User blog comment:Epic~00/Why Total Drama All Stars Was Such An Abysmal Season (PART 4)/@comment-27588345-20141030221457/@comment-4742462-20141031014507

@TDPIScarlett, I honestly hated Pahkitew Island just as much as All-Stars for I feel it repeated a lot of the same mistakes:


 * Bad characterizations (characters like Max, Leonard, Rodney, and even Shawn would fit in much better on something like Family Guy or Robot Chicken)


 * Character Derailment (Dave's is record breaking).


 * Painfully obvious eliminations (Topher)


 * Aborted Arcs left and right (Samey's friendship with Jasmine and trying to be her own person)


 * Constant insutling of your intelligence (everything from the ending of Twinning Isn't Everything through A Blast from the Past, Scarlett falling for the Chris bot, Sugar eliminating Jasmine, and the entirety of Pahk'd with Talent)


 * An episode that invalidates one of the main plots making most of the season feel pointless (Sundae Muddy Sundae 2: Lies, Cries and No Prize).

And then there's Sugar... So help me god if their not only stupid enough to put her another season but as a finalist!

I wasn't reallty surprised to learn that the season didn't have any rewrites in order avoid a lot of production problems because the whole thing feels like a rough first pass that they rushed to get out.