User blog comment:TheDipDap1234/Duncan - a Good or a Bad character?/@comment-25027229-20141115234814

He's pretty low on my rankings, but I won't call him poorly written for the most part. In TDI, he was decent at best, but I hated his conflict with Harold with a passion. In TDA, he was worse than before, but I gradually learned to like him until he snuck his way out of every other vote by dumb luck. I thought his reign of terror was over when he got booted first in TDWT, but then my most hated episode from the season, "I See London..." happened and I lost all interest in him as a person and a character. However, his good guy plot in All-Stars was fantastic and rejuvenated my toleration of the guy. His long overdue karma was perfect too and even though I hope her never comes back to the show, at least I don't despise him.