User blog comment:Epic~00/Why Total Drama All Stars Was Such An Abysmal Season (PART 6)/@comment-3410066-20150322124819/@comment-26897147-20150322153506

If anyone should've replaced Sam, the most logicial choice would be Anne Maria, since not counting Dakota who returned, she's the highest ranking competitor in TDROTI not to compete in TDAS. Though since that would cause the gebder ratio to collapse, Brick would suit well.

Honestly, to me, the 7 all-stars from the original cast should've been the final 5 of TDI, Al, and Courtney. That makes the most sense instead of what we got.