User blog comment:Epic~00/Why Total Drama All Stars Was Such An Abysmal Season (PART 6)/@comment-27013391-20150328015340/@comment-31556666-20150328133137

Scott is his Revenge of the Island self in All-Stars, but with certain traits showcased more. As for the first 2 episodes, he was villainous in 1 moment in Evil Dread. Other than that, he had a bunch of humor (cowering in fear in confessional, hit in the face with shovel, etc.) And that moment where he was villainous served a purpose in introducing Mal, not to mention that was just Scott trying to win. It's nothing major.

And "turning into a dumba**"? Scott has always been dumb. He's been good with strategy and all, but that's not connected to his lack of street smarts that have been evident in both seasons.