User blog comment:Smv21/My Total Drama Season Rankings/@comment-27607014-20180514183352/@comment-25342388-20180515172904

"Derailment" may have been the wrong choice of words but I just most of the time don't like when shows do that. Dave may have always been a bit of a jerk but he legitmately loved Sky, had a good friendship with Shawn, saved Ella from drowning and most of his rude behavior early on was justified (who wouldn't be a stick-in-the-mud on a team woth the likes of Leonard and Beardo). Starting a character off as mildly sympathetic and then exaggerating their more unlikable qualities later on is bad writing. It was bad writing when they did it with Courtney and it is bad writing here as well.

Nearly all of the challenges in the series are dangerous. That still didn't make it any fun for me. I like creative challenges that keep you on the edge of your seat wondering who is going to win. This was just Chris doing his usual sadistic life threatening courses.

Skave's plot is overly mean spirited and toxic and really shows that it was produced at the same time as All Stars.

Actually I think we have every right to judge PI's cast and season the same way we would with others. If the cast are flat, one note gimmicks or just plain unlikable then how are we suppose to cate for them? Personally, the only characters I care for are Sky, Shawn, Jasmine and Ella. The others can just go away! Scarlett had potential to be a good villain but they butchered it by rushing her plot and making her come off as outright stupid during the last five minutes of her episode.