User blog comment:Stryzzar/Who is the Greatest Antagonist?/@comment-3410066-20140606173545

I prefer Heather as a character to Alejandro, as her arc was a truly beautiful story (that was ruined by her appearances in TDRI and TDAS), but her stratergy was terrible. If it wasn't for that random piece of cake she gave Owen, she would have gotten the boot in episode 5 of Total Drama Island, she got through most of that season soley on luck.

Where did she get that peice of cake from? She wasn't willing to go get food in Paintball Deer Hunter from Chef's kitchen, and she obviously didn't send Lindsay or Beth to get it, as they act like they've never snuck into Chef's kitchen before when she asks them to get food in Paintball Deer Hunter. So did she bring it with her? Who knows.

If it wasn't for luck (i.e. Cody getting mauled by a bear, Beth's tiki doll, her getting the invincibilty pass in her chest in Wawanakwa Gone Wild! DJ's automatic elimination, the Guys Alliance not voting her off for some reason, everyone stupidly voting for Goeff over her, etc.) she would have gone multiple times.

The best antagonist is Alejandro, his stratergy was perfect, he didn't simply annoy people by reading their diaries like Heather, he actually used ruthless methods that contestants didn't realise were in play until they'd already taken the Drop of Shame. Based on stratergy alone, Al got to Awww, Drumheller! Luck saved his butt there, but other than that he was a generally great antagonist.