User blog comment:Epic~00/Character Appreciation - Week 43: Scott/@comment-27157772-20171026225712

Same reason why I have two template's as Cody. I am neutral on Scott.

Contrary to what most people on this wiki believe, I actually thought Scott's strategy on ROTI was a stroke of brilliance. By losing multiple challenges, he was making himself appear weak to the Maggots and weaseling himself into their good graces through the help of Zoey. Through his convincing deception, Scott also got rid of likeable characters of B and Dawn. I would agree that his strategy was extremely risky if enough people found out, but he managed to get enough people to keep him safe while getting rid of his targets.

If I had any critiques on his gameplay, it is the fact that he could have played merge episode better by eliminating Cameron instead of Mike. By doing that, you aren't betraying Zoey's trust if the lie is convincing enough and you aren't making an enemy out of her by eliminating her BF.

In All-Stars, Scott's game was subpar to the initial theme of the season, which was the best of the best. The devious strategy Scott brought to the table in ROTI was quickly out the window. Sure, he is not going to be a same trick pony, especially if that one trick involves losing challenges. However, what has Scott done in AS that wasn't a comic relief jab? His only main move in that season was the suggestion to throw a challenge to get rid of Lightning. Other than that, he hung around Courtney most of the time and basically became a sheep when he used to the shephard leading the sheep to the slaughter house.