User blog comment:Fire Eater/Call to Save Total Drama/@comment-4758157-20140115103133

The show neither doesnt suck nor is a failure. Its about the lack of writing and a letdown of next seasons. For me, TDI is one of only seasons that has its full magic and it was the best, it introduced as the kind of a reality show for childern, something that never happened before and was unique. Thats why the first season is known to anyone around the world and its the most successful. TDA was pretty excellent as well, introducing new theme with movies stuff, the relationships were pretty good, but it wasnt as creative as first one.

TDWT was the season that revived that old magic, and making a musical themed reality show, that it sounded sweet, cast songs, they were all happy. It recieved positive reviews, TDWT was even more successful than TDA. TDRI was also harshed at the beginning with 13 episodes and new cast, and most fans were dissappointed. However, as it was confirmed to get back to island, they were happy. Eventually, TDRI was successful and got good reviews, although it was critized by fans that the character development wasnt as good as first cast, and it was kinda true.

The interesting note is TDAS was opposite of TDRI, it began as the most anticipated season and actually turned out, the worst season of series according to fans or critics due to the lack of character development and unfair eliminations. It left many cliffhangers and eventually turned a hateful season as the camp sinked, Courtney's unfair writing, short relationships, etc. I agree that TDAS challenges weren't creative, as they were mix of previous ones from previous seasons. However, i really think TDPI will bring the magic that TDWT or TDI had, and it'll be successful. Calling it from now!

At the conclusion, this show only needs excellent writers and directors. If we have good ones or the ones from TDI crew, i'm sure TDPI will be very successful and bring those jokes, character development, and unique challenges back.