User blog comment:WreakerOfClash/Positives with All-Stars/@comment-1527105-20171008005804/@comment-30567301-20171008060221

ok but the biggest problem with noah and tyler is like. they can't hold a story?? like yeah tyler sort of developed in TDWT but it was more of a short-and-sweet thing. if he stayed i could see him being like the lindsay to alejandro's heather but honestly did we wanna see that again? and noah is just... he can't hold a story without being ooc. he just can't. they tried to make him important in RR and it worked horribly. i'm not against noah making it far but they'd have to actually like... put effort into it and not just be like "hey he likes [random chick that makes no sense] so now he's nice!". maybe idk he'd be good if he stayed longer in tdwt i just. i don't think he would be able to do that much.

duncan wasn't useless, he just wasn't as useful once gwen/courtney left. he still had other things to do, and i doubt that tyler/noah would fill the role of him if he did leave before them.