User blog comment:Fedora Kid/Moon Madness Review/@comment-460966-20131009113620/@comment-1734566-20131010165156

OK, so you've listed your problems. But you still didn't explain why they're problems, which is what I do. But at least it gives us something to debate. So let's go through it.

1. What about the beginning scene? I'll admit, it wasn't very strong, but there was nothing wrong with it, IMO.

2. Lack of Chef. OK, fair enough...but a TON of episodes have lacked Chef recently. So by your logic, a vast majority of TDWT and TDR episodes sucked then, right?

3. So you hate Scottney. Some people (like me) love it. So that's just a matter of characters/interactions you don't like.

4. Yes, the challenge was very simple. But boring? Heck no. The setting made up for the simplicity of the challenge in how awesome/epic it was. And even then, can you criticize an episode for having a simple challenge? The very first episode of TDI was jump off a cliff. Big whoop. Must've sucked then, right?

5. Again, it's just because you hate Mike/Zoey, while some (like me) love it. Not a reason to hate the episode itself.

6. Have you forgotten about their friendship? Of course they're going to talk to each other.

7. Seriously? ._. Chris watches a TON of challenges from the sidelines. TDA? TDWT?

8. Heather was faking it, OMG. That was the point. >_>

9. and 10. Fine. I will concede that Duncan was probably at his absolute stupidest in this episode, and it seriously brings his character down in my book. Fair enough.

11. Once again, I concede. Courtney's denial of Gwen's friendly support is worsening her character as well.

12. Yeah. Mike totally would've been toast...had it not been for Cameron.

13. Yes. Although it was heavily built up in this season, it was handled very sloppily. The one redeeming factor was that Gwen was justified due to Duncan's stupidity, but seriously; the writers could have handled this a lot better.

14. YES. I. F***ING. HATE. NON. ELIMINATIONS. >_> We agree on this major Con.

15. In connection to Point 14. Once again, we agree. A sad repeat of the same formula as TDR.

16. Yes, that much is obvious...but every season has had at least one double elimination since TDI. So what? Does a double elimination automatically make a season suck?