User blog comment:MHS0501/MY Biggest Problem with Total Drama All Stars:/@comment-25297892-20150806104512

Even before the season began, I was really disappointed about the cast, few likable characters (on my side) and only screenhoggers from the first generation, with the exception of Lindsay but she was the first boot. They simply confused All Stars with All Screentime, because they didn't consider those characters that, despite having a minor screentime than Duncan & company, showed in the past some heroic values or really negative vibes, and also they didn't even thought about bringing back some unfinished conflicts like Dawn and Scott, Noah and Alejandro, Izzy and Justin, exc..

Many characters had potential to join All Stars:


 * Izzy, Harold, Owen and Leshawna for their amount of screentime, overall huge and similar to Lindsay's. Izzy is a fanfavorite since first generation and got all the first three seasons, a pure wildcard that IMO should have been used for Mal, Harold and Owen no need to explain, and Leshawna...meh..just because she starred in TDI.


 * Cody, Noah, and Dawn as pure underdogs with conflicts never explored enough and also as character that in their minor roles played an heroic part respectively in TDWT, TDWT and TDROTI. Cody and Noah would have given a reason for Alejandro to be a little more original than what seen in TDAS, basically 99% of the plot was with Heather, while Dawn could have contributed to Scott's redemption that was kind of dumbplayed..


 * Justin as villain vulture fodder together Ligthning.