User blog comment:SteelWolf/Unpopular opinions/@comment-31556666-20150203104850

Despite how scathing I am to it, and even though it's my obvious least favorite season, TDAS is enjoyable TO WATCH, because at this point it just seems to be a guilty pleasure for me. The badness of it is classic now.

I think Samey is 10x more overrated than Noah, Dawn, Ella, or Cody. At least those characters have actually been called overrated. Samey is barely ever compelling, and she has a massive fanbase because she's.... nice?

I don't think Sierra is that amazing of a character. She was alright in WT, and awful in AS, something her fans even say. But why did she get so much fans in the first place? Sure she's likable and funny, but those are obvious components to a good character. She's not as funny as about 10 characters off the top of my head, and her jokes get really repetitive. Her wasted potential is also annoying, because instead of being creepy to all the cast, she's just creepy to Cody.

Justin is absolutely hilarious because his humor revolves around himself, something which he's popularly known for. I think he gets unjustified hate, which is why I'm calling him the most underrated character. I mean, look at the personality section on his page on this wiki, and then try and attempt to say that Justin lacks depth.

I think Anne Maria is a lot funnier than people give her credit for.

I think Scott was still in character in Total Drama All-Stars.

I'm glad that Lightning didn't get character development.

I thought, as an antagonist, Alejandro was more entertaining than Heather (she's still a better character though).

I find Duncan one of the most consistent characters, at least prior to AS.

I prefer Dave over Sky.

I prefer Zoey over Sky.

Based on the cast, I thought Topher lasting 8 episodes in PI made sense.