Thread:Greenhatdigital/@comment-1037137-20140618030010

Okay, I read earlier that apparently the directors still aren't talking about this scene, and yet they have 'plans' for it?

Well that to me feels like a red flag. Personally I think it's really unfair how they keep leaving us hanging on this sort of thing. First the third season ending which really left things semi-ambiguous, and now this? We have no idea when any of the eight of the other six even are going to make a reappearance Ms. Giles, are we really going to be forced to wait what could be years before we see any of them reemerge alright? How is that fair?

Given the dissatisfactory note most of them left on due to this season's overall poor storytelling and lack of closure, I can't imagine what makes them think that such a sendoff is okay. We were given no cause to suspect that we would not be able to see the full peanut gallery in the finale, something we've always been allowed since the first season. And such a scene is just bizarre and to be frank, unfunny. Who wanted to see that?

I'm sorry but with all due respect ma'am, regardless of what plans they have or what their intentions were, this still seems a silly and unwarranted scene and it leaves too many big questions that we're presumably not gonna get answers for for a while. I don't know why such a scene made it into the finale, but this was a highly inappropriate sendoff. I mean there's keeping things open-ended for future installments.......and then there's this, going to an extreme like this particular instance. No closure whatsoever, and nothing to keep us sated for who knows how long we'll have to wait for any further word or reappearance of them.

I'm sorry, but there's simply no defense for how far this went. It was an inappropriate note to end on along with the other events of the finale, and for the directors to openly leave an entire fandom hanging on this note for what I suspect will be a long time is not fair to most who are watching.

I'm personally very frustrated that such a card was played on us a second time around. Whatever the mindset behind it, this was not a fair note to leave the majority on, especially given the considerable amount of distaste for how the overall season progressed and concluded.

I would very much hope that we get more answers some time in the near future, because fans should not have to wait what could be years to finally get some light shone on this bothersome question and scene. 