User blog comment:VeryUnknownFan/Do you think the Wikia is overreacting about Total Drama All Stars?/@comment-27329394-20140202031117

I haven't watched the season (I currently don't plan on it either), but bad or good, fans of a show will tend to point out every detail because they know what to expect and get upset when it deviates from the norm. The "randomness" people are pointing out is an example - the show is not known for its randomness, and if it was nonsensical then problems will ensue amongst the fanbase. This tends to happen when you reach later seasons of a show - they get more goofy to "top" the humor they had before and it just ends up being goofy.

I don't think its overreacting at all. In fact, it is more than likely a more realistic take on the show as a whole since we have seen all the seasons and therefore have something to compare it to, as Season 1 set the "standard" of the show which it seems to have deviated from, which is almost never a good thing.

Again, I'm basing this off of other shows that have veered off into similar paths, so I could be off. It could even be a case of a broken base considering wiki veterans hate the Mike + Zoey pairing since there have been much more realistic and entertaining pairings in the show's history that newer viewers have not seen before.