User blog comment:Epic~00/Why Total Drama All Stars Was Such An Abysmal Season (PART 4)/@comment-24971793-20141030161213/@comment-24152851-20141031123750

Not that I feel this way, but Courtney haters would argue that she's just being a hypocrite.

Problem with Courtney is, a lot of people (whether they like or hate her) think of her as a villain, and what she was meant to be. I have a feeling that it includes the writers, they wanted her to be the villain from the beginning, only they gave her the unique twist of being a Fallen Hero. With Courtney, the TD base seems to fall into 3 categories: Courtney haters who hate her for being Eva with brains, post-TDI Courtney fans who love her because she's so excessively cruel (typically antagonist lovers), then there's TDI "good Courtney" fans who loved her for that half a season of non-villainous personality she had and refuse to accept any of her other characterizations.