User blog comment:HammerBro101/How I Would Rewrite Total Drama All-Stars/@comment-27157772-20180623195300/@comment-31967823-20180625072645

Cameron and Gwen get eliminated first because as much as I like them and as much as I like Cameron being independent and strong, they previously made it to the finals, so there's no point in them making it far this season. Duncan's behavior in TDAS turned him into a bland and unlikable character, and the writers treated him awfully. The writers also went WAY too heavy on Lindsay and Lightning's stereotypes. The only good character derailment is Sierra, because Sierra's character derailment (Sierra going crazy and beginning to lose her sanity) led to a very satisfying elimination. Blaineley joined when the merge happened in Total Drama World Tour. Also, she is a host in most of her appearances, so I asked myself, "why not make Blaineley and All-Star?"