. While on the subject of PI eliminations, there are some contestants that should've been early outs and the early outs should've staed longer.