User blog comment:NesteaCookie/Total Drama: Pahkitew Island - NesteaCookie's Way/@comment-4400695-20191012233732/@comment-35606925-20191013040612

Returning players in the finale don't generally work for me. Amy conceptually works and is an exception as she was robbed by Sammy. However, Amy is a complete jerk. Her returning to win doesn't sit right with me. If she didn't leave though, I think it's still a solid finale.