User blog comment:Webkinz Mania/"Scarlett Fever" Review/@comment-23995441-20140716231457/@comment-27329394-20140717033118

That's a reason to dislike Mike, not Mal...

Regardless, I think Scarlett was much better because she actually initiated an evil plan, whereas Mal pretty much spent the whole competition covering his identity. Also, even if Scarlett only managed to show her truly antagonistic side for a single episode, Mal never did anything half as evil as trying to blow up the whole island for the million dollars (or kill everyone trying). Similarly, Scarlett had a clear motive, whereas Mal kept changing his.