Thread:Fedora Kid/@comment-2091662-20151127221038/@comment-1734566-20151129020720

Again, if they were actually stupid enough to cast the contestants of KR SPECIFICALLY by their beauty/brains/brawn, then they deserve the hate that season could get, since it would prove that they learned literally JACK from the failure of Season 29. Probst even admitted that the original BvBvB theme was created AFTER they cast the season, simply as an excuse to separate the tribes. And you can tell, because the traits were SO interchangeable among all three: Beauty on the Brawn tribe (pretty much all three Brawn dudes), Brawn on the Brains tribe (Tasha and Spencer), Brains on the Beauty tribe (Brice and LJ), etc., etc. When the swap came, it wasn't a HUGE mix-up. In a case like, say, Worlds Apart, the tribal divisions really made sense, and their attributes truly did affect the way they all played: White Collars were collectively strategic rather than strong or social, the Blue Collars were purely physical and focused on camp life rather than strategy or social, and the Red Collars were laid-back and very friendly/popular, rather than cunning or strong (except Joe, duh). So while something like a WA II would work, a BvBvB II would fail miserably IF that was their intention in the casting process.