User blog comment:DougSmith/What's Your Favorite Season/@comment-2205520-20110110001017

Obviously Island was the best season. It was a classic with all the characters competing and great quotes. Action, well... The main thing I don't like about it is that it destroyed all the great stuff they created in Island. Where do I begin? TxG breakup, Duncan sreenhogging, (making Justin an antagonist? what were they thinking?, ruining all the good relationships, Owen and Duncan make it to the final four AGAIN, the whol season was kind of... bland. But it did have the best final five: Lindsay, Beth, Courtney Duncan and moslty Harold. That was the best thing about action was Harolds awesome character development. And Lindsay's too.

Aside from that, TDWT was certainly an action-packed season which thankfully brought back some of the underdogs (Tyler, Ezekiel, Cody...) for some better character development and the season also freshened things up by bringing in new characters and changing the locations. The downside is Some bad character development for Cody, the skethy ending, Alejandro in general, Duncan returning (screen hog) and mst of all, the whole stupid Duncan-Courntey-Gwen love triangle. That completely ruined the second half of the season and made me loathe those characters.

Aside from that, it was good. TDI is still the best season ever as I don't think TDR will be as awesome.