According to Chris, if you take anything from the island, "you would be cursed forever." However, Beth does not hear this warning because she is using the bathroom at the time he says this and takes a tiki idol from the island that she found in a bush. This causes a supposed curse on the Screaming Gophers with a losing streak that spans over the course of three episodes. Ultimately, her choice to take something off the island influences her team's decision to make her the next target of her team. When she is finally eliminated, the curse seems to disappear and the team's winning streak continues. After finding out about the curse and before being eliminated, she promises to return the tiki idol to Boney Island.In Trial by Tri-Armed Triathlon, it is revealed that Beth did not return the idol as promised, but instead broke it into three pieces and flushed it down the septic tank, which leaves the campers disgusted. The final six campers are tasked to collect the idol and toss the pieces into the Cave of Treacherous Terror. When the campers reach the cave on the island, some face problems relating to the creatures that reside on the island. In the cave, Owen is scared away by a spider and drags Heather along with him. Leshawna and Duncan are chased off by a pack of woolly beavers that show up in the cave. Geoff and Gwen end up tossing the doll into the cave, resulting in their win for that part of the challenge.
Boney Island makes its first appearance since Trial by Tri-Armed Triathlon in Runaway Model, where ten campers (one of them as an intern) have to save Lindsay from Sasquatchanakwa. During this episode, it is also revealed that Chris is turning the island into his own private resort, which explains the scaffolding that Sasquatchanakwa and Lindsay are on top of. However, most of the construction workers of the project are dead, presumably due to the wildlife of the island.
Boney Island plays a more significant role in the fifth season, as one member from the winning team is exiled to the island for a night. Despite having to fend for themselves against wild animals and struggling to find food, the exile does have one upside: a McLean-Brand Chris Head hidden somewhere on the island. Once the campers reach the merge, exile duty is appointed twice more before being stopped as of Sundae Muddy Sundae. Lightning holds the distinction of being the first competitor to go on exile, while Gwen is the first female as well as the last overall.
The Fun Zone is a closed off area of Boney Island which serves to isolate the mutated flora and fauna from the previous season. Surrounding it is large trees with a stone entrance and metal sliding door. Nothing can travel in or out of the Fun Zone without someone authorized opening it. The Fun Zone is the location of the challenge in No One Eggspects The Spanish Opposition. It is revealed later in the episode to be the hiding place for the aforementioned McLean-Brand Chris Head. As seen in the exclusive clip of Zeek And Ye Shall Find, this is now the home of Ezekiel, who lives in harmony with his fellow mutants.
- Total Drama Action, Total Drama World Tour, and Total Drama: Pahkitew Island are currently the only seasons in which Boney Island does not make an appearance.
- Eva, Noah, Justin, Katie, Tyler, Blaineley, Staci, B, and Dawn are the only contestants from the first two casts to never visit Boney Island.
- Gwen and Scott visit Boney Island more times than any other contestant, with four times each.