User blog comment:Zoether/Do you want this to be to the last season with the original cast?/@comment-1708265-20131006025825/@comment-1708265-20131006172109

I have to agree with you for the most part. Katie was the fifth eliminated in TDI and competed in six episodes. Sadie was the tenth eliminated and competed in eleven episodes. I would love to see these two actually get their own personalities by being on the opposite teams. If they beg to be on the same team Chris should make them switch teams (although they still aren't on the same team) and when they start complaining Chris says remember what happened last time and there is a backflash of them arguing and Katie's elimination and Sadie crying over the elimination.

Gwen she would only need to come back depending on how she is in TDAS, because this is somewhat a redemption season for her, and I would love to see her make it to the final three again. :)

Owen, I don't think he needs to return for a redemption season at all, the lowest he's ever placed was ninth (tenth if you include his return) place (i.e. TDA) and then later returned to make it to the final three again. And for his last season he made it to the merge (again) and placed eighth although if it wasn't for Blaineley debuting he would've come in seventh.

Mike, I personally don't think he should be in a redemption season (don't get me wrong I'm a Mike fan) because he merged in TDROTI and placed sixth, and in TDAS he is the main antagonist (that's what it looks like anyways) and is most likely to make it to at least the final four.

Jo, she placed fifth in TDROTI but then was the third eliminated in TDAS so she's one of those that doesn't exactly need a redemption season but it would be nice to see her again especially if there is a Eva/Jo rivalry.

Lightning, was the winner/runner up in TDROTI but was the second eliminated in TDAS. I personally don't think he needs a redemption season because we've seen enough of him, he has humor and everything but isn't needed to come back. If he does return make sure he's eliminated before the merge preferably in the middle of the team parts (say there is 20 contestants and he comes in 15th.)

Izzy she definitely needs to return. She has only made it to the merge once (i.e. TDI) although she had to return in order to make it to the merge. In TDA she was the third person eliminated and then returned and was once again eliminated and was the seventh eliminated. In TDWT she was in an accident and was the seventh eliminated to her injuries. She has probably done worse than any other contestant that was in the first three seasons and definitely needs to merge (without having to return.)

Cody, I am a fan of him but I don't think he needs to return. In TDI he was only eliminated (episode 9) because of his injuries, and in TDWT he placed 3rd and his storyline was pretty much based on him trying to avoid Sierra, and most of his jokes were because of her. He's a good competitor because he doesn't do bad enough in challenges on his team to be eliminated, and then he isn't a strong enough contestant to be considered a threat, and he just kind of slides right through the competition.

I'd be fine with Heather returning (only if she is eliminated in soon (before episode 6 or 7.)) But Duncan no, he definitely does not deserve to be in a redemption/underdog season he is the total opposite of a underdog, he is a total godplayer, he's always placed in the final five in the first three seasons besides in TDWT when he was the first eliminated (and returned,) although if he wouldn't of quit he would have definitely placed high again anyway, and has never had anything really bad happen to him so he doesn't need to be redeemed so I'm against him returning. I like how in a video Christian Potenza said that Duncan is the favorite character for all the fans of the show and I'm thinking "No, no he's not, in fact he's one of the least favorite." (He has a lot of fans but then a lot of people hate him.)