User blog comment:VeryUnknownFan/Do you think the Wikia is overreacting about Total Drama All Stars?/@comment-1756703-20140131160454

It's not just the wiki that has criticized TDAS. Have you gone on Tumblr? Lots of TD fans on there, and the vast majority of them were disappointed by TDAS.

And anyways, the Youtubers tend to be younger and not as easily disappointed. The comments section on TDAS videos tend to consist of hardcore Mike, Zoey, and Zoke fans who constantly rag on characters like Courtney and Alejandro. Thus I usually can't take them seriously.