User blog comment:BatmanBaleLover/Seasons' reception based on Rotten Tomatoes ranking/@comment-26897147-20140616104607/@comment-4758157-20140616115629

@Moneyballer: well, both action and revenge have their own good things. In Action, there were more intractions, aftermaths, and some challenges, and it raised some characters such as Justin and Beth. In Revenge, they return to the island where it all began but with a new twist (although it wasn't well with most fans aka toxic), and some challenges with some creatures were interesting, some characters such as Dakota, Sam, Brick, Jo shined, especially, the cameos (Heather and Lindsay had the best since their parts were major).

But there's one thing i find TDRI a little better, they had a new cast, it wasn't the same 1st generation. Sure, i admit i love 1st generation cast, more. But TDA was just like TDI with less characters, and a movie theme instead of island one. And this season was more success in terms of both critics and ratings, and according to McGillis. However, its your opinion and i respect that. And i think they're on same level, but i feel TDRI is better a bit in my opinion.