User blog comment:Total Drama Wiki! Wars/Week of May 10, 2015/@comment-4742462-20150515014904/@comment-4742462-20150516031426

@BlueBarracuda555, That's ultimately a subset for why I thought he didn't deserve it, he was a blatant Villain Stu.

He was the first antagonist to dumb down the cast (even if there was a BS in-universe explanation), had no threats aside from Heather (not counting Noah who was quickly terminated), and he lucked out too many times (Heather did too in Island, but not this much). In other words, he was TOO perfect and gets too much love at times.