User blog comment:YoungEezy27/3rd Alternate Ending?/@comment-3573655-20141006220931/@comment-24152851-20141008004823

@Tamoti, I never said Sugar wasn't an antagonist. I said Sugar sucked as an antagonist, but that doesn't mean she get to escape scot-free for the things that she did.

I agree the 2 relationships mash-up was not the best idea, and I'm not entirely opposed to a Sky-Sugar finale and would've found it tolerable-ish, but thing is she shouldn't even have made it there to begin with. I think everyone was getting sick of antagonists making the finales just because their antagonists, and if that was the case it should have been Scarlett who made it.

I said Sugar is worse than Mal, because he could've been good. He just got given shoddy writers. I can't see Sugar becoming a good villain if Chris Nolan was signed up to write this, she simply isn't villain material. She's dumb, she's unfit, everyone hates her, she keeps holding back the team (with her consistent attempts to eliminate Ella, and eating everything), so what reason has she got to be there? I'll tell you how, because she godplays. Which is even more ridiculous than Zoey's (who at least was quite fit and had moderate intelligence). She makes it far simply because that's what the writers want and don't backup the reasons for it. You honestly expect by stupidly climbing to the top of the tree it would conveniently fly her all the way to the finish line while knocking Sky on the other side? While I had already expected the slingshot thing, I thought she would catchup to Sky not win all in one go for doing absolutely nothing. Furthermore, some of her godplays are completely pointless. What was the point of throwing the coin from 100 feet away if Ella was going to be eliminated anyway?

@Ella, thank you. :)

@Scarlett, they had so many villains this season and I don't know for the life of me why they chose Sugar to make it far. This feels like the whole Lightning over Jo thing all over again: "Oh crap, we just kicked out the main antagonist Scarlett. Who's left? Eh, sure why not?"

I pretty much agree with eliminating Ella. She wasn't even officially the antagonist at that stage. At that point what she did to Ella wasn't anymore antagonistic than Duncan pranking Harold, Eva having a spaz attacks, or Jo picking on Cameron.