The class lone wolf accidentally brought a toy from their past. Worried that this will completely changed how their classmates will feel about them, the lone wolf must make sure that their toy must not fall into anyone else's hands.






Voice actor Role(s)
Deven Mack Chef Hatchet
Sarah Gadon Beth
Emilie-Claire Barlow Courtney
Drew Nelson Duncan
Lilly Bartlam Gwen
Katie Crown Izzy
Christian Potenza Jude
Cory Doran Noah
Scott McCord Owen
  • Bridgette, Cody, Harold, and Leshawna appear, but have no lines, however, Cody can be heard screaming.
  • A younger version of Geoff makes a cameo in the slot machine, but has no lines.
  • Two people speak in a commercial but it is unknown who voiced them.



  • When the kids choose a friend for "Partner playtime", a child version of Geoff can be brief seen for a second.



  • The title is a reference to the quote, "Stay gold, Ponyboy. Stay gold." from the 1967 novel, The Outsiders.


  • The episode's description from the Cartoon Network website says that Gwen brought a pink stuffed pony with her to the daycare but she actually brought a pink stuffed poodle with her.


See also

Total DramaRama episodes
Venthalla | Duck Duck Juice | Cluckwork Orange | Free Chili | The Date | Aquarium for a Dream | Cuttin' Corners | Sharing is Caring | Ant We All Just Get Along | Germ Factory | Cone in 60 Seconds | The Bad Guy Busters | That's a Wrap | Tiger Fail | A Ninjustice to Harold | Having the Timeout of Our Lives | Hic Hic Hooray | Bananas & Cheese | Inglorious Toddlers | Not Without My Fudgy Lumps | Paint That a Shame | Snots Landing | Know it All | A Licking Time Bomb | From Badge to Worse | Snow Way Out | All Up In Your Drill | Toys Will Be Toys | Stay Goth, Poodle Girl, Stay Goth | Gum and Gummer | Invasion of the Booger Snatchers | Wristy Business | Melter Skelter | The Never Gwending Story | There Are No Hoppy Endings | Too Much of a Goo’d Thing | The Price of Advice | Mother of All Cards | Duncan Disorderly | Soother or Later | Camping is In Tents | Mutt Ado About Owen | Simons Are Forever
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.