Thread:UnderdogFan28/@comment-4742462-20151204023419/@comment-4742462-20160206055848

@UunderdogFan28, Scarlett was my favorite from that season because she had the only plot that was worth giving a crap about. Unfortunately, it proved to be too complex and not entirely thought out for such a short season. Jasmine would've been my favorite had she not been bogged down with one of that season's many forced plots (being mad at Shawn when she was planning on taking the fall anyways) but 2nd best for that season's pretty good too. Sky & Ella were the only other ones that I really gave a crap about.

Yeah, we've talked about Dunce getting worse in every season (including All-Stars despite what others would say) before. Courtney was OK in Island but became insufferable when she was (intentionally) derailed for Action. She started out fine in World Tour but went back to rock bottom around the halfway mark thanks to the triangle. Started off in All-Stars at rock bottom still only to become OK again after Suckers Punched only to go back to rock bottom AGAIN after Sundae Muddy Sundae. At this point, she would be better off simply being retired as it's obvious the writers don't agree on what they want to do with her character.

I can't really bring myself to hate Gwen either as she was my initial favorite of the series (and still is in terms of the original series, but 2nd overall after Crimson when both shows are taken into account), but my opinion of her is somewhat lowered thanks to All-Stars. Well, would you at least admit that she was also guilty in terms of the love triangle and that All-Stars in the long run really didn't do her any favors?

I could honestly care less about Samey as she definitely gets too much credit for being such a stale character (everything about her revolves around her conflict with Amy) and it isn't helped that Twinning Isn't Everything is one of the most overrated episodes of the series for it's ending that was one of several cases of that season insulting the audience's intelligence for the sake of plot.

Dawn's become my favorite from the 2nd cast essentially by default as she 1. Didn't return (unlike Mike & Zoey) or 2. Had something completely horrible happen to her (Dakota). I would definitely want to see her return, but because of the two aforementioned points it's probably for the best that she (along with a few others that I like who haven't competed in ages) doesn't come back. I mean, I was initially excited to hear Geoff was coming back... And look at how the spinoff lowered my opinion of him.

Can My Way or Zimbabwe be considered underrated? Because even though it was pretty 'meh', it was also one of the more passable episodes.