User blog comment:The Noah Killer/Total Drama Action: My Way/@comment-35606925-20190903015448

My Rankings:

7. World Tour

First is the worst as they say. I put WT here as retroactively Action makes it kind of...pointless. I mean the final two of WT is Noah and Leshawna, who are very closely tied to the canon fianlists of the previous seasons (I see it as Harold since Courtney, if forced to choose, would totally pick Harold). Additionally, while your All Stars Heather is great, you sacrifed WT Heather to do it. Honestly, I liked it but it's worse than canon.

6. Revenge of the Island

This season is good but flawed. Scott and Lightning going out so early kind of sucks. I also thought having two returnees at the final four was really awkward. The final four itself was good. Virtually tied with Revenge. Another that I'd say was worse than canon, but just barley.

5. Pahkitew Island

I'd say this season was neutral. For as many good changes you made there was just as many bad ones. I liked how you fleshed out certain characters such as Beardo and Ella while eliminating garbage like Lennard and Rodney early. Your season has one MAJOR problem with it though: The finale four sucks. I mean that by there was no conflict. it's why antagonists typically make the final four at worst. Also, while I like what you did with Ella, still don't see her as great finalist material.

4. OG Island

Another neutral season. With the exception of Duncan going early, you played the season safe. Would probably be ranked higher than Action if you switched Cody and Duncan's placements. I know that Duncan is a returning player but Cody feels like he was pointless.

3. Action

Maybe this is becuase this is fresh in my mind but I'd say it was your first better. Geoff returning in place of Owen makes a lot of sense, nobody went too far either...mostly. You again suffer from the problem of Courtney and Geoff making the final 4. Geoff being eliminated an episode earlier would have fixed this. Popular but solid two in Harold and Lindsay as icing on the cake.

2. All Stars

You sacrificed WT to make this work, and, for what it's worth, it paid off. Great final two and all around great elimination order. It sill has flaws (I would've switched Leshawna and Al's placements) but this is lengths and bounds ahead of the original.

1. Finale

Is there even a comparison to be made? A brand new original season 26 episodes long, with new storylines and wrapping up all the loose ends. Additionally, Duncan and Dawn is a great final two. I wish this season was really made (even if there were changes to make it work in the canon universe).