User blog comment:NesteaCookie/Total Drama: Pahkitew Island - NesteaCookie's Way/@comment-32999728-20191014124647/@comment-32999728-20191014140009

Okay, Duncan's not a character everyone likes, he's more of a base breaking character since many like you really hate him.

The reason I hate Amy and not Heather, Al, or Duncan is because they had varying interactions, had more character, and more and better moments while Amy's just the cliche bossy older sister that interacted with no one except Samey and was only there to help with Samey's development (which kinda worked since Samey's a fan favorite).