User blog comment:TDFan4Ever/If you could change 1 elimination/@comment-31556666-20141019122457/@comment-25297892-20141019142333

TDI:

Lindsay:unfair elimination that saved (again) the guts of the 2 pets of the Writers,aka Duncan and Owen,but at least was necessary to provide the ultimate drama and marked Heather as the ultimate reality queen bee.

Izzy II:right time (maybe),but in a very unfair and senseless way.This was one of the biggest mistake of coerence ever made by the authors,and the biggest of this season,sure.http://totaldrama.wikia.com/wiki/User_blog:King_Flurry51/Izzy:Popular_Underdog_or_Forgotten_All_Star%3F

Geoff:sincerely once both Bridgette and his fellow partner DJ weren't anymore in the game,Geoff was kind of plotless...unfair elimination,but at the right time sure.

Leshawna:along with Izzy and Lindsay,another victim of Heather's luck provided for her by the authors.

Duncan:the only season he deserved to be a finalist.

Owen:same of Duncan,even if both were saved too many times.

TDA:

Lindsay:no comment,really.

Izzy II:I add this because I HATE that episode,and above all the random way they again eliminated Izzy ONLY to make Justin to appear as a villain,while he was only a dork floater.

Harold:he should have been finalist and Owen never returned.

Owen:floated and derailed.

TDWT:

Lindsay:again,no comment,considering Team Victory lost mostly because of DJ's curse problems.Also he wanted to quit...boh.

Izzy:another ridicolous device they used to rid off her.As a fan of Izzy,I cried in that episode,really T^T

Noah:most unfair elimination ever seen,just a dumb plot device to make Duncan to return and above all a clear device to keep Alejandro in a safe position.Coincidentially,when Noah was eliminated,both Tyler and Owen went down terribly becoming plotless and useless,just puppets of Al.

Gwen:should have been eliminated in Amazon Race so to not have the idiot triangle hogging the scene.Courtney in Sea Shanty,instead.

TDAS:

Lindsay:both Courtney and Sierra were the reason of that defeat,but Lindsay got all the fault without a reason.

Light:one of the few elimination done in the right time.The floater was now a fodder.

Jo:Courtney over Jo,for her coward attitude.

Heather:mah...there should have been many other cleverer ways to make Alejandro revenging on her than such a childish mistake.

Duncan:he was PLOTLESS all the time,I barely noticed him in Moon Madness only for the Gwuncan end,that I liked.He was as generic and bland as Zoey...I would have eliminated him in Moon Madness,infact.

Cameron:he was totally derailed cause of Sierra and Courtney.

Alejandro:he got simply an humiliation conga moment the audience was expecting for his villain sue in TDWT.

Courtney:awesome elimination,deserved derailment,and finally some KARMA.She was the immoralest of the Whole season 5 and should have been eliminated in the third episode,but floated again and had a dumber plot after another,starting from her conflict-friendship-Katie-Sadie moments with Gwen to the rushed Scourtney couple.

Scott:no offense,but Scott was a complete floater.Funny to see,but really the weakest memeber of the villains.And he lasted so much than I expected.

TDPI:

Samey:one of the few elimination I completely disliked in this season.

Ella:Sugar in place of her.

Topher:lol,the non contestant floater.I think the only reason he lasted so much was because he was one of the few not completely forgettable males remained.Anyway,this generation had only one decent male:Shawn.

Max:I thought he would have been the second Kinosewak eliminated.Scarlett's obsession on him was literally HER ruin and showed how harmless is this "main" villain to be unable to rid off a "Too Dumb to live" chubby chunk as Max.The way the eliminated him was at the right time but for the completely wrong reason.It was like seeing Plankton buy honestly a Krabby Patty but being arrested just for being evil.