User blog comment:Scotteatingdirtfor12Hours/My thoughts on All stars/@comment-25342388-20180524235745/@comment-4742462-20180526010918

@DipDap, They were undeserving because they never went through any kind of development not even in their final episodes and outside of their friendship being briefly tested by the Ice Dancers they had no plot or storyline at all during the season (not even Brody's crush on MacArthur which only gets a rushed conclusion in the ending where Surfer Dudes win).

Say what you will about some of the other past finalists who some would argue didn't deserve to be, at least a random last minute reason was given for why they became such. Surfer Dudes had no such reason other than the belief that they were brought back in by order of the network to have more males for the finale.