User blog comment:Zoether/Antagonists ranking/@comment-1376932-20131219001345/@comment-23995441-20131222215621

Everyone wanted Heather gone because she treated them like crap...so that's not a very valid point. Gwen didn't win all the time in TDI she only won four challenges, Heather won more challenges.

Heather is a 60 pound stick.....I doubt she actually put fear in anyone. And Beth stood up to Heather too infact Lindsay cursed Heather out to her face, so I don't understand what you mean. None of the antagonists actually put fear in anyone.

That's like saying if you take the plot out Heather would have been gone in Search and Do Not Destroy. All of the antagonists rely on plot sometimes, the problem with Scott though was that he relied on it too much. What does Duncan eliminating Courtney have to do with her being a good antagonist?

I never said Alejandro didn't have strategy but I like Courtney's better because she didn't godplay as much to accomplish her goals. You admit that Courtney manipulating Justin was impressive but give her only a 4?