Thread:TRRFan6/@comment-26986696-20180901230614/@comment-4742462-20181104022043

Stolen5487 wrote: ThomasVeggieDramaFan wrote: FloridaMan wrote: I thought Aquarium for a Dream was bad because the entire episode only had one joke and not a particularly funny one at that.

Germ Factory didn't really have any jokes that I found funny and, yeah, didn't really care for the puking.

I know I'm in the minority, but I despised Tiger Fail's dark, depressing, and mean-spirited ending. Screw that episode.

The fact that it's a one-joke episode was the reason why I didn't care for it either. That, and Gwen here was mostly her GINO (Gwen in name only) self for the sake of Goths pandering.

Germ Factory feels more like a TTG! episode honestly just based on it's premise.

I like Tiger Fail the most of these three, but it's ending is a classic example of mostly fine episodes for whatever reason completely crapping themselves in the last 10 to 30 seconds. Granted, here it's not as bad as in say... Scarlett Fever

Regarding Tiger Fail, I don't care how good the rest of the episode was, the ending completely ruins it. Having Cody die is going way too far. No one wants to see that, even his haters. I am just glad it was of old age, rather than have him die a horrific, gruesome Kenny-like death but the fact that no one even cared makes it even worse.

That's pretty much how I feel about Scarlett Fever. Doesn't matter how good most of the rest of the episode was, they crap themselves so hard in those last two minutes that not only does it screw the episode over, it completely screws over Scarlett's entire plot (which was the only one I actually gave a crap about in Pahkitew Island)! Yet for whatever reason, most fans just tend to ignore how badly written it was despite them ripping apart the ending of I See London... for similar reasons.

If I was Evany Rosen (my mindset for how bad an episode turns out is "If you wrote it, then 90% of it is your fault!"), I would've ended the episode the same way except have the quiet game carry out to only anywhere between three days to a whole week and have Cody lose by some other means (like sneezing) while keeping him alive obviously.