Thread:BarBar/@comment-1734566-20150507222158/@comment-1734566-20150508201356

Hmm...speaking only of the contestants that I've seen in action (and with your non-S31 pick criteria in mind)...I'm kinda iffy on this whole list, TBH. Vince and Nadiya as Heroes? J'TIA as a Hero? The only Hero I really agree with, TBH, is Eddie. :p

And the Villains...I can understand Morgan and Joaquin, OK...but Papa Bear? Really? Leif is kind of a tossup too - he was more of a wish-washy flip-flopper, not a villain, IMO.

Again, I think your list is really scraping the bottom of the barrel because of your own criteria. When I made my HvV 2 list, I DIDN'T have criteria - past returnees, past winners all welcome. Again, my original HvV 2 list was:

Heroes:

1.	Jud “Fabio” Birza 2.	Troy “Troyzan” Robertson 3.	Malcolm Freberg 4.	Denise Stapley 5.	Lisa Whelchel 6.	Carter Williams 7.	Jeff Kent 8.	Reynold Toepfer 9.	Vytas Baskauskas 10.	Spencer Bledsoe

Villains:

1.	Russell Hantz 2.	Brenda Lowe 3.	Marty Piombo 4.	Matthew “Sash” Lenahan 5.	Andrea Boehlke 6.	Abi-Maria Gomes 7.	Jonathan Penner 8.	Tony Vlachos 9.	Kassandra “Kass” McQuillen 10.	Max Dawson