User blog comment:Spiderguy56/ranking the total drama's form worst to best/@comment-25194000-20141124063341/@comment-1037137-20141125010651

I am saying that I think the season is fundamentally flawed no matter how intriguing its setup is, and that I do not agree with its popularity at all. I never did. I openly consider it overrated. If people like it fine, but I by no means am required to agree with them.

It isn't nitpicking TDPIScarlett. This nonsense I listed from the season is far more prominent than that, and a lot of it loaded with the old stupidities of the series that I wish the writers would learn to drop.

The Feral Zeke joke still continues at our expense, regardless of his absence in TDPI. They were steely enough to bring him back for more in TDROTI and TDAS, giving him his own episode in the latter case. You can blame this season for what is widely considered one of the most unwarranted derailments of any character and one of the worst running gags that remains ongoing. It could resurface later, do not be too self-assured by the lack of him in TDPI.

Well they were a band of likable characters all derailed in some way just to be pure fodder. I did not find that cool at all. Nor does my feelings about the Strong Team vs. Weak Team formula change in a season with three teams, doesn't make a difference to me.

That's not what I've seen when it comes to talk of Sierra. At least not in any discussion where TDAS does not come up. She seems to be one of the darlings of TDWT, if not the whole series.

Not a very good point about Tyler and Noah. No offense intended, but they were becoming nicely fleshed out here and coming into their own. And this season was giving some overlooked contestants some nice spotlight similar to how TDA did for at least a few people. But give TDA credit, it didn't throw that away for the sake of a controversy that never had to be. For all of its faults, TDA rarely committed that offense for the people it did want to give more spotlight to. Except for Cody, TDWT seemed pretty eager to unravel that, and opinion isn't really in favor of Cody much these days it almost seems like.

What are you getting at? She still had absolutely no purpose or business being a contestant whether it was for two, one episodes, or even ten minutes. She doesn't belong in the running. And seeing how they have stated no intention to reuse her anytime in the future, that just makes her more pointless of an addition to this season. She'd have been more smartly used as the actual selected Aftermath hostess.

Not an excuse for the way any of the three are used, were used, and continue to be used. It was a disgusting mess that took advantage of them in all the wrong ways. An ugly controversy that still has fans at each other's throats in some places. And it wasn't properly resolved, any of the tension it had caused. And it's a true ***pull, they had to f*** with their personalities quite a bit to put it into motion, all without the more appropriate buildup and all while sending some pretty bad messages to the crowd it was aimed at. It was a marathon of audience insulting stupidity.

And that episode still sucks. If it weren't for Wreck-ening, I'd still call it the worst finale, I'm being totally honest with you.