User blog comment:Sunsummer7/Why Total Drama Island Can Never Be Replicated/@comment-25027229-20150718121247/@comment-1741760-20150718130833

I agree. Since Total Drama has naturally become it's own series, it makes sense not to judge how great a season is not by how it replicated Island but by how good it was in Total Drama standards.

And for how awesome Island was, it definitely still had it's flaws. It was fairly inconsistent and some of the eliminations were forced. Also I think sometimes lines were repeated so much it drove me nuts, and some of the voices weren't as vigorous as they would come to be.

Still good, but not perfect. Looking forward to RR though, it's a great idea!