User blog comment:Total Drama Wiki! Wars/Week of June 9, 2015/@comment-24152851-20150610133156

If it was a choice between the seasons I would probably go with TDPI, but comparing casts alone I have to go with second gen. They may not have been used to the best of their ability, and while they do include a few sour notes, the cast as a whole feels a lot more natural and realistic. Even though the third gen was used better in comparison, it simply had too many gimmicks and obvious fodders. While a few of the third gen are my favorites, there's only 6 characters that I care for.