User blog comment:Cody73/The good about TDAS (Yes folks.... THE GOOD)/@comment-25196843-20141110195337/@comment-27588345-20141110205049

Actually, I love Scarlett mainly for that nutso side, but she's actually #6 in my TDPI character rankings, she would be higher if she showed that side for more than one episode. I like Shawn, Jasmine, Dave, Sammy/ Samey, and Ella more than her. I think the major reason people like her, is because she was the season's "true villain", even though this season actually had no main villain, that goes for Dave too. Just because a character went insane in the last few minutes of an episode does not classify them as a major villain, maybe just a minor one, but not a major one. We don't call Izzy a villain, do we? Also, Scarlett was boring, but she was 10 times better than Topher, the guy who somehow made it 8 episodes, without doing crap.

Also guys, if you're to call out Dave for his crap in the finale, you might as well call out Scarlett for trying to blow up a whole island, trying to murder 5 innocent teens, attempting to murder her only friend, and why did she do this? Because she wanted a million dollars.

Sorry if I sound like I'm hating on her, I really don't, but part of a fan's job is to critique the characters they like.