User blog comment:Haloking7410/what i think about the past 5 seasons of total drama/@comment-23995441-20140222060403

TDI - Overrated season, seriously it wasn't that good. Most fans like only because of nostalgia. It's too slow-paced, Owen didn't deserve to make it to the merge let alone win over Gwen. Who actually had a plot, Owen was like Cody in TDWT where he made it far without doing much. Trent was bland, his whole character centered around Gwen. While Heather was sort of a good antagonists, after rewatching the season she depended on luck too much. I mean if Cody never got mauled she would have been eliminated in the paintball episode, if the Gophers never found out about Beth's tiki doll she would have been eliminated in the cooking challenge, in the episode where Trent's eliminated she had to randomly have had the immunity pass in her bag. And most of the time she would have been eliminated had she not won immunity. So yeah IMO, Heather is better as a protagonist/antihero like she was in TDWT. TDI is just plain mediocre.

TDA was good, it improved the bland mediocre disaster that is TDI. It had the most shocking eliminations, underused characters like Beth, Courtney, Harold, Justin were given more depth, An awesome final two, etc. The only problem was Owen returning in the final 5.

TDWT improved upon that too. By giving us two new contestants I liked Alejandro he was a very strong antagonist [better than Heather, Justin and Courtney combined] even if he was a bit of a Gary Stu. He caused the most eliminations out of any contestant but I didn't like him for it because he came off too perfect but I thought his attraction to Heather was cute. It gave him more depth besides the fact that he's perfect at everything and comes from a family of talented super-geniuses. I actually liked the love triangle since Courtney got her karma and I like Gwuncan even if it did start from cheating. You could tell that they really loved one another.

TDROTI. Had interesting characters but most of it's episodes are forgettable and I hated the Man vs Man finale. Mediocre.

TDAS. TERRIBLE!