User blog comment:Fedora Kid/Moon Madness Review/@comment-460966-20131009113620/@comment-1734566-20131011161738

OK, I'm starting to see some of your logic a bit more. Just a few more points I'd like to respond to.

1. Maybe TMO was hiding under there, waiting for someone (most likely Cameron) to walk down? Villains lie in wait all the time. Alejandro hid behind that statue in TDWT when LeShawna was eliminated. Did he know she was going to hang on so that he'd have to knock her off?

3. A crack couple? OK, that's a fitting-enough description. But crack couples can turn out awesome. Look at Sam/Dakota. Once again, just because you don't like it doesn't mean the episode sucks because of it.

4. That doesn't seem fair. Just because it was the first challenge, it's OK that it was boring? The first challenge in TDA had them just running around waiting for the monster to pick off all the others first. The challenge in Hook, Line, and Screamer had them doing the same thing, just with a psycho killer instead of a monster.

5. OK, that makes a little more sense. True, she could've talked it out with Mike...but it was Cameron's glasses who were broken, and she knows that Cameron is Mike's best friend. So it makes some sense...I, however, would argue that Cameron blabbing it to Mike right in front of Zoey was much more sloppily-handled.

7. Yeah, that bothers me too. Though that's just Chris's stupidity, I guess. I mean, he made himself out to be such a genius for switching Duncan and Courtney, and now Cameron...but yeah, I guess you could argue that it wouldn't be fair to switch Mike because it's technically not Mike; it's The Malevolent One. I think even the Villains would be shocked at such a switch.

8. This point is what bothers me the most. It doesn't matter if it was OOC, that was the point. She was acting OOC on purpose, as part of a clever trick to fool her teammates and make Alejandro show that he still cared about her. She acted OOC in talking to Trent in Search and Do Not Destroy. And although that episode itself was terrible, that resulted in one of the most dastardly and strategically brilliant moves she ever made. She acted OOC in her conversation with Harold in TDDDDI. Does that mean that it sucked? No. It's Heather playing the game.

12. Um...what about the TDWT writers?

13. Once again, we do agree. Seriously, the writers are so obsessed with their cliches that they can't just give it a rest? This season had - and TDPI has - the potential to be a perfectly no-nonsense season in terms of the eliminations. 13 episodes, 14 contestants. I did this with My Fictional Time in both seasons, actually. It allows for every single episode to have one elimination in it, and if it had zero double eliminations, zero non-eliminations, and zero returns...and if you go with this easy-to-follow and easy-to-write pattern, you'd still have two contestants left by the finale. It's perfect, easy, and makes much more sense. But NO. Those stupid writers.