User blog comment:ArtDraw12/Biggest plot holes, goofs, mistakes & inconsistencies in Total Drama series/@comment-27157772-20161106145309

From the part of where contestants are eliminated after finding out who the antagonist is, you also have to consider that there might be footage that was edited out. Alejandro could've persuaded Tyler to vote for Noah after him and Own left him on the rack. Alejandro could've also convinced Duncan to vote off Noah being a 3-2 vote.

I think Alejandro voted off Tyler because he feels like the jock's usefulness has run out. Sure he was a vote, but for how long can Alejandro keep him around? Tyler did destroy his team's artifact on accident, so that could be a reason.