User blog comment:TheTDQueen2014/Who's the BEST and WORST Writer?/@comment-24245380-20141114044708/@comment-24152851-20141114080957

Yes Mal's a villain stu, case closed, and they had to dumb Courtney down to give him easy passage. It was very OOC for Courtney to leave the chart around. Though only reason Scarlett is badly done is she shouldn't even be an antagonist at all.

And I never said cruel Courtney was OOC, I'm not sure where I stand on the whole cruel VS nice Courtney thing, but Courtney fans would argue her TDI personality was real. Whatever, that's besides the point. She did go all "Bridgette" all of a sudden, but that's still no excuse to set up that long line of OOC before reverting her back with no explanation. In TDI she turned evil because Harold had her eliminated, what's the excuse this time? Nothing. She was on top of the world, so she had no reason to suddenly act that way.