User blog comment:SEGASister/WHO IS BEST ORIGINAL CASTMATE?!/@comment-7985501-20140517211140/@comment-1708265-20140517232421

Okay, here's the reasons why I prefer Sadie over Katie. When they got in their argument, Sadie said that Katie was bad with directions, and was stating facts about how her sense of direction was bad. Katie said that she was much prettier than Sadie (which I agree with, but I think Sadie is cuter) and said that Sadie's butt was too big to fit in a bus seat. Would you really want a 'best' friend that would say something like that? Also, when people say that Sadie deserved to be eliminated over Katie, I must remind you that Katie was the one that noticed that blueberries, and was the one that got them lost, since Sadie was following where Katie was going. I say that Katie's elimination was instant karma for what she said to Sadie.

Also, SDF you used Katie having a boyfriend as why you liked Katie more. Don't forget that Sadie was taking about the bad date that she had with the guy with bad breath.

Anywho, the only stick out moment that Katie ever had for me was when she through up on Sadie, her dodgeball, her and Sadie getting poison ivy on their butts, and her and Sadie's facial expression when Ezekiel said that men are stronger than females. Notice how two of them involve Sadie. While Sadie, has her doing the splits, farting in the pool, has those many one liners, the can in her belly button, her and Lindsay doing the phobia factor challenge, her friendship with Harold and Lindsay, helping DJ conquer his fear, her lines in the TDWT finale "AleHUNKdro" and "Even if it was Heather" which could have easily went to Katie since her voice actress voices Lindsay, but Katie didn't talk. Sadie and Katie didn't even hesitate to jump off the cliff, they both did well on the sleeping challenge, Sadie didn't even have a chance in dodgebrawl, Katie got them lost in Sucky Outdoors, Sadie did good in the phobia factor, did well in the boney island challenge, did good in the paintball deer challenge, good in cooking challenge, and even did good in the trusting challenge, but didn't hear Chris say it was over so she kept trying and was wrongfully eliminated when DJ should have been.

In my opinion Sadie's more interesting, she has those one liners, and is smarter, quirkier, nicer, and funnier than Katie. To me she has more potential of the two (they both have lots of potential) but I could see Sadie being an antagonist over Katie.