User blog comment:ConkerChu/Who Would You Like to See Again?/@comment-4742462-20150703172045

Scarlett (main antagonist, and actually truly focused upon this time)

Amy & Samey

Jasmine (main protagonist)

Eva (secondary antagonist/rivalry with Jo)

Beth (deserves another chance simply for being a finalist)

Izzy

Tyler

Brick

Dawn

B

Jo (rivalry with Eva)

Trent

Dakota (only if she's normal again)

Dave (but only if he was like the way he was in the first two episodes of Pahkitew Island. No romance plots either)

Sky (establish that her and Dave did ultimately work it out to just stay friends right away and then move on from there. No more romances for her as well).

Noah

Bridgette

Geoff

Ella (fodder)

Everyone else not listed should either be brought back but only after a very long break, has no chance of returning, shouldn't return due to being overused, or is a lost cause by this point.