User blog comment:ArtDraw12/Total Drama Horror 4 - Episode 1/@comment-4726418-20170411235649/@comment-11883116-20170412015352

Geo, did you miss my earlier explanation. Random option chooses the choice the voters voted for if it's the case of a tie in characters' votes. If both characters vote for random option, the random victim is chosen with a certain method that references something from the actual show. For Devin it was his fall from the mountain from ep 24, for Taylor (if the random choice was chosen by both) it'd be inspired by the moment where Kelly wanted to teach her a lesson.