User blog comment:TheDipDap1234/After Re-Watching TDROTI/@comment-1037137-20150419155755

I still stand by my enjoyment of this season when it first came out, but I better understand why perhaps some did not, and that's totally cool. The cast I actually feel is better than the third cast but suffers from the fact that 1) The better ones are not used to their full and obvious potential and 2) Mike and Zoey, undeniably a sore point for many and myself now. Yeah, it's probably never gonna escape the latter count there. But that said, I still found the challenges enjoyable and the island theme, didn't bug me that badly. And there were some awesome characters mixed into this lot I'd love to see come back for a much more fulfilled run. But it is also the season where some of the more "childish" aspects became undeniable I suppose.

I still think Revenge of the Island is an okay season compared to some of the others, and still holds up far better than the season to come immediately after it. But yeah, it's got its share of problems to keep in mind so that they don't reemerge later. It's got some serious issues, but I still appreciate the parts that still hold up, particularly the characters outside of the trio. Heck, Cameron was still okay back then. But yeah, I understand why not everyone likes it.