User blog comment:MegamanZero0002/Second All-Stars Speculation and Potential Ideas/@comment-4557745-20140418192911/@comment-1376932-20140419100508

Honestly, I would want to see Eva, Noah, Katie, and Sadie again. These may not be the most developed characters but that doesn't mean there's not room for improvement. Noah is already highly appreciated by a large part of the fanbase, and Eva has a lot of potential. She's one of the strongest female characters on the show and has formed quite a few strong friendships in the episodes that she actually gets screentime.

That being said, you're right about the losers not producing enough ratings. However, if the show is brave enough to introduce two new casts (and Pahkitew Island has been confirmed to be cameo-free, which means we won't be seeing the classic competitors for a whole season), then I'm sure bringing back some underdogs wouldn't be a huge deal. It's all about the way they market things, and even though Total Drama has a habit of keeping the popular characters around longer to please the audience, I wouldn't be too surprised if they're considering bringing back the less popular ones for another shot at the million.