User blog comment:TheDipDap1234/Duncan - a Good or a Bad character?/@comment-26897147-20141115222447

I usually go from liking him to...meh. In TDI, I barely noticed him, he was just pretty meh to me. I didn't start liking him fully until TDA, considering how overexposed he was and all, but I still stuck by his side and wanted him to win the season over the boring bland Beth. The only season I didn't like him in was TDWT, where he was just straight up pointless and didn't need to return to the competition after already hogging screentime in the first two seasons, but I began to like him when he returned in AS, he was pretty much the only good character that season.

So yeah...I would say he's a neutral character in terms of characterization, but I wouldn't say bad. Just an overexposed and iconic character is all.