User blog comment:TylerSurvivorFan/Who Will Win in Canada?/@comment-25546154-20141118162941/@comment-24971793-20141118173524

Having the word supposedly doesn't really help in defending the case ;) Zoey supposedly is an indie chick that holds a grudge for jocks. They both have an interesting characterization with some depth in theory, but never lived up to it.

I do give Sky a bit more credit since she was significantly less Mary Sue-ish then Zoey. She had actual complicated obstacles to overcome and she made a lot of dumb mistakes. Her performance in the Pahkitew season really wasn't all that good to accuse of godplaying. Ok she had some gymnastic moves that even the gold medal gymnastics from beijing wouldn't be able to replicate and she occasionally floated to victory on the back of a flying crocodile, but she also nearly killed Dave cause of an idiotic plan and brought her team to shame when she couldn't jugg that water in "love you knots". So she has shortcomings, unfortunately many of the shortcomings where quirks or got blamed on other characters (Dave) ... but I would still say Sky is an improvement on Zoey (not by much though) on the matter of lacking personality and being Mary sue.